My thanks to Ho for this one as neither Hi nor Ba could do it. We found it much harder than Tennyson’s Maud and the poets a few weeks ago, though Ho didn’t!
There were Double Clues – two clues run together, the answers fitting in either of the two available symmetrical slots, and Single Clues which led to two answers. The answers to the Single Clues turned out to be clues in themselves which led to a second answer of the same length as the original. Again either answer could fit in either available slot and were not necessarily words.
It was all made more difficult by the number of unfamiliar words (about 8 requiring a dictionary check!). Complex, and a lot of jigsaw work to be done even if you could solve the clues!
There was a cross-check phrase, but I would have preferred a bit more guidance on the meaning of the term ‘unclued’ letters , which seems to mean letters from the secondary answers to the Single Clues which are not cross-checked. Our count of these letters was only 12, not 14 as in the rubric. They were made up of:
PN from RENNAPS, I from TIMER, NOI from NEOLITHI, PE from REPRESE, PP from PEOCPR and HR from NETROHS. This yields “IN ‘PP’ HORNPIPE, but I am at a loss to find the extra RN!
In the table relating to Double Clues below, the clue numbers have been reversed if the second answer fills the first space in the grid and vice versa. The answers and explanations are in order of the clues. The word after the split is indicated. A full grid can be found at the bottom for clarity.
Double Clues:
Across | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
No. | Answers | Split at | First half | Second half |
35,1 | ICILY/ROPES | guys | (S)ICILY | RES(ervation) round OP |
11,33 | EPOCHA/CHOREE | foot | COPE reversed + HA(rriers) | a trochee (foot!)CHORE + E |
32,12 | EPHA/COMA | company | Hidden in largE PHArmaceutical | CO + M + A |
30,14 | MOTEN/SET BY | appoint | Spenserian for may: MO(second) + TEN (XI – 1!!) | reserve: SET (appoint) + BY (handy) |
26,17 | ELMIER/ASSOTS | backing | [LIME]* + RE reversed | STOA reversed round SS |
25,19 | TOSS/REAP | gather | TO (closed) + S + S (societies) | REP (material) round A |
23,21 | SPURGES/SLEEKIT | glossy | GE in SPURS | LEEK in SIT(e) |
Down | ||||
No. | Answers | Split at | First half | Second half |
27,2 | EXCEL/OPENS | put | top: replace PT (gym) by L(eft) in EXCEPT (bar) | starts: O (protest in C but cry ??) + PEN (put inside) + S |
3,24 | POTASH/BIHARI | Indian | POT + [HAS]* (hit as anag. indicator??) | BI + [1 RAH] reversed |
21,6 | SEDUCES/ENSEALS | stamps | [CUSSED E]* | ENS (being) + [SALE]* |
29,7 | ONCE/MISO | notes | former: O(ld) + C in NE | MI + SO (notes) |
15,8 | BOAR-SPEAR/ICECREAMS | finishes | B + OARS + PEAR | ICES round CREAM |
20,9 | APOCOPE/EMBRAID | lace | A POPE round CO | [DIME]* round BRA |
In the table relating to the Single Clues the No. column indicates where the answer to the primary clue is to be placed. The secondary answer goes in the other position
Single Clues:
Across | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
No. | Answer | Explanation | Second Entry | Explanation |
5 | DEMIREP | shady character: PERI + MED all reversed | REPRESE | “Demi” REPRESENTATIVE |
31 | CUTBACK | BACK (support) after CUT | NETROHS | SHORTEN “back” |
28 | COP-OUT | excuse: COP + OUT | PEOCER | COPPER “out” |
Down | ||||
No. | Answer | Explanation | Second Entry | Explanation |
22 | TURNKEY | TURKEY round N | RENNAPS | “Turn” SPANNER |
4 | SHORTAGE | SHORE round TAG (to dog) | NEOLITHI | “Short” NEOLITHIC |
10 | PAY UP | discharge: PA + YUP | TIMER | REMIT “up” |
R | O | P | E | S | D | E | M | I | R | E | P |
E | P | O | C | H | A | N | I | C | O | M | A |
N | E | T | R | O | H | S | S | E | T | B | Y |
N | N | A | B | R | P | E | O | C | P | R | U |
A | S | S | O | T | S | A | N | R | E | A | P |
P | A | H | A | A | S | L | E | E | K | I | T |
S | P | U | R | G | E | S | O | A | B | D | U |
T | O | S | S | E | D | E | L | M | I | E | R |
I | C | O | P | O | U | T | I | S | H | X | N |
M | O | T | E | N | C | U | T | B | A | C | K |
E | P | H | A | C | E | C | H | O | R | E | E |
R | E | P | R | E | S | E | I | C | I | L | Y |
The ‘unclued letters’ are unchecked letters in the unclued answers plus the R and N where two unclued answers intersect.
I found this about as difficult as last week’s as far as filling the grid is concerned but I didn’t bother to look for all the obscure poets in that one, I just confirmed the ones listed in Bradford’s.
The Inquisitor has definitely got harder this year and is now often harder than the Listener.
Thank you for that Richard. The extra RN eluded us. I wasn’t clear why we had been given them anyway as they didn’t seem to help with solving the rest of the puzzle!
I didn’t get a single answer in this puzzle despite staring at it for a week. 🙁 So well done to Ho.
Didn’t find this much harder than average – solved a few pairs and a lone intersection (e.g. COMA + EPHA, and EMBRAID) and I was on my way. Some guesswork placing other entries, and things fell into place – maybe I got lucky.
I found this puzzle hard, but fair and fun. A variation on the standard Ximenes/Azed special “Left and Right” – with the bonus of clues to which the answers were wordplay in themselves. And the clueing was impeccable.
Thanks, “that nut, Meg”.
I have absolutely no complaints about the puzzle or the clues, which I agree were impeccable! Like kenmac, I just couldn’t do it – my fault not Nutmeg’s!