Guardian Genius No 145 by Picaroon

An apparently anonymous puzzle for July, offering an unusual twist on a familiar device.  As Gaufrid pointed out to me, the identity of the setter was in fact available by doing an archive search, but not on the page where the puzzle itself was to be found.

completed grid
 
The instructions told us that there were 12 clues which led to solutions that were too long for their spaces in the grid, and would need to be “adjusted” in order to fit.  The adjustments had to be done in a consistent way and would lead to real (but undefined) words to enter in the grid.  For the purposes of the blog, I have shown the original answer with the letters to be omitted shown in brackets.  I have highlighted the amended entries.
 
 
This was more difficult than first appeared, since in some cases (e.g. 8 across) there was more than one possible answer.  Some would become clear from crossing letters, but in others there was doubt until the nature of the method required became clear.  It all involved abbreviations, and it’s probably simplest just to list the letters omitted in order, along with the preceding letter.  In each case the letter preceding omission, when added to the letters omitted,  serves as an abbreviation for the whole.
 
Across
 
8 A (CE )               A = ACE
11 R (AND)            R= RAND
15 T (ON)              T = TON
17 E (ARL)             E = EARL
18 N (EW)             N = NEW
19 C (ENT)            C = CENT
26 L (AKE)            L = LAKE
 
Down
 
5 M (ETRE)           M = METRE
13 A (RE)             A = ARE (the metric measure of area)
20 B (ORN)          B = BORN
27 V (ERSE)         V = VERSE
28 G (RAM)          G = GRAM
 
Finally, although it’s six months since I last blogged a Genius puzzle, the Guardian has still not resolved the technical issues that mean that you have to enter the competition without completing an online grid.  The so-called printable version produced something far too small for my eyes to read.
Across
8 CONTRA(CE)PTION
Can protection for frolicking be this? (11)

The first of the 12 clues where letters had to be omitted.  At first CONTRACTION seemed equally likely, before I had the crossing letter, but only CONTRAPTION fits the theme (see introduction).  With all the letters included, the clue is a very nice example of an & lit.

9 CAD
Queen, say, losing right heel (3)

CA(r)D.

11 BR(AND)ING
Putting logo on bottom of badminton racket — boast about it (5)

(badminto)N DIN in BRAG.

12 THESAURUS
Tailless bird circles character in Old Testament book (9)

ESAU in THRUS(h).

13 AKINETIC
A family name’s brought back still (8)

A KIN CITE(rev).  This word was new to me, but easily gettable from the wordplay and crossing letters.

15 SEMIT(ON)E
Record company not about to enter Home Counties for a short interval (6)

EMI NOT(rev) in SE.

17 PE(ARL)ER
Diver’s parking before one leaves (4)

P EARL(i)ER.

18 REN(EW)AL
Frenchman sent back rules for overhaul (5)

RENE LAW(rev).

19 DOC(ENT)S
Con coins from US academics (4)

Another unfamiliar word for me.  The word play is a simple charade: DO CENTS.  Arguably the US in the clue could equally well serve as part of the definition.

22 LEAN-TO
Deliberately fencing a cabin (4-2)

A in LENTO (a musical term meaning slowly, so deliberately).

23 MALAYSIA
Graduate bets capital from east Asian land (8)

MA LAYS A1(rev).

25 INCUBATOR
Current trainee returned schedule for hospital device (9)

IN CUB ROTA(rev).

26 FL(AKE) OUT
Collapse cooking kale and tofu (5)

*(KALE TOFU).

29 GEN
Low-down fellow? Not quite (3)

GEN(t).

30 LIPOPROTEIN
Something in the blood, cheek or toe fixed with pin (11)

LIP *(OR TOE PIN).

Down
1 SCAB
He shouldn’t be working in second vehicle (4)

S CAB.

2 ANTI
Not for visiting Byzantium (4)

Hidden in Byzantium.

3 TRIGGER
Cause to bring goods into German city (7)

GG in TRIER (one of the smaller German cities, but one which is very useful to a crossword compiler!).

4 SPITFIRES
More than one plane tree pest is unfortunately covering (9)

FIR in *(PEST IS).

5 LIM(E TRE)ES
Greenery is prone to be occupied by London coppers and sappers (5)

MET(ropolitan police) RE in LIES.

6 INHALER
It helps breathing, being cool and well rested, initially (7)

IN HALE R(ested).

7 SCURRILOUS
Abusive rascal interrupting Hindu’s address, endlessly base person (10)

CUR in SRI, LOUS(e).

10 DYSPEPSIA
Days suffering without drink, having trouble with consumption (9)

PEPSI in *DAYS.

13 APPA(RE)LLING
Girl with an apple for cooking, getting dressing (9)

*(GIRL AN APPLE).

14 ICE DANCING
Gliding and tripping in chilled party in Africa in Gabon’s capital (3,7)

ICED ANC IN G(abon).

16 PARAGRAPH
Secretary to mock and criticise hard lines (9)

PA RAG RAP H.  Nicely misleading definition.

20 STUBB(ORN)LY
Animal painter not quite right, entering just like a mule (7)

STUBB(s),  R in ONLY.

21 SAFFRON
Colour’s very loud in most of Asian dress with no back (7)

FF in SARON(g).

24 STEPS
Small animals retreating in flight (5)

S PETS (all rev).

27 OV(ERSE)ER
Supervisor finished date with queen (4)

OVER SEE R.

28 TANG(RAM).
Hint and sign in eastern puzzle (4)

TANG RAM.

*anagram

12 comments on “Guardian Genius No 145 by Picaroon”

  1. Thanks for the blog – this was a classic genius puzzle and we enjoyed most of it… FLOUT was our first suspect for an adjusted answer, but it took several such answers letter until the penny fully dropped.
    Most of it went fairly smoothly, but the last few were ground out slowly, and we failed completely on 17a and 19a – the short ones are harder as the possibilities of addition/subtraction make a more significant difference.

  2. Many thanks to setter & blogger.
    This was fun and a good challenge but I had to take a guess for both 17A and 28D and got both wrong.
    By the way, has the Guardian Editor’s blog been discontinued ? I cannot see any updates since May so none of the usual comments about the Genius submissions.

  3. Managed to mostly complete this, but had to guess 17a and went with PIER (I was hoping for PITCHER= diver).

    I also never worked out the theme- many thanks, bridgesong, for restoring my faith in the Guardian by reassuring me that “adjusted in a consistent way” did not just mean “remove some letters from the middle”- I was having flashbacks to that rubbish SELF-CENTRED Genius from last year.

  4. Oh, and regarding the print version, I usually copy the clues and grid into a Word document, mess about with the formatting and print that. Whenever I’ve tried to print the web page I’ve ended up with a grid that spans the page break…

  5. James, my experience was similar to yours, except that I (randomly) guessed PIES for 17a. I also got 19a wrong, carelessly putting DONS, thinking it was a cunning double bluff (another kind of academic), and not realising that it didn’t even match my “rule” of “remove some consecutive letters from inside the word”. So no £100 for me again this month (I wonder if anyone is getting it, as per paul8hours’s comment about the Editor’s blog.)

    Thanks to bridgesong for the elucidation.

    I see the new Genius (which I am due to blog) isn’t available yet – depending which link I follow I get either this one or an error page. And this one’s annotated solution isn’t there yet either, so pretty much par for the course..

  6. I didn’t get the theme either – got as far as removing consecutive letters to leave another word, which did yield the right answer nearly always. Spent some time trying to find a theme from the results without success, and eventually submitted DOTS at 19ac, as it seemed more likely.

  7. Andrew @6: the Guardian crossword home page shows a winner for Genius 144, so perhaps it’s safe to assume that prizes are still being awarded even in the absence of a monthly newsletter from Hugh.

    Maggy@10: your suggestion hadn’t occurred to me, but it seems that either version of the wordplay could be the intended one, both producing the same result.

  8. Maggy @10: the annotated solution is now available and confirms that your version is correct! On reflection, my version would require some repetition, so I should have realised that it wasn’t correct. Thanks.

Comments are closed.