Independent 9,429 by Punk

A very late appearance of this on the Indy website means the blog has been considerably delayed.  It’s not giving too much away to say there was a theme of cities.

I felt the cluing could have been better constructed.  There were a few too many DDs and the intersection of two short clues at 15, one a DD and the other a homophone, made that section quite tricky if you’re not someone who can instantly reel off the names of dozens of cities.

Across
7 ORIGAMI Delicate operations in city between roundabout and motorway (7)
  Riga in o + MI
8 BERLIN City songwriter (6)
  DD
10 YOKEL Rustic bond with land, primarily (5)
  Yoke + l[and]
11 NERVE CELL Around back of tramcar there’s constant shifting about, little room for conductor (5,4)
  Even< around [tramca]r + cell
12 REPROBATE Rascal worried by agent, mug? (9)
  Ate(=worried) after rep + rob, of which mugging is a variant.
14 ROUEN City 12 heading for nick (5)
  Roue + n[ick]
15 CORK City stop (4)
  DD
16 BONNY Pretty city gritty, ultimately (5)
  Bonn + [gritt]y
18 MISS Pine for girl (4)
  DD
21 NAIVE Green water ebbing (5)
  Evian<
22 RUN RAGGED Doctor urged gran to keep busy (3,6)
  (Urged gran)*
25 EMULATION Following Australian runner, old Italian going round circuit (9)
  Emu + latin around o
26 VIRGO Sign right in the middle of city (5)
  R in Vigo
28 PARISH City Hall’s first administrative district (6)
  Paris + h[all]
29 ESSENCE Outskirts of Cologne east of city, Cologne! (7)
  Essen + C[ologn]e
Down
1 BOWYER Robin Hood’s supplier ending in jeopardy in woodland retreat (6)
  Bower around [jeopard]y.  A bowyer produces bows, so might supply Robin Hood.
2 MINK Fur coats finally taken out of city (4)
  Min[s]k
3 EARLY ON Attention on city while still young? (5,2)
  Ear + Lyon
4 VIENNA City queen, climber endlessly climbing (6)
  (Anne + iv[y])<
5 ARREARS Outstanding money comes up after a rise, initially (7)
  Rears after a r[ise]
6 FINE TUNING Provided raised catch in gun needs repairing, making slight adjustments (4-6)
  If< + net + (in gun)*
8 BURGEON Comestibles served up on time – that’s swell (7)
  Grub< + eon
9 PLANES Those flying out of Naples (6)
  Naples*
13 PARTICULAR Nice point (10)
  DD
15 CANNES City vessel, we hear? (6)
  Hom of can
17 OGREISH Unlimited foresight, terribly monstrous (7)
  [f]oresigh[t]*
19 GELATIN Setter with genital rash (7)
  Genital*
20 HARVEST A gathering storm truly starts after boxer claims victory (7)
  S[torm] t[ruly] after Hare around v(ictory) – I assume it must be James Hare
23 NANTES City relative put up (6)
  Nan + set<
24 DOOFER Thingummy on table, lifted (6)
  (Re food)*
27 RING Call round (4)
  DD

*anagram

5 comments on “Independent 9,429 by Punk”

  1. There were far too many dubious double definitions and stretched definitions. Well done, Neal, for sticking with it.

  2. Well we enjoyed it. We didn’t notice that there were two many of any particular type of clue during the solve and enjoyed the way that Punk wove the cities into the grid.

    Very ingenious.

    Thanks Punk – we’re sorry that you didn’t enjoy it NealH but thanks for the blog!

  3. I found this challenging but enjoyed the geography test.

    BOWYER was a new word for me. My favourite was GELATIN for the misdirection.

  4. Well I enjoyed this, even if it was a bit of a trawl through the cities. Difficult though. But some very good clues, like 22ac. I wonder how the DDs can be called dubious. Seemed OK to me.

    I thought the definition in 7ac was a bit thin.

  5. Struggled with this but eventually got everything except GELATIN where I was totally barking up the wrong tree. I had ME for ‘setter’ and GAMIC as vaguely ‘genital’ and thought there might be a word MEGAMIC lurking deep in the recesses of the OED – maybe there is but whether it means ‘rash’ (in any sense of the word) is another matter. There’s certainly no such word in Chambers or Collins.

    In 20dn I took ‘hare’ to be the animal, referring to its behaviour in spring as described in this Wikipedia article – “During this spring frenzy, hares can be seen ‘boxing’, one hare striking another with its paws…”

    Thanks, Punk and NealH

Comments are closed.