Financial Times 12,922 by Crux
Posted by Gaufrid on November 11th, 2008
Rishi is usually an early poster so I think it is safe to assume by now that he is unable to join us today. I have therefore produced this relatively brief substitute blog. Nothing too difficult in this puzzle except perhaps 26d where the checked letters (_e_s) were of little help. 4a appears to be flawed and I’m not particularly happy with 17d, as explained below.
Across
1 THEORY OR in THEY
4 BREACHED R in BEACHED – no containment indicator for the ‘R’
9 ATHENA hidden in ‘sunbATHE NAked’ – the Greek goddess of wisdom amongst other things
10 CONTRITE CON TRITE
12 CHOW MEIN CHOW (dog) MEIN (‘my’ in German)
13 CHEESE cd
15 EPIC *(PIEC[e])
16 SUTHERLAND dd – Graham Sutherland, artist, and Sutherland the region in Northern Scotland. If the clue had been ‘She paints’ instead of ‘He painted’ it would have been an &lit since Wendy Sutherland is a Highland based landscape artist (though less well known than Graham)
19 WENDY-HOUSE cd – Wendy Darling, the daughter in Peter Pan
20 USED hidden reversal in ‘handmaDE SUits’
23 STREAM ST REAM
25 SEAQUAKE cd
27 ELICITED ELI CITED
28 SIENNA *(INSANE)
29 NONSENSE NON SENSE
30 ASTRAY AS[h]TRAY
Down
1 TRANCHE RANCH in T[roubl]E
2 ETHIOPIAN *(PIANO THE I)
3 RENAME *(MEN ARE)
5 ROOK dd
6 ANTI-HERO ANTI HER O
7 HEINE [t]HE [l]INE – Heinrich Heine, German poet
8 DEEP END PEN in DEED
11 SIT-UPON U in *(POINTS)
14 CHASTEN C[hemistry] HASTEN
17 ABSTAINER cd – I’m not sure I agree with the ‘in more ways than one’. Chambers defines a party-pooper as ‘someone who spoils the enjoyment of others at a party or social occasion by their lack of enthusiasm or unwillingness to participate’. COED is more succinct, ‘a person who casts gloom over social enjoyment’. An ‘abstainer’ is a person who doesn’t drink alcohol and so *might* be consideded dull by those who are under the influence but this is not always the case, some people are quite lively when sober. S/he can also a person who doesn’t vote thus possibly displeasing other members of a (political) party, but this is not supported as ‘party-pooper’ in the dictionary definitions. Thus it is only possible to equate ‘abstainer’ with ‘one who is unwilling to participate’ (unless, of course, I have missed something).
18 DYNAMITE *(IT MAY END)
19 WESTERN WE STERN
21 DIETARY ET in DIARY – ‘et’ can be ‘extraterrestrial’ (Chambers) or *that* film character again! Why can’t we have a change, such as ‘Journal about emergent technology initially concerned with food’ or ‘Journal about the beginnings of emergent technology relating to food’?
22 EQUIPS [rud]E QUIPS
24 REIGN G in REIN
26 SEAS homophone of ‘seize’ (appropriate)
November 11th, 2008 at 7:33 pm
Yes, a nice assortment of answers but no real penny-droppping moments along the way. (Although I did had to confirm 16A post-completion.)
17D is a little tenuous, but didn’t make me foam at the mouth and – on balance – I’d allow it to pass muster on the grounds of lateral thinking.
My quibble of the day is 1A; to my mind, either the definition suggests a verb, or “reveal” need to be “reveals” to allude to the wordplay.
Re: Extra Terrestrial overkill. Hear, hear!
November 11th, 2008 at 11:10 pm
First cryptic I ever tried to solve. Only got 13A and 28A without help. Don’t know how experienced solvers would rate this puzzle but I was left a little non-plussed even after checking the answers.
November 12th, 2008 at 4:01 am
Congrats on dipping your toe into the water, Daniel. Come on in, the water’s fine, and hopefully we’ll have you solving an entire puzzle unaided before the year is out. :>
Do have a stab at Wed’s FT- it’s probably more accessible and user-friendly puzzle for a novice solver.