I think Kruger has set some tough puzzles in the past, but this week’s was comparatively easy. The wordplay in every clue had an extra letter not entered in the grid, and these spelt out a quotation, apart from two key words. The central square had to be completed with the last letter of the quotation, as given by Brewer’s Dictionary of Phrase and Fable.
I didn’t find anything too difficult with the clues, in fact they were quite easy, with a lot of anagrams and simple truncations. The surface readings were very good, with a number bringing a smile to my lips, especially 45ac, 53ac, 3dn and 49dn.
The unclued entries were fairly obviously, and I chose to look up DEVIL in Brewer’s first. This quickly led to DEVIL DICK as the nickname of Richard PORSON, but I couldn’t find anything by him in the ODQ. There was nothing much under Aeneas in Brewer’s, but the entry for Dido revealed all the details necessary. Apparently Richard Porson said he could make a rhyme on any subject, and when challenged to make one on the three Latin gerund endings, -di, -do, -dum, came up with what was spelt out by the extra letters in the clues:
When Dido found Aeneas would not come
She mourned in silence and was Di-do-dum(b)
And there at the end was the ‘optional’ letter B that was required in the central square of the grid.
Solving time: about 2 hours
Legend:
Definition in clue
ABC* = anagram
ABC< = reversal
abCDef = hidden
X = extra letters in wordplay
| ACROSS | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | W | PANDIT | Learned man put measuring rod into hole (6) WAND (measuring rod) in PIT (hole) |
| 5 | H | CUDWEED | Mistakenly deduce how nothing is lost in plant (7) (DEDUCE HOW)* – O (nothing) |
| 12 | E | ART | Award for drawing and painting (3) ARET (award) |
| 13 | N | MAILING LIST | Heartlessly, man in poor health has to lean over catalogue of addressees (11, two words) M(A)N AILING (in poor health) + LIST (lean over) |
| 14 | F | TRICORNS | Hats off to Francis — right to stand in for academician (8) [(TO FRANCIS) with R (right) for A (academician)]* |
| 16 | O | CHEDDAR | Mostly a tedious task carrying old books? Hard cheese! (7) CHOR(E) (mostly tedious task) carrying EDDA (old books) |
| 17 | U | HOTEL | Inn‘s not in use — in unfinished, miserable state (5) OUT (not in use) in HEL(L) (miserable state, unfinished) |
| 19 | AENEAS | Unclued | |
| 23 | N | NOON | Twelve in Japanese drama? No, French (4) NO (Japanese drama) + NON (no, French) |
| 24 | D | SKIER | Risked high lob (5) RISKED* |
| 25 | W | LAPPET | Start parking (with an offended feeling) in fold (6) LAW (start) + P (parking) + PET (offended feeling) |
| 27 | O | MIRE | Watered a bog (4) MOIRE (watered) |
| 28 | U | PROCEED | Pass on dodgy European produce (7) [E (European) + PRODUCE]* |
| 30 | L | GLOATED | Foolish person, left inside and under control, looked satisfied (7) GOAT (foolish person) with L (left) inside + LED (under control) |
| 32 | DICK | Unclued | |
| 33 | D | TARRAS | Dart around headland’s volcanic ash (6) DART* + RAS (headland) |
| 36 | N | LIERS | They adopt a horizontal position in large ships (5) LINERS (large ships) |
| 38 | O | ROTA | Round grub on top of azalea (4) ROOT (grub) + A (top of Azalea) |
| 44 | PORSON | Unclued | |
| 45 | T | TASER | Liking face of real stunner (5) TASTE (liking) + R (face, ie front, of Real) |
| 47 | C | GINGILI | Soldier slicing head off strange plant (7) GI (soldier) + ((S)LICING* |
| 48 | O | ENGRIEVE | Edmund’s to vex reeve — going almost crazy (8) [REEVE GOIN(G)]* |
| 50 | M | ENDOTHELIUM | Destroy male cat returning with gas in cell tissue (11) END (destroy) + TOM< + HELIUM (gas) |
| 51 | E | KIT | RAF aircraft’s equipment (3) KITE (RAF aircraft) |
| 52 | S | SLEIGHS | Harry, sightless, with no time for journeys over snow (7) [SIGHTLESS – T (time)]* |
| 53 | H | MEEKLY | Gently starts to make extra effort helping kids learn Yiddish (6) initials of Make Extra Effort (Helping) Kids Learn Yiddish |
| DOWN | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | E | PATHOS | Anticipate hospice has quality arousing pity (6) in anticiPATE HOSpice |
| 2 | M | ARROW | V-shaped mark in vegetable (5) MARROW (vegetable) |
| 3 | O | DUCE | Mussolini‘s sober when north of the border (4) DOUCE (sober, Scotland) |
| 4 | U | TAR | Sailor‘s cross with rector (3) TAU (cross) + R (rector) |
| 5 | R | CINEMA | Hideous carmine building exhibiting pictures (6) CARMINE* |
| 6 | N | DICED | Department’s friendly director took great risks (5) D (department) + NICE (friendly) + D (dirwctor) |
| 7 | E | EGEST | Discharge wild geese on time (5) GEESE* + T (time) |
| 8 | D | ELDIN | Designated driver enters organised line for fuel (5) DD (designated driver) in LINE* |
| 9 | DIDO | Unclued | |
| 10 | I | ISADORE | Woman is a Christian, possibly English (7) IS A DIOR (Christian, possibly) + E (English) |
| 11 | N | STRINE | Australian steamer in New England (6) STR (steamer) IN NE (New England) |
| 15 | S | SNAP | Bridges over small lock (4) SPANS< (bridges) |
| 18 | I | TRIO | Backing choir (Italian) is covering musical composition (4) in chOIR ITalian < |
| 19 | L | AGLEAM | Convict male criminal for flashing (6) LAG (convict) + MALE* |
| 20 | E | HECK | Jeer abusively when lecturer leaves — it expresses displeasure (4) HECKLE (jeer abusively) – L (lecturer) |
| 21 | N | TRET | Allowance for waste in river (4) TRENT (river) |
| 22 | C | NELSON | Hold lens broken by prisoner (6) LENS* + CON (prisoner) |
| 26 | E | TOLD | Informed US city’s not old (4) TOLEDO – O (old) |
| 27 | A | MAIN | Cockfighting match hurt animal — front part of leg being lost (4) [ANIMAL – L (front part of Leg)]* |
| 29 | N | RIOTING | Revelling in Indonesia, not in Gabon (7) RI (Indonesia) NOT IN G (Gabon) |
| 31 | D | TENS | Waits upon large numbers (4) TENDS (waits upon) |
| 32 | W | DRAGEE | We raged about cake decoration (6) (WE RAGED)* |
| 34 | A | RUSE | Royal Artillery employ cunning (4) RA (Royal Artillery) + USE (employ) |
| 35 | S | ADONIS | Anglo-Saxon fellow is a handsome young man (6) AS (Anglo-Saxon) DON (fellow) IS |
| 37 | D | SURETY | Fit sturdy electronic safeguard (6) [STURDY + E (electronic)]* |
| 39 | I | ARGOL | Gloria removed dried dung (5) GLORIA* |
| 40 | D | SPITE | Thwart mine in Swaziland with last of ore (5) PIT (mine) in SD (Swaziland) + E (last of orE) |
| 41 | O | GRIEG | Composer‘s arrangement of unfinished “Georgia” (5) GEORGI(A)* |
| 43 | D | ENDS | Terminates direct debit that’s in being (4) DD (direct debit) in ENS (being) |
| 46 | U | AIDE | President’s assistant is independent in French department (4) I (independent) in AUDE (French département) |
| 49 | M | GUM | Toothless, give up yen for gelatinous confection (3) GUMMY – Y (yen) |
If the central square is to be AS PER BREWER, shouldn’t it contain (b) ?
Oh yes, I think you’re right Chesley … sorry for the sloppiness!