Guardian 25,064 / Araucaria
Posted by Gaufrid on July 16th, 2010
I thought that this was going to be relatively easy today having entered quite a few answers during the first pass through the clues. However, the remainder of the puzzle proved problematic in places and there are still some clues that I cannot adequately explain.
I am uncertain as to the intention in 23ac but cannot see an alternative. I think the first part of my explanation for 11dn is correct but I cannot be 100% sure (pun intended). I have been unable to come up with a rational explanation for 20dn, I’m hoping that someone will help me out here. Edit: 23ac has now been resolved thanks to molonglo’s comment #4.
For me, an enjoyable start but a degree of frustration at the end.
Across
1 MUCILAGE *(GUM ALICE) – ‘gum’ doing double duty as the definition and part of the anagram fodder.
5 ABLAZE AB (sailor) LAZE (take no action)
9 HANGNAIL *(GHANA NIL)
10 DUGOUT DUGO[ng] (marine beast mostly) UT (note)
12 WHOLE W (with) HOLE (gap)
13 SHIPSHAPE cd&d
14 DIVORCE COURT *(REOCCUR) in DIVOT (piece of turf)
18 HEAVY POLLING V (very) *(PLOY) in HEALING (therapy) – is there such a phrase?
21 ASPARAGUS ASP (snake) SUGAR A reversed
23 TRACE dd – at least I assume this was the intention. If the clue is split after ‘bit’ the ‘of horse’ makes no sense as a second definition. If it is split before ‘bit’ it is still inaccurate because a ‘trace’ is a strap attached to a horse’s collar or breast-strap, not the ‘bit’ that goes in its mouth. Or is ‘horse’ being used in its drug sense to give a simple, single definition? Edit: thanks to molonglo I now see that it is ‘a little bit’ and ‘horse’ as in trace-horse.
24 EMBARK ME (setter) reversed BARK (his word)
25 DIABETIC DI (princess) ABET (assist) IC[e] (a lot of diamonds)
26 ROYALS dd – a reference to the Blues and Royals.
27 CEREBRAL CERE (apply wax) BRA (support) L (student)
Down
1 MOHAWK MO (doctor) HAWK (belicose type)
2 CENSOR CE (church) NS (partners) OR
3 LONGEVITY ON (continuing) G (gravity) in LEVITY (lack of it {gravity})
4 GAINSBOROUGH GAINS (wins) BOROUGH (urban seat) – a town in Lincolnshire (11).
6 BLUES d&cd – Gainsborough’s painting ‘The Blue Boy’ and a censor’s blue pencil give two blues, hence the plural.
7 ABOMASUM A BOM[b] (nearly a lot of money) A SUM (12 {whole}) – the fourth or true stomach of ruminants, lying close to the omasum.
8 ENTREATY E N (directions) TREATY (agreement)
11 LINCOLNSHIRE cd – Lincolnshire is divided into various ‘Ridings’ including the North, South and West Riding of Lindsey. The Ridings are further subdivided into several wapentakes or ’hundreds’. The abbreviation for Lincolnshire is Lincs. which is a homophone of ‘links’, a seaside golf course which gives its name to a type of golf (as currently being played on the St Andrew’s Old Course), hence the ‘briefly golf, say’.
15 CONSTABLE CON (study) STABLE (horses) – I assume that, apart from benefiting the surface, ‘force’ has been included as an allusion to a rank in the police force since I am not aware of Constable having painted a waterfall (are there any in Suffolk?).
16 WHEATEAR HEAT (temperature) in WEAR (erosion)
17 PALPABLY PAL (friend) PABL[o] (Picasso with no love) Y[our]
19 CASTER d&cd – if ‘caster’ is ‘donned’ it becomes ‘Doncaster’, the Yorkshire racecourse where the Lincoln Handicap is run (‘home to the 11′). Until 1965 the race was known as the Lincolnshire Handicap.
20 PENCIL ??? – I’m not sure. If ‘take’ had been ‘make’ I would have said that this was *(LINE PC) or even simply a dd. Alternatively it could be a multiple definition with ‘pencil’ being used in one or more of its following senses: “something long, fine and narrow in shape” (line?), “a fine paintbrush” (15 might take?), “the art of painting or drawing” or “an artist’s individual style or technique in drawing” (line 15 might take?).
22 RURAL R (right) UR (old city) AL (others)
July 16th, 2010 at 9:50 am
Many thanks Gaufrid.
There were too many odd clues and solutions for my liking.
July 16th, 2010 at 9:57 am
Thanks Gaufrid,
I agree, some clues here I don’t fully understand, but an interesting puzzle.
18ac – was clear enough from the cluing, but it is hardly a common phrase
I took the def. of 4dn. to be “seat in Lincolnshire”, which it is (MP – Edward Leigh). Uncle Yap has in the past complained of the parochialism of some clues – I think that this one definitely falls into that category.
July 16th, 2010 at 9:58 am
Well if Gaufrid had problems…
July 16th, 2010 at 10:49 am
Thanks Gaufrid. This was fun and mostly plain sailing with the splendid 11d giving some sort of theme. 1a helped get 4d, and then 15d: but weren’t both of them Suffolk men who never painted in 11d? The NE corner proved tricky and checking was needed for the UT in 10a, and drudgery required to get the last, 7d. I wasn’t too bothered with TRACE – it’s a little bit, and a horse – or PENCIL – writer/chief inspector/line … or something like that. Araucaria has earned a lot of leeway.
July 16th, 2010 at 11:02 am
Hi molonglo
I now see 23ac thanks to your comment. I wasn’t aware that there was such a thing as a trace-horse. However, I don’t follow your reference to ‘chief inspector’ for 20dn.
July 16th, 2010 at 11:04 am
Thanks Gaufrid. You can well imagine that the parochialism harry@2 referred to caused me problems. “Hundreds into ridings”, Lincs, Royals and Blues etc. mean nothing to me. I was happy to accept PENCIL as *(Line PC) as you suggest and a trace is close enough to the bit and it makes a nice clue so I let that one slide as well. I liked the cluing for Doncaster, but wish I understood the connection to 11. (I thought it must have had something to do with a football team.) I agree with molonglo that Araucaria deserves some leeway and I enjoyed the puzzle overall.
July 16th, 2010 at 11:28 am
7 definitely a dictionary word; and so, for its horse meaning was 23 – last to go in and I guessed it. 9 was naughty. I lived in 11 for a few years – in West Lindsey! – it didn’t help. It’s all Districts now. But it did help with 4, since I’ve been there. I also thought I’d been to Caster there – but I it turned out to be Caistor.
July 16th, 2010 at 11:31 am
Re 18ac – after long involvement with local elections, I have heard the term ‘Heavy Polling’ (usually in the context of queues at polling stations). But it’s hardly common parlance except among election geeks and us politicos.
July 16th, 2010 at 11:32 am
I forgot to add – and I didn’t get the answer!
July 16th, 2010 at 12:04 pm
Thanks, Gaufrid. I found this pretty difficult and didn’t understand the wordplay at 19dn, 20dn, 10ac and 23ac or the convolutions of 11dn. Much recourse to the check button!
July 16th, 2010 at 12:39 pm
I’m not a politico, but “heavy polling” was a perfectly familiar phrase to me. I didn’t make the “Lincs” connection so was mystified by the golf reference, but the solution was clear enough from the linked clues.
July 16th, 2010 at 12:51 pm
Thanks, Gaufrid, for the explanations. I found this quite a toughie, and eventually gave up with 7d and 13a unsolved. I even thought of SHIPSHAPE for ‘neat’, but couldn’t see the cd. Very clever.
I have heard ‘heavy polling’ during election coverage, so it is a known and used phrase, although in a specific context. Nothing wrong with that, though.
I eventually got LINCOLNSHIRE for 11d, but with absolutely no idea why. Like 13a, it’s a cd of an unusual sort for cryptic crosswords. No complaints about that, although both defeated me today.
Ref comment 2, I think in 4d BOROUGH is ‘urban seat’, so the def is ‘in 11d’ (which Gainsborough is).
I had a suspicion that someone in literature had a horse famously called Trace, but can’t pin it down. Am satisfied with trace-horse though, although it’s a new term on me.
Phew, need a brain shower now.
(Can’t wait until we can discuss this month’s Genius, which was an absolute joy.)
July 16th, 2010 at 12:52 pm
Oh, forgot to say that I took ‘Force painter’ in 15d to be two separate definitions to help the solver along. Not sure how valid this is.
July 16th, 2010 at 1:08 pm
Hi harry @2 and otter @12
The wordpay in 4dn has to be ‘urban seat’ = BOROUGH since ‘urban’ on its own is an adjective whereas ‘borough’ is a noun and the two do not equate. For ‘borough’ Chambers gives “a town that sends representatives to parliament” which, for me, is an ‘urban seat’.
July 16th, 2010 at 1:23 pm
This was extremely difficult for me, and I didn’t get very far (thanks to Gaufrid for explaining many things).
Perhaps PENCIL is something to do with the “thin blue line”?
July 16th, 2010 at 1:34 pm
Yes, quite a slog, but with some enjoyment along the way – HANGNAIL was very nice, and I liked North/South as partners. Having put CLOSE for 12a (which seemed suitably Araucarian), I was stymied in the NW, but MOHAWK forced my hand and the simpler WHOLE fell into place, which still failed to help with ABOMASUM – brain-dead by then I think. Shame about DI and BRA.
July 16th, 2010 at 1:44 pm
Ah yes. Forgot to mention the return of ‘support’.
July 16th, 2010 at 2:45 pm
Hi Mr Jim @ 15
“Perhaps PENCIL is something to do with the “thin blue line”?”
The site seems to be experiencing problems today and the comment I added earlier has disappeared (the database must have been restored to an earlier version) so I will type it again.
Interesting idea. I did check to see if a pencil-line might be manned by members of the Constabulary, even though I had never heard of one, but I could find nothing relevant.
If the link you suggest had been intended then I would have expected a reference in the clue to 6dn or its wordplay, but I could still be missing something.
On balance, I still favour a misprint for ‘take’. Had it been ‘make’ then there would have been at least a couple of valid parsings for the clue.
July 16th, 2010 at 3:50 pm
This was a dog’s breakfast.
I don’t want to be rude to the man – this was wholly unworthy of him. I do wonder about people who seem not to enjoy the head-scratching and bewilderment of cryptics, but this was a different thing altogether. There was barely a clue without some sort of failing.
July 16th, 2010 at 3:52 pm
Isn’t 20d just a simple anagram of line and PC = constable = 15?
July 16th, 2010 at 4:03 pm
Hi medici
As indicated in my analysis, this is a possibility but how can ‘might take with’, or any part of it, be an anagram indicator? As I have said, if ‘take’ had been ‘make’ there would have been no problem.
July 16th, 2010 at 4:16 pm
Hi Mister Sting @19
“There was barely a clue without some sort of failing.”
I think that is a gross exageration. The vast majority of clues were straightforward and fair (by Araucaria’s standards and many by normal standards), a couple needed a little thought to work out the wordplay, though it was possible in the end, and one (20dn) so far defies satisfactory (to me) explanation unless ‘take’ is a misprint.
July 16th, 2010 at 4:35 pm
Thanks Gaufrid, Araucaria et al.
After briefly wondering if I could get going at all, this went pretty well for me until I got stuck on 10a. and 7d. These took a long time and some fruitless faffing about until I actually saw the answers for myself – ‘ut’ in 10a came to mind to give dugout (and dugong) and I was then able to construct 7 from the clue and check it. This was pleasing in retrospect – I had begun to feel this would be my first uncompleted puzzle for a long time – but by then ‘aha’ was not a sentiment I could immediately muster!
Some nice clues. I assumed 9 is some reference to Ghana’s defeat in SA as a result of a Uruguyan handball foul – which led me astray looking for ‘hand’ words till I saw the anagram.
14 was also good with ‘divot’ harking back to the golf ref.
re 23. I felt like one or two others that ‘trace’ was close enough to ‘bit’ to do, and did not know trace-horse. I wonder if the ‘?’ after horse points at something less direct than an actual horse.
re 20d The anagram of ‘line PC (constable)’ = pencil (writer) seems simplest and best to me. ‘Take’ seems OK, and I read the might as a sort of anagrind.
24 ac. involves the idea of a shouted command I suppose.
19d was a clever clue. I assumed in my blissful ignorance it was still ‘The Lincolnshire’.
Heavy polling seems pretty standard to me, but I am not totally reliable on these things.
July 16th, 2010 at 4:43 pm
Hi tupu
“24 ac. involves the idea of a shouted command I suppose.”
Though your supposition works, I had intended to include a note in my analysis to the effect that I interpreted ‘his word’ as the communication method of a (Red, Gordon or Irish) setter.
July 16th, 2010 at 4:52 pm
Hi Gaufrid
Thanks – very nice, that went past me at the time. The exclamation mark led me to the command idea and inertia as usual set in.
July 16th, 2010 at 6:28 pm
Coincidentally, the Lincolnshire/Doncaster connection has just come up in a question on tonight’s “Weakest Link”.
July 16th, 2010 at 6:40 pm
Thanx Gaufrid
July 16th, 2010 at 6:41 pm
The weekend is not looking so good as A has cropped up today
July 16th, 2010 at 6:55 pm
Pencil seems to have bothered people but being older I found that easy …
The Censor used to take a blue pencil to anything improper in a book/play/film…
July 16th, 2010 at 6:56 pm
Re 20d In thé us anyway, to ‘Blue Pencil’ léans to censor.
July 16th, 2010 at 6:58 pm
… even odder that that explanation is under blues – but not under pencil ?
July 16th, 2010 at 7:14 pm
gareth and Gwhite
The censor’s blue pencil is not in doubt as indicaled in my analysis of 6dn. What is in question is the wordplay for 20dn, and ‘censor’ and/or ‘blue does not come into it..
The definition would appear to be ‘writer’ which leaves ‘Line 15 might take with’. As 15 is ‘Constable’ it could be an anagram of (LINE PC) but I do not see that ‘might take with’, or even part of this, can be an anagram indicator.
July 16th, 2010 at 7:15 pm
6 down is the link between censor censor and pencil
July 16th, 2010 at 11:29 pm
Hi Gaufrid
Re 20d. Sorry to bother further, but it is frustrating not to understand a relatively short clue with a clear answer. I must ultimately bow to your knowledge and experience, but I am still not sure there is no sense in the wording as it stands.
If one assumes that word order and punctuation are not sacrosanct in a clue, then one can generate something like
‘PC (15 constable) might take line with writer (pencil)’.
I don’t like it all that much but ‘with’ might then be taken as ‘in the case of’ (or similar
referential expression).
At a greater stretch it might be taken as a kind of hanging adverb like ‘along’ – in which case there might be a stop or hyphen to mark off a pause followed by ‘writer’ as self-standing definition.
July 16th, 2010 at 11:57 pm
Would someone enlighten me as to why UT = note ?
I put DUGOUT in, having twigged ‘dugong’, then decided it didn’t really work – I was expecting a note (one of A – G) in ‘dugon’. And anyway, a dugout is a boat, not a trench !
July 17th, 2010 at 12:20 am
Mr B – Ut is the old equivalent of ‘Do’ in solfege, relating to the notes of the scale in music. In Italian and French systems it represents the note C (useful for setters?), and in the English system the keynote of any major scale.
July 17th, 2010 at 12:36 am
Thanks Gaufrid.
I thought this was an excellent puzzle full of wit and invention and with a couple of Araucaria’s trademark “loose” clues – hence all the debate here.
As usual a lot of answers were easier to guess than to parse,but working out the wordplay is a lot of the fun.
I see your point re. 20 down but must admit that I spotted the anagram and didn’t think any deeper than that.
15 down – Like Otter I think “force painter” was two definitions,but to try to mislead, rather than aid, the solver.
I thought “heavy polling” was quite a familiar expression and the Lincoln Handicap is still known by punters as the Lincolnshire.
“Trace horse” is often used in pre 20th century novels and is also to be found in most English translations of the Iliad.
Favourite clues for me 13 and 14 across and 19 down.
July 17th, 2010 at 12:40 am
Thanks Martin – you live and learn !
July 17th, 2010 at 1:05 am
Have returned to these puzzles after many years absence – for me this was very difficult with 7 solutions missed. Much more problematic than Araucaria’s Prize puzzle last week which was easy by comparison. Hugely enjoyable though.
July 17th, 2010 at 6:47 am
HI Scarpia
re 20d. In the end I largely agree with you that it’s probably not worth trying to make too much sense – something about pig’s ears and silk purses I seem to remember.
July 17th, 2010 at 9:55 am
Phew. Bit of a slog for me, I’m afraid. Finally gave up on ABOMASUM & TRACE.
No one else seems bothered about 13ac. I’m happy that a ship can taper forwards and be blunt at the back, but how exactly does a ship taper downwards?
Sorry to be dim.
July 17th, 2010 at 11:55 am
Hi William
If you take a plan view of a ship’s hull it tapers towards the bow and is blunt at the stern. If you take a section through the hull, or view it in elevation, it tapers from the deck to the keel, ie \/ (but usually with curved sides).
July 17th, 2010 at 12:02 pm
Hi William ~ I guess the hull of a ship tapers from its beam to its keel.
July 17th, 2010 at 12:14 pm
oops! ~ messages crossed ~ should have refreshed the page before submitting. Sorry.
wrt 27a, Gaufrid, can cere be a verb as in “to apply wax” as you suggest or does it mean CERE (noun, the wax-like patch on a birds beak) added/applied to BRA L. Can’t find any reference to the verb thing.
July 17th, 2010 at 12:36 pm
Hi Roger
Yes, ‘cere’ can be a transitive verb. Chambers gives “to cover with wax; to wrap (a dead body) in cerecloth”.
July 17th, 2010 at 12:40 pm
Hmmm… took me longer to read all this than to do the puzzle
July 17th, 2010 at 1:35 pm
Thanks for that, Gaufrid. Not in my on-line version, though.
Bet Rufus wishes he’d thought of 13a. (But then perhaps he has, among his millions!).
July 17th, 2010 at 2:08 pm
Roger
The on-line version is Chambers 21st Century Dictionary which is not as comprehensive as the full Chambers 11th edition.