Hard but fair is my normal estimate of Schadenfreude’s puzzles. The rubric read: One letter must be removed from the answers to 16 clues and the residue used to form a word for grid entry. The removed letters spell out three words: A, B and C. In each A (of which there are four) a B must be replaced by a C, requiring changes to 21 cells. In the final grid all entries are real words and there are no empty cells.
I started with 1A (rarely a good omen!) SOFA and found 3D to be WARINESS, but it had to start with an A, so (I thought) the letter to be removed must be a W – right answer, but wrong reasoning!
At this point I realised that the answer lengths given referred to the answers, not the grid entries, so I was able to identify 7,18,20,40,41,49 across, and 3,9,10,16,2140,42,43,44,45 down as the clues containing the letter to be removed. If it weren’t for this I might still be struggling.
After finding 12A ESURIENT 3D had to start AR, so I assumed an anagram of (W)ARINESS and put in ARSINES – again right answer, wrong reason. 7A was BINDING and after a time and much attempted juggling with JONAH (Lomu) I realised that he was a KIWI, so 8D was IWI, so 7A looked like BIDING.
This process continued slowly. i.e. remove a letter, make an anagram of the rest, though sometimes reverse engineering was necessary. The normal clues were mixed, some easy clues and some not easy at all. Eventually I had an almost full grid (though 4D and 18A remained unsolved for a long time). The extra letters were (I thought) N?RDE? WEED F??WER. So where were the weeds? On the top row I had FAT HEB, which led to the realisation the 7A was NIDING not BIDING, and one weed was FAT HEN. Thus A was B?RDE?, so BORDER. The title, “Improvements in Bed” would make sense if we were to replace WEEDs with FLOWERs.
So, in each BORDER (i.e. the four sides of the square) we had to replace a weed with a flower. Top row FAT HEN, left hand column THISTLE, bottom row MOSS (is this a weed?), right hand column NETTLE. This is a total of 23 letters, with only 21 to be changed.
Now it became a deduction/guessing game.
On the top row, ARSINES at 3D could not have its first letter changed, SOFA could become SODA – a 6 letter flower starting DA. I guessed DAHLIA which gave SODA, HILT, LEARS INSURE and AIDING as the resulting “real words”. Hooray!
On the left hand side the E of ECRU/ESNE could not be changed, thus all of the letters in the bottom row and right hand side must be changed (23 – 21 = 2 unchanged letters). SENT could be SENA, SEND, SENE or SENS, the third letter must be E (INMESHED to ENMESHED) so the flower started A/D/E/S and was ??E???E. If it started with A it could be ANEMONE, giving NAUNTS, MASSES, ORES and NATTER. OK so far.
Now the bottom row UNSEAM could become UNSEAL or UNSEAT, ALPINO could become ALPINI or ALPINE, BROOS could become BROOD/K/L/M and ARTS can only become ARTY. So we have LILY which fits all the criteria.
The right hand side must start I or S (DROMOS or DROMOI). The second letter (SER?) could be ABFGJKR, the third letter is E or H (UNWISE or UNWISH) then R from FALCONER, then T from BRUNET (or not – see below), then all sorts for the last letter (?ARD). So: S?ERT? or I?HRT? or some combination. None of these options yields a flower, so a bit of lateral thinking was required. After much cogitation I tried possibilities with I?ER?? and came up with IBERIS (the candytuft genus) which makes DROMOI, SERB, UNWISE FALCONER BRUNEI (not brunet!) and SARD.
Success! I found the last stage a real slog, and parsing some of the clues pretty tricky too. However my initial estimate (hard but fair) stands!
Across |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
No. | Clue (definition) | Answer | X | Grid | Wordplay |
1 | Surveyor initially measuring a lounge (4) | SOFA | S(urveyor initially) + OF (measuring) + A | ||
7 | Length removed from dazzling cover (7) | BINDING | B | NIDING | BLINDING (dazzling) minus L(ength) |
12 | Hungry mutineers short of money at sea (8) | ESURIENT | [(m)UTINEERS]* | ||
13 | Athletic husband goes in to court a fast swimmer (5) | WAHOO | A(thletic H(usband) in WOO (court) | ||
14 | Numbers besieging a place of worship (4) | NAOS | NOS (numbers) round A | ||
15 | Scottish girl fails to finish a cold drink (5) | LASSI | LASSI(e) (Scottish girl) | ||
18 | Swell local street party, old-fashioned (6) | STROUT | O | TRUST | ST(reet) + ROUT (old fashioned party) |
20 | One for Ireland turned in wild revelry (5) | ARIOT | R | IOTA | A (one) + TO (for) IR(eland) reversed |
22 | Visits frequently start to hinder relations (6) | HAUNTS | H(inder) + AUNTS (relations) | ||
23 | Romans aboard fellow warship (6) | DROMON | ROM(ans) in DON (fellow) | ||
24 | Explosive mine part caught in a net (8) | INMESHED | [MINE]* + SHED (part) | ||
27 | Dry and withered old claw (4) | SERE | Double definition: Dry and withered and an obsolete word for claw | ||
28 | Seven old pounds for antique locks (6) | SASSES | S (one of my un-favourite Mediaeval Roman numerals) + ASSES (pounds) | ||
29 | One regional weight holding is not known (according to Spenser) (6) | UNWIST | UN (one regional) + WT (weight) round IS | ||
32 | Nancy’s very tense unfinished letter from Tel Aviv (4) | TRES | T(ense) + RES(h) (Hebrew letter unfinished) | ||
36 | Company following Cornish river to capture field gun (8) | FALCONET | FAL (Cornish river) + CO(mpany) + NET (capture) | ||
37 | Modern female leaving to gratify (6) | LATTER | FLATTER (gratify) minus F(emale) | ||
38 | Book published by US railroad engineer (6) | BRUNEL | B(ook) + RUN (published) + EL (US railroad) | ||
40 | Valleys seen indistinctly by day (5) | DENES | D | ESNE | D(ay) + [SEEN]* |
41 | One hesitating some say to kick and run (6) | PAUSER | E | SUPRA | PAUSE (kick) + R(un) |
45 | Prince and King of France returned earlier (5) | PRIOR | PR(ince) + ROI (King of France) reversed | ||
46 | Fish with a plan (4) | IDEA | IDE (fish) + A | ||
47 | League in widespread disarray (5) | RIFLE | L(eague) in RIFE (widespread) | ||
48 | Comparatively rugged kilometre circuit by Tasmanian mountain range (8) | KNOTTIER | K(ilometre) + NOT (logic circuit) + TIER (Tasmanian mountain range) | ||
49 | Handle country losing independence to Spain (7) | SURNAME | R | UNSEAM | SURINAM (country) minus I(ndependence) + E (Spain) |
50 | Very good driver brought back some ducks (4) | SORD | SO (very good) + DR(iver) reversed | ||
Down |
|||||
No. | Clue (definition) | Answer | X | Grid | Wordplay |
1 | Dispatched note penned by exclusive group (4) | SENT | N(ote) in SET (exclusive group) | ||
2 | Very large area north of Soul City (5) | OSAKA | OS (very large) + A(rea) + KA (soul) | ||
3 | Cryptic answer is “caution” (8) | WARINESS | W | ARSINES | [ANSWER IS]* |
4 | Cover charge (4) | TILT | Double definition (numbers 1.6 & 2.1 in Chambers) | ||
5 | Tries are converted in High School (5) | HEARS | [ARE]* in H(igh) S(chool) | ||
6 | Secure space over stable (6) | ENSURE | EN (space) + SURE (stable) | ||
8 | Lomu perhaps missing his first tribe (3) | IWI | (K)IWI (Jonah Lomu – All Black star) | ||
9 | One beaten side on deck (7) | ADONISE | E | DANIOS | A (one) + [SIDE ON]* |
10 | Tenor with a certain harmony (4) | TONE | E | NOT | T(enor) + ONE (= a) |
11 | An artist unknown in part of India (4) | GOYA | Y (unknown) in GOA (part of India) | ||
16 | Wine party in New England state college (5) | MEDOC | D | COME | DO (party) in ME (Maine, New England state) C(ollege) |
17 | Quantities of money necessary in Tashkent and Sweden! (4) | SUMS | money is used twice in the clue, SUM (Uzbekistan currency) + S(weden) | ||
19 | Kitty runs into people of fashion on cocaine (5) | TRONC | R(uns) in TON (people of fashion) + C(ocaine) | ||
21 | Rustic men enthralled by a concentrated period of indulgence (6) | FOREST | F | TORSE | OR (Other Ranks – men) in FEST (concentrated period of indulgence ) |
25 | Exotic fruit new to active prince (5) | NARAS | N(ew) + A(ctive) + RAS (prince) | ||
26 | Seat deserted in cathedral city square (5) | SEDES | D(eserted) in SEE (cathedral city) + S(quare) | ||
30 | Shabby little people without posh roles (7) | WOUBITS | WO (without) + U (posh) + BITS (roles) | ||
31 | Europeans ignoring fine hotels (4) | INNS | (F)INNS (Europeans) | ||
33 | Tradename belonging to each heating vessel (4) | ETNA | TN (tradename) in EA(ch) | ||
34 | Earth dumped in old shaft in places (6) | STEALE | E(arth) dumped in STALE (old) | ||
36 | A record belonging to ordinary Italian serviceman (6) | ALPINO | A + LP (record) + IN (belonging to) + O(rdinary) | ||
38 | In due course eye up allowances for Siobhan (5) | BROOS | SO (in due course) + ORB (eye) all reversed. (In Chambers definition 3 of BROO is Irish unemployment benefit) | ||
39 | Islamic Leader heading for Egypt captured by northbound army corps (5) | EMEER | E(gypt) in REME (army corps) reversed | ||
40 | Enticement to secure constant riches (5) | LUCRE | L | ECRU | LURE (enticement) round C(onstant) |
42 | Criticise bank in collapse (5) | ROAST | O | ARTS | ROT (collapse) round AS (ås is a kame or esker – a sandbank) |
43 | Shore bird with a raised comb, chiefly Scottish (5) | WADER | W | EARD | W(ith) + A + RED (comb, chiefly Scottish) reversed |
44 | Can turning end in complete darkness? (4) | NITE | E | TIN | TIN (can) reversed + (complet)E |
45 | Refuse old transport (4) | RAPE | R | PEA | Double definition, refuse and old transport |
Page 1 of 8
Hard but fair would be my assessment of this puzzle as well. The grid fill took an absolute age. The end game I found on the easier side – though I must admit to employing the services of a word searcher to find the flowers, which many would consider to be cheating. 43d I never did manage to parse, but it couldn’t be anything else…
The usual thanks. Another one I didn’t finish — the interlocking anagrams with multiple possibilities (BIDING, DINING, NIDING?) sort of wore me down, and I never even saw let alone solved the endgame. Must try harder.
I normally like Schadenfreude’s puzzle and up to a point I enjoyed this one too – however, I have a particular antipathy for puzzles where the endgame consists of spending ages trying to work out which words (in this case flowers, of which there are literally hundreds if not thousands of possibilities!) will replace the others. Though my social diary is hardly on a par with Truman Capote’s back in the day, I do think life may be a teensy bit short for that.
Thanks anyway to setter and blogger
If I hadn’t stubbornly stuck to ‘dining’, I might have deduced a third flower. What unlocked this very tricky puzzle for me was looking at the nearly-filled grid for 4 things… and thistle and nettle rather shouted out. Which hugely helped deduce the three words. Agree with hard but fair, but I also thought it rather brilliant, this one got under my skin (just as well, given the labour involved). Thanks to Schadenfreude and Hihoba.
I started this on the plane to northern Tuscany. I read the preamble, and before looking at the clues I wrote down GARDEN WEED FLOWER – pretty close – but some of the advantage gained was given up trying to remove the letters GArdeN from 7a, 18a & 49a instead of the letters BOrdeR. I only realised that my initial guess was wrong when I woke in the middle of a night and thought “SURINAM”!
Yes, it was a bit of a slog at the end to replace all the weeds with flowers … and I too have doubts about MOSS being a weed. (I did toy with the possibility of SEA MOSS – seaweed – being replaced by SEA LILY, bit that’s not a flower.)
Thanks to Sch… & Hi(hoba).
PS I’m not sure that “money” is used twice in the clue for 17d (Quantities of money necessary in Tashkent and Sweden!); “necessary” also means money so it’s that that’s used in the wordplay for SUM, the monetary unit in Uzbekistan.
HG @ 6 Good point. Ho and I missed that.
I agree with the general feeling that the grid fill took absolutely ages and it just wasn’t worth it to then sit and leaf (a thank you) through lists of flowers to find words that would fit. I got Dahlia and Iberis by employing the general principle that the more obscure words would become less so after the final change, but that doesnt hold for the other two so never finished them. Quite frustrating, but thanks nevertheless.
I began by thinking this was the easiest Schadenfreude I’d ever tackled, but it became much harder later on. I also found the endgame a bit of a slog since so many of the candidates for a change of letter offered multiple possibilities. Like HolyGhost I had initial doubts about moss being a weed, but if it appears where it’s not wanted I suppose it’s a weed.
Unusually for me, I got most of it fairly straightforwardly, including the “flower for weed substitution in borders” … DAHLIA, ANEMONE and LILY came easily, but I was then stuck with hours of frustrating letter-logic-wrangling, over about three days, before I finally came across IBERIS, which I’d never heard of before, with an audible sigh of relief. Thus finally allowing me to grade it as yet another fine Schadenfreude puzzle.
Jon@1, I feel no guilt whatsoever these days in using outside aids … but my Bradford didn’t have IBERIS under “flowers”. Respect to Trebor @8 for knowing about it. As a boy, I was forced to “dig for victory”, and thus hated anything to do with gardens and gardening thereafter, hence my floral ignorance.
I had mostly filled the grid but had made a couple of wrong guesses at which letters to omit. I didn’t manage to find the three words from the missing letters and eventually ground to a complete halt. I continued to look at it off and on for a couple of days hoping for a breakthrough but sadly I did not make any further progress.
I found the main difficulty was that even after having solved a clue there were many possible entries one could make. Without a definition for the grid entry how to know which to enter? This meant a much higher proportion of “cold solving” than normal. The bottom left corner was especially bad: 47ac was the only normal clue, if you didn’t manage to cold-solve that one then you were stuck.
Thanks to Hihoba and Schadenfreude.
I concur with many of the above comments: I made a fairly rapid start, but found entering the final few clues very difficult and after resorting to a few blogs for hints, I gave up. Similar to PeeDee @11, I found the top right corner particularly difficult with the multiple, interacting jumbled entries. Entering ALPINI at 36d didn’t help either – while it turns out that was what was required for the flower, it prevented me from seeing MOSS 🙁