Never knowingly undersolved.

Independent 7222/Punk

Posted by John on December 8th, 2009


Punk has clearly been very clever getting all those 13 24s in, but unfortunately I’m not the person to appreciate all his subtleties. Most of this seemed very good, but the odd one is a closed book. No doubt there are plenty of readers who will be very happy to explain things to me, like a child patiently showing a grandparent how to use the latest technology.

Another thing that made it particularly hard was all those cross-references: when you’re starting and can’t see what’s going on, the number of accessible clues is much diminished.

1 GREASE — ref. Sandy in Grease
4 S(ABBA)TH — I think this is how it works, with sth a rather unusual point; ref. Black Sabbath, a heavy metal band, also of course Abba
9 MOTORHEAD — another heavy metal band in some way connected with Rush
10/30 JUDAS PRIEST — which is a heavy metal band, but the rest of it is beyond me.
11/21 LEAD SINGER — lead is a weight on a line when fishing, but I don’t quite get the way it’s put; ‘bass perhaps’ is singer (“base”); ref.
12 DEE{lam}P PURPLE — a heavy metal band
14 PULLED TO PIECES — Led [Zeppelin] in (people is cut)*
18 CONVERSATIONAL — (carnations love)* — I’m less than comfortable with the definition, which is presumably ‘it’s said’, and that doesn’t seem to me to equate to ‘conversational’
22 IRON MAIDEN — well it’s this heavy metal band, but the wordplay???
27 G HOST — host=present? — there is an obsolete sense ‘sacrificial victim’, but I doubt it’s this
28 ILL AT EASE — 1 late in (sale)*
29 RED FLAG — 2 defs — standard as in we’ll keep the red flag flying
1 GYMSLIPS — “Jim’s lips” — ref. Jim Morrison
2 EXTRA — 2 defs, ‘One’s part little’ referring to film extras, and ‘more’
3 SORT — 2 defs
4 SODA POP — (pad o)rev. in sop
5 BIJOUTERIE — jo{b} in (Beirut)* ie
6 ADD UP — (pud DA)rev.
7 HOSIER — her around (1 so)rev.
8 DESERT — 2 defs
13/24 HEAVY METAL BAND — lead pronounced in two ways
15 LO 0
16 EON — one with its bottom letter raised
17 grievinG LAD DESTined
20 A G(E)OLD — if English is gilt it’s in gold
25 A MAZE — mazes are sometimes in gardens with hedges (but there are plenty of mazes that aren’t)
26 STAR — 2 defs

7 Responses to “Independent 7222/Punk”

  1. sidey says:

    Morning John, I’m glad I don’t do blogging.

    22a is a reference (definition?) to this

    27a Present in the sense of presenting a TV show I think.

    I agree that not all mazes are hedged however I can’t think of any other puzzles apart from mazes that are hedged. Seemed like a good clue to me.

    I think the Fish in 11/21 is this chap as an example of a lead singer.

  2. IanN14 says:

    I think 9ac. is “motor” = “rush”, the capital just giving an allusion to the band.
    And 10/30 ASP (killer)+R(ight) inside DIE (stop) inside JUST (suitable – I know, not the best definition…).
    Good puzzle, though, for those around my age, if not musical tastes…

  3. NealH says:

    Very tricky, but quite satisfying (not least because I both finished it and understood everything eventually).

    It took me an age to figure out the wordplay for Judas Priest – I could see just, asp and r in it but struggled to put it all together. 1 across was the last one I got: one of those where I thought all along the answer must be Grease or Greece but didn’t put it in because I couldn’t see why. Only when I’d finished everything else did it dawn on me that Sandy might be the name of a character in the musical.

  4. Ali says:

    I thought I was in for a torrid time with this one on first look and often have problems with puzzles with multiple connected answers, but eventually got Deep Purple from the checking letters and worked back from there. Never been a grebo myself, but am familiar with all the bands, so once the theme was cracked, I polished it off pretty quickly (admittedly without stopping to check the wordplay in a lot of the band clues)

    Overall, a hugely enjoyable puzzle, and classic Punk. The ‘lead’ connection with heavy metal is inspired, as is the tricksy use of ‘Fish’.

  5. nmsindy says:

    Not overly familiar with those bands, tho I heard heard of most of them without knowing they were HMBs but got there in the end. Some nice touches as always from Punk.

  6. Joins says:

    This was plain sailing for those of us brought up on NWOBHM bands. Loved the AMAZE clue.

  7. Al Streatfield says:

    What does NWOBHM mean…?

    Was teenager at the start of heavy metal, but didn’t really like it, preferring stuff like Pink Floyd, King Crimson, Soft Machine etc. In my opinion, (based, admittedly, on limited knowledge- don’t think I have heard Judas Priest…) the only bands mentioned that were musically interesting were Led Zeppelin, the Doors (although I think it is a bit of a travesty to call the Doors a heavy metal band…) and, occasionally, Deep Purple (Concerto for Group and Orchestra is worth a listen with its Stravinsky-esque composition, but doesn’t really bear repeated listening).

Leave a Reply

Don't forget to scroll down to the Captcha before you click 'Submit Comment'

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

9 − = five