It’s Thursday, so we can expect a difficult crossword
Nimrod has given us what we expect … and more. I found this one of the hardest crosswords I have solved for a long time. There were many entries that I didn’t see the full parsing for until I came to write the blog. There were a few dictionaries studied including a French one. I think I looked at all of Chambers, Collins and the Shorter Oxford dictionaries while writing the blog.
In the end, I reckon I have got the parsing of everything, but wouldn’t be surprised to be told that I have got a detail wrong somewhere.
At the end, there were two words that I haven’t come across before – QUAILING and ÉLÈVE. Foreign languages are a serious weakness for me; give me a computer language any time, so 6 down was a struggle. Having said that, the clue gave a strong indication that the word was French, so it was a case of trawling through possible words in the French dictionary. Once I found the word, the misdirection of ‘in-form’ became clear.
Indeed, misdirection was the order of the day with some very well concealed definitions. The ones that stood out for me were ‘[Penny and] Peg use to row’ for THOLE PIN, ‘if not’ for UNLESS, ‘condition’ for ECZEMA, and I for INDIA
There were some good allusions – e.g. CAN ZONE, the Tinder reference, and two-time Maggie.
The clue that took me the longest time to parse was for TWEEPS until I realised how to unfriend Wally via reverse engineering the entry back to the clue.
The Independent crossword series always throws up an eclectic mix of difficulties during the week. Long may it continue. Possibly other people may feel differently.
I’ve had a look for a theme or message, but I can’t find one.
Across | |||
---|---|---|---|
No | Clue | Wordplay | Entry |
1 | A way to work a Weary Willie (5) |
MO (modus operandi; way of working) + PER (for each or a) MO PER |
MOPER (one who moves aimlessly or listlessly; Weary Willie [a person habitually lackadaisical or deficient in energy or spirits] |
4 | Hotline is buzzing, given Penny and Peg used to row (5,3) |
Anagram of (is buzzing) HOTLINE and [given] P [penny] THOLE PIN* |
THOLE PIN (PIN or peg in the side of a boat to keep the oar in place) |
8 | End up with radius broken and in support (8) |
Anagram of (broken) END UP and R (radius) + IN UNDERP* IN |
UNDERPIN (support by building underneath) |
9 | To "unfriend" Wally in step #4 of five? That’s confused "followership"! (6) |
Anagram of (that’s confused) (WALLY excluding [un-] ALLY [friend]), i.e. W and STEP and E [fourth letter of {#4 of} FIVE]) TWEEPS* |
TWEEPS (people who follow someone on Twitter; followership) |
10 | For beginners, whole between three and one (3) |
W (first letter of [beginners] WHOLE) contained in (between) (T [first letter of {beginners} THREE and O [first letter of {beginners] ONE]) T (W) O |
TWO (the whole number between three and one) |
11 | Back to pour some ale and wine we’ve lost (3,3,2) |
(PULL [reference PULL {pour} a pint {of ale}] + ASTI [type of wine]) all reversed (back) (IT’S A LL UP)< |
ITS ALL UP (expression implying all hope is gone; we’ve lost) |
12 | Hard to follow fine heavy metal festival in Cork? (6) |
F (fine) + LEAD (a metal that is heavy in terms of weight) + H (hard, when describing pencil lead) F LEAD H |
FLEADH (festival of Irish [Cork] traditional music, dancing, etc) |
13 | Suddenly afraid a new King’s imminent? (8) |
QU (queen) + AILING (unwell) QU AILING |
QUAILING (flinching; shrinking back; being suddenly afraid). It seems a bit of leap to suggest that just because the Queen is unwell then we will necessarily get a new King, even if we are talking about the current royal family in the UK with a 92 year old Queen and a Prince as heir to the throne. I guess I’m missing something here. |
15 | Overcast? Presumably overcast if not! (6) |
SUNLESS (overcast) excluding the first letter (if not overcast) S I understand what is intended here, but I don’t think I’m explaining it very well. UNLESS |
UNLESS (if not) |
17 | Winding Mediterranean course mostly in very good condition (6) |
(MEZE [type of appetizer or hors d’oeuvre served in Greece, Turkey, Lebanon, etc, [Mediterranean course], especially with an aperitif before dinner) excluding the final letter [mostly] E contained in [in] ACE [very good]) all reversed (winding). (EC (ZEM) A)< |
ECZEMA (a skin condition) |
19 | Liking as always to confine female, with force, in it? (8) |
AY (always) containing (to confine) (F [female] + F [force] + IN IT) A (F F IN IT) Y |
AFFINITY (rapport; liking) |
21 | People out of hospital later (2,1,3) |
INHABIT (people, as a verb) excluding (out of) H (hospital) IN A BIT |
IN A BIT (later)
|
23 | Chemical decomposition of ICI union card (4,4) |
Anagram of (decomposition of) ICI and U (Union, as a term in mathematics) and CARD URIC ACID* |
URIC ACID (chemical, ACID of the purine group) |
25 | Is no longer viewed from behind (3) |
SAW (viewed) reversed (from behind) WAS< |
WAS (is no longer) |
26 | Boy busy with a composition (6) |
SON (boy) + AT (busy) + A SON AT A |
SONATA (musical composition) |
27 | Addition of new information – on Tinder profile one hopes it will? (8) |
UP (increase) + DATING (Tinder is a DATING website / app) – presumably those seeking a DATE and have added new information to their profile hope they will be attractive to an increasing number of potential DATEs UP DATING |
UPDATING (adding new information) |
28 | Eighteen in the round – but not doing the nineteenth? (8) |
TEE TOTAL (there are a TOTAL of eighteen TEEs in a full round of golf) TEE TOTAL |
TEETOTAL (descriptive of someone who doesn’t drink alcohol. In colloquial terminology, the NINETEENTH HOLE is the Clubhouse bar or other hostelry where the players participate in alcoholic beverages) |
29 | A name for cutting edge (5) |
PRO (in favour of; for) contained in (cutting) (A + N [name]) A (PRO) N |
APRON (rim; edge) |
Down | |||
1 | Be "brave"? Tonto’s first to flee N American Indian spirit (7) |
MAN IT OUT (an exhortation to withstand or endure defiantly; be brave!) excluding (to flee) the final T [first letter of [first] TONTO) It’s obviously the second T that has to flee to generate the word MANITOU MANITOU |
MANITOU (spirit or sacred object among certain Native American tribes,especially the Algonquian peoples of North America) |
2 | Ordain, say, romance should rise in value (9) |
TALE (fictional story; lie; romance) reversed (should rise; down clue) contained in (in) PRIZE (value) PR (ELAT<) IZE |
PRELATIZE (to invest a person as a priest; ordain) |
3 | Force back Scots dancing around piano (5) |
REEL (Scottish dance) containing (about) P (piano) RE (P) EL |
REPEL (force back) |
4 | Guys will become attached to me, "Two-time Maggie" (4,3) |
TEN (the entry at TEN across is TWO) + T (time) + PEG (diminutive of Margaret, as is Maggie) giving TWO-TIME MAGGIE TEN T PEG |
TENT PEG (the GUYS of a tent are attached to TENT PEGs to hold the TENT in position) |
5 | Pooped! In motion, scooping nasty bits of tofu up (3,2,3) |
OFF (started; in motion) containing (scooping) an anagram of [nasty bits of] TOFU UP O (UT OF PU*) FF |
OUT OF PUFF (exhausted; pooped) |
6 | In-form individual in French national team dismissed (5) |
ELEVEN (a word for team if there are ELEVEN people in the team, e.g. football, cricket) excluding (dismissed) N (national) ELEVE |
ÉLÈVE (French [in France] for pupil, someone in the class; in-form) |
7 | Half-heartedly went through escalating house checks (7) |
PEED (went [to the loo] excluding one of the middle Es [half-heartedly]) contained in (through) SEMI (semi-detached house) reversed (rising; down clue) IM (PED) ES< |
IMPEDES (hinders; obstructs; checks) |
14 | With hint of asteism aboard hapless Titanic: "The suspense is killing me!" (1,4,4) |
(W [with] + A [first letter of {hint of} ASTEISM}]) contained in (aboard) an anagram of (hapless) TITANIC I CAN’T (W A) IT* |
I CAN’T WAIT (phrase implying that the suspense is killing me) |
16 | 15th Century house found in narrow street, overlooking river (9) |
(CAST [found, in relation to the CASTing or founding of metals] contained in [in] LANE [narrow street]) + R (river) LAN (CAST) E R |
LANCASTER (reference the Royal House of LANCASTER. one of two branches from the House of Plantaganet that fought the other branch [House of York] in the Wars of the Roses in the 15th century) |
18 | Where they put e.g. the soup in the supermarket song? (7) |
CAN ZONE (the area where the cans are stored. Many soups are sold in cans, though there are a lot nowadays in packets or sachets) CAN ZONE |
CANZONE (a song or air resembling, but less elaborate than, a madrigal) |
19 | Predictably, crossword constructors in America are looking up "aluminium" 2,5) |
(US [crossword constructors – which could include both setters and solvers as both ‘build up’ the entries in the grid] contained in [in] USA (America]) all reversed (looking up [down clue]) + AL (chemical symbol for aluminium) (A (S U) SU)< AL |
AS USUAL (customary; predictably) |
20 | Where agreement ended War on Art in Barking (7) |
Anagram of (barking) ON ART IN TRIANON* |
TRIANON (The treaty of Peace after the First World War between the Allied and Associated Powers and Hungary was signed at TRIANON palace in Versailles in 1920) |
22 | Small scale turning up in buffet-car breakfast (5) |
BRACT (hidden word reversed [turning up in ; down clue] in BUFFET-CAR BREAKFAST) BRACT< |
BRACT (scale can be defined as a specialized leaf or BRACT, which in turn is defined as a specialized leaf, usually smaller than the foliage leaves, with a single flower or inflorescence growing in its axil) |
24 | I arranged for ad in i (5) |
I + an anagram of (arranged for) AD IN I NDIA* |
INDIA (INDIA is the international radio communication codeword for the letter I) |
Great blog Dunc. Thanks for parsing of MANITOU, PRELATIZE and ECMEMA(I was thinking MAZE not being a frequenter of Greek Taverna)
Thought QUAILING ,TEETOTAL amd CANZONE were brilliant
It was tough even by Nimrod standards and nowhere near a clean solve for me (loads of check button)
But as usual with N, when its done and dusted you say-what was wrong with any of that- I think writing in general is the order in which the words go.JH being a master. When’s the first novel coming out?
Nimrod at his most beastly – my piece of paper has neat writing, untidy writing, different colour pen use, and Tippex and I still couldn’t finish it. So thank you to Duncan for his assistance with my outstanding entries
However, to make up for the fact that I lost the battle, can I point out that if you look at the down solutions, there are creatures to be found in the end letters of one word and the start of the one below, although I’m not sure what sort of creature I’ve found between 7d and 20d, and I’ve no idea what goes between 6d an 16d. The across rows reveal a PERTH PINT but I’m not sure what one of them is either
Thanks to Nimrod for a proper battle of a crossword – I’m still trying to work out why you are here on a Thursday?
@2 crypticsue
Thanks for identifying what I have missed. If you add in the PEDESTRIAN, crossing between IMPEDES and TRIANON, all the animals / birds relate to PEDESTRIAN crossings -TOUCAN, ZEBRA, PELICAN and PUFFIN. A bit more research tells me that a PEGASUS crossing is apparently designed especially for horse riders. Finally, there is the LEVEL crossing.
There is a nina on types of crossings. TOUCAN, ZEBRA, PELICAN, PEGASUS, PEDESTRIAN, LEVEL hidden in the down columns.
Sorry, didn’t notice this was already mentioned.
Should add many thanks to Duncan for explaining it all. Didn’t get ELEVE or TWEEPS both unknown words for me. Several other words I had to look up but worked out correctly.
I parsed 19d slightly differently. Given that it is Nimrod, I felt that, rather than USA for America, it was probably US with the A coming from “are” as in the unit of area.
@Duncan and Hovis – D’oh – that’s the trouble with Mr H’s crosswords, he mangles the poor old brain so much, you can’t see the perfectly obvious
Thanks crypticsue and dunc for the hidden gems-thats the thing-you can be exhausted from the struggle-easier if its s straightforward nina which can assist the solve but no Mr Nice Guy today.’E’s got is reputation roun the manor to think of, guv.
Thanks to duncan and Nimrod
I have 15a as:
OVERCAST = SUNLESS, presumably (i.e it is possible to presume it represents) IS (‘S)UNLESS, then OVERCAST (overthrow) IF NOT – NOT IF = UNLESS
Am I alone in not understanding any of the explanations of 15a? Attempted this on my day off following a day at the races, and will go back to work tomorrow for a rest!
Thanks Nimrod, Duncan
DNF (tweeps, + a couple I shouldn’t have given up on), but I mostly found it quite ‘normal’.
@Dansar: eh?
fwiw, I had sunless = overcast, then [s]unless was removing S[un] (overcast, presumably)
I think James’s reading for 15a makes sense. Overcast overcast becoming sunless sunless, i.e. (s)unless with ‘presumably’ thrown in to confuse us even more. I hope Nimrod will clarify.
Hovis @12
I initially had that parsing too but I rejected it for three reasons
None of my dictionaries have S as an abbreviation for SUN (perhaps it’s in Chambers)
PRESUMABLY seems redundant and a bit unfair to just “bung in”
I can’t think of any phrase where UNLESS can be replaced by IF NOT, (perhaps others can)
With any most setters I would reject my own parsing as too contorted, not if it’s Nimrod, (unless it’s Nimrod)
If not correct, the parsing needs to be changed? Sort of works for me.
I admit when solving (?) the puzzle, I just took ‘overcast presumably’ to mean ‘having (one) too many letters’ but wasn’t overly convinced.
Me @13 delete “any in the last sentence”
Hovis @14
Thank you
When I first read your post I thought “of course, why didn’t I think of that”, but the more I thought about, it didn’t feel quite right.
I think it’s because the “not” belongs to “correct”, rather than to “if”. This becomes clear if we change “not correct” to “wrong”.
Like you, I hope Nimrod will clarify, but he didn’t in the case of a similar lack of consensus on 23 Feb so I won’t hold my breath.
A cricket team during a match would be fielding unless/if not batting.
Too much for me. After about an hour I’d done the bottom left corner. After that I more or less ground to a halt. No fun at all. I don’t find Azed this hard.
Almost there. We struggled in the NE corner, eventually got SUNLESS and (from crossing letters and definition but couldn’t parse) IMPEDES. That left us with 9ac and 6dn and we thought 9ac could be ‘twerps’ (a wally being a twerp, but again couldn’t parse) but never thought of 6dn being a French word – all a wordfinder came up with was ‘exeme’ – an archaic form of ‘exempt’.
But we felt quite chuffed to get QUAILING, ECZEMA and CANZONE. Failed to spot the nina, of course.
As to Nimrod dropping in to clarify, I think you’ll find he has a policy of not commenting on blogs.
Thanks, Nimrod and Duncan.
As other have (almost) said, impossibly difficult. Next time, maybe.
24D I thought the definition was I (the call sign for India), an anagram of “ad in i”, with the italicising of “i” a distraction.
Thanks to Nimrod and duncanshiell.
Managed about two thirds of this but I am not at all surprised that the rest wete beyond us
Thanks to Nimrod and full marks to Duncan for solving the b****r