Comments on: Guardian Genius 101 / Brummie

By: Gordon

Gordon — Mon, 05 Dec 2011 23:14:15 +0000

I found the two ‘added’ categories frustrating; so I agree with Mr. Beaver. I suffered from this in that unlike everyone else it seems, I made a mistake with the answer to 20d. I had FLEDGE. I had Place = FL as a cheeky Brummie nod to one of the main categories of missing letters because this is another US state [and seemingly Brummie could have made this clue into a 6th US State if he had wanted]. Lip = edge [rather than ledge] and the answer was [r]ear = fledge. So the missing letter was an ‘R’ which is a direction [right] in my book.

I also found another possible missing element for 4d. RECTI is in the exact middle – i.e. HEART of DIRECTION. So the missing letters could be He [Helium] rather than P.

This was another reason that I did not like the puzzle as much as I felt I should, as it would not be difficult to construct other solutions for different missing letters. A little too sloppy for me.

I also struggled and failed to get my solution entered on Friday because of the technical issues mentioned by mhl.

Still, as I had the one mistake it did not matter.

Nice blog by the way – mhl

By: Trebor

Trebor — Mon, 05 Dec 2011 18:37:57 +0000

Another interesting Genius – Brummie seems to enjoy this taking letters out / adding letters in to the wordplay business. Got about 80% during my first session but never bothered returning to finish it off having worked out all the devices.
After a couple hours at this month’s (102) I fancy 80% completion might be a bit ambitious!

By: Jan

Jan — Mon, 05 Dec 2011 17:16:08 +0000

Thanks for the blog, mhl.

I was more confused than usual by this puzzle. It was a while before I realised and wrote …

‘Definition matches solution – clue needs extra letters.
Definition matches clue – solution needs extra letters.’

Were the extra letters IVRs, US States or chemical symbols and while SW was obvious, was I to use DM for decimetres or MS for milliseconds as measurements?

I convinced myself that it was IVRs and US states (not chemicals) and really couldn’t be bothered to re-collect my thoughts on completion.

9a Obviously the insect was BEE but then, with B_L_E was it to be BELEE, BELIE or BELLE? I opted for BELIE and Long Island. It’s not a state but it is in the US – I was getting bored!

I submitted my entry with doubts remaining so my enjoyment was dulled.

By: Judge

Judge — Mon, 05 Dec 2011 17:15:38 +0000

Minor typo – the answer to 26a should be TWEED, not TWEETED.

Great blog and I enjoyed the puzzle.

By: mhl

mhl — Mon, 05 Dec 2011 15:56:46 +0000

The crossword editor mentioned in the newsletter that just arrived that there were technical problems over the weekend with submissions to the Genius:

Our November Genius puzzle (No 101 set by Brummie) was hit by a late technical problem. At some point in the early evening of Friday 2 December the system for accepting the online entries broke down. It was not possible to discover the reason and fix the fault over the weekend, as those who tried to send in entries late on Friday and on Saturday will have discovered. The problem also affected the early birds tackling the December Genius No 102 by a new setter Qaos, uploaded today (Monday 5 December). Our apologies for this disruption, which will have been extremely vexing for those affected by it. We are working to restore normal service as soon as possible.

By: sidey

sidey — Mon, 05 Dec 2011 15:15:53 +0000

James, your progress is saved as a cookie or several. When you click ‘Save’ you should get a message confirming it.

By: dunsscotus

dunsscotus — Mon, 05 Dec 2011 14:38:54 +0000

Thank you Brummie and mhl. Happily, the IT side of things worked for me. I thoroughly enjoyed this challenge and was really chuffed to have finished it!

By: James

James — Mon, 05 Dec 2011 13:29:03 +0000

Thanks for the blog. I’ve recently encountered a problem with the online Genius site, in that it doesn’t save my work. Anyone else had this issue? Pretty frustrating, I can tell you!

By: sidey

sidey — Mon, 05 Dec 2011 10:05:36 +0000

I enjoyed what I managed to complete of this. Unfortunately I fell foul of the ridiculous requirement to log in to even view the puzzle, lost all my answers and gave up.

By: Mr Beaver

Mr Beaver — Mon, 05 Dec 2011 08:46:32 +0000

Thanks for the blog mhl. I agree, this was far from the hardest Genius crossword – the ‘straight’ clues were mostly fairly easy. But it was tricky getting started as you don’t know what variety of clue you’re dealing with. The ones with missing letters in the clue were trying – I think in every case we got the answer first then had to work back to find the missing letters.

I found it odd that two clues were in ‘groups’ on their own (17d and 20d) – particularly as the group names (14a and 18a) were plurals. I may be doing Brummie an injustice but it smacked of trying – and not quite succeeding – to get all the subtractions into two groups!

Still, we finished it, and that’s always a bonus for a Genius!