Has Rorschach blotted his copybook with this one?
In my opinion, not at all. I really liked this one, although those expecting the usual fairly gentle introduction to the Indy week might have been slightly startled. I did find it tricky: there is some devious clueing and maybe some stretching of the cryptic ‘rules’ (whatever they are) in places. There are several where I am not entirely sure if I’ve got the parsing right, so any clarification or correction welcome.
Plenty of homophones and some cds and dds, but not many full anagrams or charades, which is maybe why I found it a bit on the hard side.
The blog is a bit long, partly because I know that the Monday puzzle attracts improving solvers and lurkers and they appreciate full explanations; partly because some clues take a bit of explaining; and partly because I have wittered on a bit when I found something of interest.
Abbreviations
cd cryptic definition
dd double definition
(xxxx)* anagram
anagrind = anagram indicator
[x] letter(s) missing
definitions are underlined
Across
1 Frantically using articles to identify animals
IGUANAS
(USING AA)* AA are your ‘articles’, two in this case. The anagrind is ‘frantically’.
5 F***! Summer in Paris is decadent!
EFFETE
I somehow doubt that this would have got into many other daily papers as a clue. ‘F***!’ is suggesting EFF, as in EFF OFF, and summer in Paris is été. Stick the two together and you’ve got your answer. ‘Decadent’ might not be my first choice of synonym for EFFETE.
9 Line delay in phone call to foreign country
KUWAIT
A homophone clue: of QUEUE WAIT. The homophone indicator is ‘in phone call’.
10 ‘Sweet!’ Munch Topic heard saying this?
ICE CREAM
No chocolate required here: the ‘topic’ is the figure in the very well-known painting(s) The Scream by Edvard Munch. It’s a homophone clue: I SCREAM sounds the same as ICE CREAM. And I think, but only think, that the setter is saying that the figure in the painting is saying I SCREAM. But you might have a better idea.
11 This Roman‘s drunken ejaculation
HIC
I don’t think we want to dwell on the surface too long here. HIC is one of the Latin words for ‘this’ and it can be what you ejaculate when you’ve had one too many.
12 Trinity’s 1st and 3rd boat last in Cambridge University admitted paper
TISSUE
The first and third letters of TrInity are followed by SS and E for the last letter of CambridgE. Stick a U in and you’ve got the stuff you blow your nose with.
13 Hire mobile toilet before beginning of May for part of estate
HEIRLOOM
(HIRE)* LOO and M
14 Mist over river into which one hops?
FROG
Maybe stretching the definition a bit if I’ve understood it correctly. It’s R in FOG.
15 10 man’s address given to wife with love handles?
MR WHIPPY
The famous ice-cream is MR, which is how you ‘address’ a man, W for ‘wife’ and HIPPY, which is an extremely whimsical way of describing ‘love handles’, the rolls of fat around the waistline and hips. They are called love handles because they may be used to grab onto, in a handle-like way, during coitus in certain positions. I couldn’t possibly comment.
18 Diplomat ran domestic sector without any organisation
AT RANDOM
Hidden (‘sector’) in dipolmAT RAN DOMestic.
19 Max Ernst initially announced for award
EMMY
M and E are the intials of Max Ernst and if you ‘announce’ them, you’ve got EMMY, the television equivalent of an Oscar.
22 United supporter standing by as Maradona scored
MANUALLY
I teased in my last blog about there being too much football in the Indy, but this will not amuse those who really don’t like it, because you do have to know stuff about the beautiful game to parse it, if not to solve it. ‘United’ is MANU and ALLY is ‘supporter’. Diego Maradona scored a controversial goal in the quarter-final of the 1986 World Cup against England, when he illegally fisted the ball into the net with his hand during an aerial challenge with Peter Shilton, the England keeper, and claimed that it was the ‘Hand of God’ that had scored. So he could be said to have scored MANUALLY. Yer, I knew some of you wouldn’t like it. Anyway, at the time he was considered to be the greatest player of his generation; but he later turned into a fat knacker and a drug addict.
24 Tough-guy actor seen in Duchamp’s fountain perhaps?
BOGART
My felicitations if you knew what ‘Duchamp’s fountain’ was, ‘cos I certainly didn’t. Turns out it’s a 1917 work of art by Marcel Duchamp which consisted of a porcelain urinal. So it would be BOG ART – geddit?
25 Ingredient of pavlovas?
OVA
Rorschach really is getting all whimsical this morning. Good surface, though. To make the meringue for the pavlova, you’d need eggs. Which are OVA, an ingredient of pavlOVAs.
26 Recluse goes around on underground finally arriving at 3?
LONDONER
An insertion of ON and D for the final letter of ‘underground’ in LONER. Suralan is indeed a LONDONER, but this wasn’t my favourite clue this morning.
27 That’s made by chef, that is
COOKIE
A charade of COOK and IE. I’d call this &lit. Cue animated discussion with another Indy setter.
28 Setter Rorschach’s filled with panic
TERROR
Hidden in setTER RORschach.
29 Spies backtracked taking a month free from corrupt activity
ASEPTIC
An insertion of SEPT in CIA reversed. It’s referring to a lack of infection, or ‘corruption’ in a wound, say.
Down
2 More tacky than a pierced ear, say?
GAUDIER
A homophone (‘say’) of ‘gored ear’.
3 Lord Raglan warred with Russia regularly
ALAN SUGAR
An anagram (‘warred’) of RAGLAN and the even letters of ‘Russia’. And for those familiar with the 1854 Battle of Balaclava during the Crimean War against the Russians, the surface will have some meaning. Crimea 1854; Crimea 2014. Plus ça change? Let’s hope not.
4 Country air
ANTHEM
A cd.
5 Browser’s functioning in apple.com according to helpline?
EYESIGHT
Again, I just can’t quite pin this down. It’s more whimsy: suggesting that I-SIGHT might be an Apple product that sounds like (‘according to helpline’) EYESIGHT. Perhaps that’s it, but over to you if not.
6 Will actor broadcast in wild?
FERAL
Another homophone: of the actor Will FERRELL. I’m not massively into cinema, but even I’d heard of him.
7 East coast criminal acquiring unknown pot user’s paraphernalia
TEA COSY
‘Criminal’ and ‘pot’ in the same clue? Got to be drugs. But that’s cryptic misdirection for you. ‘Criminal’ is the anagrind for (E COAST Y)* Y is one of the mathematical ‘unknowns’. And the stuff you put in the ‘pot’ is much less damaging to your health, even if you didn’t inhale.
8 A king who’s slightly on the spectrum
RICHARD OF YORK
Clever, clever … it’s referring to the mnemonic which teaches little ones the colours of the rainbow (‘spectrum’). RICHARD OF YORK GAVE BATTLE IN VAIN for red, orange, yellow, green, blue, indigo and violet. And the soon to be Leicester-based monarch is only part of, or ‘slightly on’ that phrase. Not everybody’s tasse de thé, but I liked it (when I finally got it).
16 Contemporaries who are normally found around Duchamp’s fountain?
PEER GROUP
Quite a lot of bodily function in this puzzle. Refer to 24ac. If the lads all go to the urinal together during half-time at the match, we’d be a PEER GROUP, wouldn’t we?
17 Gag Queen Elizabeth?
ONE-LINER
A dd.
18 The latest Bowie hit here finally – David Bowie
À LA MODE
He knows some stuff, this setter. Two different Bowies: the first refers to James Bowie, a defender who was killed at the Battle of the ALAMO; the second is David Bowie, where the final letters of his first and second names give you DE to form your answer. Ground Control to Major Tom.
20 Perhaps Luther King’s second drink
MARTINI
This is going to start sounding like a love-in between the slogger and the better, but I thought this was really inventive too: it’s MARTIN plus I for the second letter of kIng.
21 UCAS in mix-up over exam results in summer
ABACUS
An ABACUS does ‘sums’, so it’s A and B for ‘exam results’ followed by (ACUS)* with ‘mix-up’ as the anagrind. Normally, ‘over’ in a down clue would indicate that the AB would come below ACUS. Can it be an instruction to put the AB first? You tell me.
23 Drinks dispenser required Duracells – back up and running essentially
UDDER
Hidden reversed in requiRED DUracells. Since this is a down clue, then ‘back up and running essentially’ is the rather long-winded reversal and hidden indicator, I think. If that’s complete and udder nonsense, you’ll tell me, no doubt.
I enjoyed this and could handle some more of this setter in the Indy. Thank you to him for today’s puzzle.
Some nice clues but it was all too much like hard work for me – I gave up after a while and just came over here to look at the answers. By the way, I think the idea in 5a is that apple.com is an i-site.
Thanks Pierre
As you say, a bit more tricky than the usual Monday fare.
In 5dn, I thought it was a homophone of i-site, ie apple.com itself rather than a product.
In 21dn I justified the ‘over’ by making it an anagram of UCAS around BA, though strictly speaking a BA would be a singular degree rather than the clued ‘exam results’.
… I mean 5d, of course.
Thanks Pierre and Rorschach,
A very nice and testing puzzle.
I think FROG could be Mist over = Fog (as a verb) + river into which (insertion of “r”), leaving “one hops” as the definition.
I groaned when I parsed last-in GAUDIER.
Thanks for all that. I-SITE, of course. D’oh. Muffyword is surely right about FROG. Gaufrid, if we take BA as an ‘exam’, then ‘results in’ could just be taken as leading us to the solution, no?
Hi Pierre
It could indeed! A good misleading surface.
Thanks for the entertaining blog, Pierre, and especially for 18dn: I didn’t know that Bowie. [But even I knew about the football.]
I had almost given up on seeing another Rorschach puzzle [it’s been four months!] so was very pleased to be challenged by this one.
I took an even more whimsical view of EYESIGHT, thinking it had something to do with the apple of one’s eye being the pupil.
[Re 8d – I do hope you’re right, Pierre: the delayed judicial review takes place at the end of this week.]
Many thanks to Rorschach for a most enjoyable puzzle.
Definitely trickier than a Monday puzzle normally is, but it was a good challenge, and the SE was the only quadrant that I completed quickly. I finished the bottom half of the puzzle when I finally solved the MANUALLY/A LA MODE crossers, and EYESIGHT gave me the NE. Four clues in the NW proved the most obstinate. I finally saw the homophone for KUWAIT, and I then solved ANTHEM which was very much a Rufusesque clue which had thrown me completely. IGUANAS finally fell into place, and my LOI was GAUDIER, having briefly considered an unparsed neologism, “glueier”.
Thanks Rorschach for an enjoyable challenge and Pierre for the blog.
21dn: I took this as ACUS (anagram of UCAS) containing (over) B+A (exam results separately – no reason they should be in descending order of merit).
That could be a good call, Pelham. So now we are back to ‘exam results’ being part of the wordplay.
And Eileen, if (even) you got the football bit, then I was perhaps being a bit harsh.
D’oh! I visited the Alamo last year and couldn’t parse 18dn. Thanks for the explanation.
A bit tough, but I did finish it with only having to do an e-search once. The clues were amusing enough to make the slog worth it.
As soon as I read the clue to 8dn, the mnemonic sprang into my mind and the answer clicked into place. Made me smile.
No football fan but I did know about the Hand of God. Duchamp’s Fountain I also knew.
EFFETE, as I’m sure everyone knows, originally meant worn out by childbirth, coming from the Latin meaning “from the f(o)etus”.
Hmm Emmy appears in 19a and unchecked on right side, a Belgian Nina?
Super puzzle. I particularly liked ABACUS and UDDER.
After not being quite sure what was the definition in 14ac, it seems to me that it is one of those rare times that the definition isn’t at the beginning or end of the clue: isn’t it simply the word ‘one’? Surely ‘into which one hops’ is referring to the river and it’s ‘into which FROG jumps’. At least that’s what I thought.
Didn’t realise that eggs were part of pavlovas. but of course they are. Until this was pointed out it seemed rather feeble. Good crossword, although I wasn’t happy with ‘slightly’ as 3/7 (8dn) and I am less than keen on CDs (4dn).
Merci, Pierre. As you say, quite a tough challenge for a Monday, but very inventive and enjoyable, though I was a bit uneasy about 3d, where it’s not clear whether RIS or USA (!) is to be used in the anagram.
A bit of Cambridge knowledge is needed to get the full surface sense in 12a – for obscure historical reasons Trinity College’s boat club is known as “1st and 3rd Trinity” (as you may know, Pierre, come to think of it…) On the other hand, I thought everyone knew about Duchamp’s famous work of sanitary ware 😉 , and although I know little and care less about football, I think Maradona’s manual goal must be pretty well known too.
Thanks Pierre and thanks all for the helpful comments!
You’ve pretty much parsed everything to perfection.
With FROG it was supposed to be as simple as R into FOG with the definition being a little recursive i.e. into which (i.e. river) one hops? The EYESIGHT clue was indeed playing on Apple.com being titled an i-site – I thought about Specsavers.com too i.e. eye-site. ABACUS was as Pelham Barton had it.
As for the difficulty – I didn’t write this as a Monday crossword. I hope you enjoyed it all the same!