The construction of this crossword was reminiscent of a puzzle a few months ago. Across entries in the two top and bottom rows, and down entries in the four left and right columns had an extra letter in the wordplay not entered in the grid. They provided an instruction to the solver. These clues were to be entered normally, all others were to be entered jumbled. I decided not to ferret out the earlier puzzle, but to solve this one uninfluenced.
Concentrating on the clues leading to entries that were to be entered normally, they were pretty straightforward. All but one or two were solved in my first pass through the clues. These then provided a solid foundation to fit in the remaining jumbled entries.
I completed the grid fairly quickly with the feeling that not all Piccadilly puzzles were as straightforward. Completed, that is, except for the ambiguity which was in 25ac which could be either NIIOCIPSLAT or NIIOPICSLAT. The extra letters in the wordplay spelt out Find disease in grid. I studied the grid for quite a while without success, looking mainly in the diagonals. I temporarily put it to one side.
Casting a weary eye over the grid again just before the land of nod, and I saw VOLCANO in rows 9 and 10, and working my way up the grid, PNEUMONOULTRAMICROSCOPICSILICOVOLCANOCONIOSIS was in the central 5×9 area of the grid. Chambers defines it as “a form of pneumoconiosis caused by very fine silicate or quartz dust”. It is one of the words in the 12th edition of the dictionary that the editors have considered worthy of strong highlighting, along with the likes of hydra-headed, Jack-go-to-bed-at-noon and piss-a-bed (the dandelion). In fact, our word is in Chambers as far back as the 1988 edition, if not before. Up till now, it has appeared quietly, without any fanfare or shouting!
Having finished the grid and found the disease (anagram of ‘Seaside’ in the title), I was left with two thoughts. Firstly, since 25ac could only be entered in one of two ways, was that one ambiguity or two? And secondly, was it necessary to highlight the disease in my submitted entry, after all we weren’t explicitly told to. I decided it would be prudent.
I checked on the earlier puzzle which employed the same technique. It was indeed another puzzle by Piccadilly: EV No. 1046, Author.
Thanks for an entertaining puzzle, Piccadilly. Just got to work out now how to bring the word up in conversation!
[It was only when I was writing this blog that I spotted a problem with 16ac. It reads as BOULLION – O = BULLION, but the broth is spelt BOUILLON. BOULLION is a French ex-Formula One racing driver.]
Legend:
Definition in clue
X = Extra letter in wordplay
ABC* = anagram
ABC< = reversal
abCDef = hidden
| ACROSS | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| No | Answer | Extra Letter |
Clue and Explanation |
| 1 | CONTRETEMPS | F | A slight disagreement aroused ref’s contempt (11) (REFS CONTEMPT) |
| 11 | RIMBAUD | I | Mauritania and Dubai excited French poet (7) RIM (Mauritania) + DUBAI* |
| 12 | BAITS | N | Tempts fish to bite heads of bathers near islands (5) BN (heads of Bathers Near) + AITS (islands) |
| 13 | PLIANT | Flexible centre of rig in factory (6) I (centre of rIg) in PLANT (factory) |
|
| 14 | RUMOUR | Strong drink belonging to us results in gossip (6) RUM (strong drink) + OUR (belonging to us) |
|
| 16 | BULLION | Gold ring removed from strong broth (7) BOUILLON (strong broth) – O (ring); in fact the clue as written gives BUILLON but both give the same jumbled letters |
|
| 17 | HETAIRA | Shyest man in road regularly procuring Greek courtesan (7) regular characters from sHyEsT mAn In RoAd |
|
| 19 | DERMIS | Skin from shoulder misgrafted (6) in shoulDER MISgrafted |
|
| 20 | COINS | In Greek island pockets money (5) COS (Greek island) pocketing (holding) IN |
|
| 21 | SCORCHES | Withers of two colts among horses inflamed (8) C C (two colts) in HORSES* |
|
| 25 | POLITICIANS | Place for some of these is in Capitol, working (11) (IS IN CAPITOL)*; a semi-&lit. |
|
| 28 | CRITICAL | One in Arctic, injured, left seriously ill (8) I (one) in ARCTIC* + L (left) |
|
| 32 | BURRO | Prickly seed-case on tail of albino donkey (5) BURR (prickly seed-case) + O (tail of albinO) |
|
| 34 | OLIVER | Man has oxygen supplied to organ (6) O (oxygen) + LIVER (organ) |
|
| 36 | GRACILE | Slender actress Kelly clutching heart in film (7) GRACE (actress Kelly) holding IL (heart of fILm) |
|
| 37 | CONCEAL | Disguise one carrying cocaine in California (7) ONE holding C (cocaine) in CAL (California) |
|
| 39 | DOCILE | Obedient child revised, spending hour absorbing Old English (6) CHILD* – H (hour) holding O (old) + E (English) |
|
| 40 | CORGIS | Caught men with soldier starting to steal dogs (6) C (caught) OR (men) + GI (soldier) + S (starting to Steal) |
|
| 41 | NEPAL | D | Young hooligan in Glasgow meeting friend in country (5) NED (young hooligan, Scottish word) + PAL (friend) |
| 42 | ALARMED | D | Scared youth carrying weapon outside (7) ARMED (carrying weapon) outside LAD (youth) |
| 43 | PROGRAMMERS | I | Computer workers compile orgasm primer (11) (ORGASM PRIMER)* |
| DOWN | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| No | Answer | Extra Letter |
Clue and Explanation |
| 1 | CRAVEN | S | Coward longs for end to intimidation (6) CRAVES (longs for) + N (end of intimidatioN) |
| 2 | OIL PAINT | E | Material for artist thrown into a pile (8, two words) (INTO A PILE)* |
| 3 | TBILISI | A | Foreign city: is it holding a small politician up? (7) (IS IT holding A LIB (politician))< |
| 4 | CAPTOR | One arresting Mafia boss skipping over hill (6) CAPO (Mafia boss) – O (over) + TOR (hill) |
|
| 5 | RUNNER | Fugitive’s name appearing in old letter to king (6) N (name) in RUNE (old letter) + R (king) |
|
| 6 | TOED | Kicked amphibian in the ear (4) sounds like TOAD (amphibian) |
|
| 7 | MUSEUM | Art gallery in New York starts to mount unusual show exploring urban myths (6) first letters of Mount Unusual Show Exploring Urban Myths |
|
| 8 | PARISH | S | Part of county’s health resort is in the centre of Durham (6) SPA (health resort) + IS in RH (centre of duRHam) |
| 9 | STOLE | E | Find ecclesiastical vestment from large quantity up in bishop’s office (5) LOT< in SEE (bishop’s office) |
| 10 | ASUNDER | I | Insured a building separately (7) (INSURED A)* |
| 12 | CLIMBS | Chicken’s head and legs showing scales (6) C (Chicken’s head) + LIMBS (legs) |
|
| 15 | CHOIR | N | Women from Norwich trained singers (5) (NORWICH – W (women))* |
| 18 | AIOLI | Oil stirred into first-class mayonnaise (5) OIL* in AI (first-class, ie A1) |
|
| 22 | CARRY | T | Farm vehicle and railway used for portage of boat (5) CART (farm vehicle) + RY (railway) |
| 23 | STRINGER | H | Part-time journalist rings the wrong rector (8) (RINGS THE)* + R (rector) |
| 24 | LARCENY | E | Theft of mobile crane in Cambridgeshire town (7) CRANE* in ELY (Cambridge town) |
| 26 | VIOLIN | Instrument broadcast live on air destroyed ear in flight (6) (LIVE ON AIR)* – EAR* |
|
| 27 | LUGWORM | G | Invertebrate, first from Gorbals to grow up in Glaswegian chimney (7) G (first from Gorbals) + GROW* + LUM (chimney, Scottish) |
| 29 | CELLAR | R | Unfortunate caroller deprived of oxygen in vault (6) CAROLLER* – O (oxygen) |
| 30 | GOOGOL | A large number love dipping into Russian writer (6) O (love) in GOGOL (Russian writer) |
|
| 31 | CALICO | Cloth Catholic weaves, losing two bits of thread (6) CATHOLIC* – TH (two bits of THread) |
|
| 32 | SAMOAN | South American getting first from Oxford with a new language (6) S (south) + AM (American) + O (first from Oxford) A N (new) |
|
| 33 | BEARDS | I | Hair on faces that is hidden by poets (6) IE (that is) in BARDS (poets) |
| 35 | LADEN | D | Lord vacated port with cargo on board (5) LD (LorD vacated, ie emptied) + ADEN (port) |
| 38 | SCAR | Remove head of statuette, leaving mark (4) [o]SCAR (statuette, headless) |
|
Thanks, Dave, for the blog for this puzzle. Hopefully the failure of myself and various other test solvers to spot the misspelling of BOUILLON wasn’t too much of an issue.
This puzzle generated the largest postbag that I can remember for an EV, with solvers being very taken with Piccadilly’s achievement in fitting the 45-letter disease into the grid in such a clean and tidy away. I have to agree that it is impressive!