Prize puzzle from the Weekend FT of September 7, 2019
My first-in was the easy 8dn and was followed by 1ac. I found the bottom-left quadrant the most challenging but my last-in was 1dn after entering a wrong answer for 12ac. There are some typically fine Mudd clues, notably 2dn (CLUELESS) and 13ac (ENDEARMENT) but also three in which either I am not understanding the wordplay correctly or possibly the wordplay is faulty. These are 27ac (ORIGIN), 8dn (RELATE) and 17dn (BRIGHTON).
| Across | ||
| 1 | CUCKOO | Cracked layer (6) |
| Double definition, slightly cryptic in each case | ||
| 4 | SPRINTER | Small item of office equipment one runs (8) |
| S (small) + PRINTER (item of office equipment) | ||
| 9 | MOUSSE | Sweet little animal biting tail of puss (6) |
| [pus]S in (biting) MOUSE (little animal) | ||
| 10 | ATYPICAL | Different capital built around capital in Yerevan (8) |
| Y[erevan] in (around) anagram (built) of CAPITAL | ||
| 12 | AXLE | Gripping back of wheel, pull shaft (4) |
| [whee]L in (gripping) AXE (pull). I messed myself up by initially entering what turned out to be a wrong answer (HILT). | ||
| 13 | ENDEARMENT | “Love Me Tender” an abomination? (10) |
| Anagram (abomination) of ME TENDER AN. “Love Me Tender” is the name of a (great) Elvis Presley song. | ||
| 15 | DESSERTSPOON | Server getting no work anxious for a turnaround (12) |
| NO (no) + OP (work) + STRESSED (anxious) all backwards (for a turnaround). I do not think of a dessert spoon as a server. | ||
| 18 | POP-UP TOASTER | Breakfast item potato, supper stew (3-2,7) |
| Anagram (stew) of POTATO SUPPER | ||
| 21 | WELL I NEVER | Very much at home, always gracious! (4,1,5) |
| WELL (very much) + IN (at home) + EVER (always) | ||
| 22 | BRIG | King aboard great ship (4) |
| R (king) in (aboard) BIG (great) | ||
| 24 | LEVITATE | Hebrew welcoming a time to rise (8) |
| A (a) + T (time) in (welcoming) LEVITE (Hebrew). A Levite is a member of the Hebrew tribe of Levi (especially the branch that provided male assistants to the temple priests). | ||
| 25 | JULIET | Project about romance for girl (6) |
| LIE (romance) in (about) JUT (project) | ||
| 26 | TENDRILS | Tailor silent, dressing doctor in threads (8) |
| DR (doctor) in (dressing) anagram (tailor) of SILENT | ||
| 27 | ORIGIN | Written on reverse of cheque, popular foundation (6) |
| ORIG (written on reverse of cheque) + IN (popular). It seems to me that ‘cheque’ must clue GIRO here but, while a cheque and a giro serve similar purposes, they are strictly distinct things. And I suppose that ‘written on reverse of’ is the reversal indicator though it is not one that I find convincing. Am I missing something? | ||
| Down | ||
| 1 | COMMANDO | Company keeping order beginning to march with soldier (8) |
| OM (order, i.e. Order of Merit) + M[arch] + AND (with) in (keeping) CO (company) | ||
| 2 | CLUELESS | Stupid solver given no chance then? (8) |
| Double definition | ||
| 3 | OAST | When to feed ‘eated oven (4) |
| AS (when) in (to feed) ‘OT (‘eated) | ||
| 5 | PITTER-PATTER | Steps taken, by the sound of it, as PM and Queen talk (6-6) |
| PITT (PM) + ER (queen) + PATTER (talk) | ||
| 6 | IMPERSONAL | Possibly a “no”, simpler being detached (10) |
| Anagram (possibly) of A NO SIMPLER | ||
| 7 | TICKER | Watch the heart (6) |
| Double definition | ||
| 8 | RELATE | Describe 2nd, 6th and 7th notes (6) |
| RE (2nd note, in solfa) + LA (6th note) + TE (7th note). If Wikipedia is to be trusted, the 7th note in solfa is normally ‘ti’, or possibly ‘si’, but not ‘te’. However it acknowledges ‘te’ as a lowered seventh in a minor scale. | ||
| 11 | INSTRUMENTAL | Like some pieces, playing a part (12) |
| Double definition | ||
| 14 | NEGOTIATOR | Go and tear into incompetent middleman (10) |
| Anagram (incompetent) of GO TEAR INTO | ||
| 16 | STARLING | Winger looking to keep left (8) |
| L (left) in (to keep) STARING (looking) | ||
| 17 | BRIGHTON | Resort not left out after heading for Blackpool (8) |
| B[lackpool] + RIGHT (not left) + ON (out?). It is not clear to me how the ON of BRIGHTON is clued here. Does the ‘not’ extend to ‘out’? But that would clue IN, not ON. | ||
| 19 | TWILIT | Visible in the gloom, clown masks sick for the most part (6) |
| IL[l] (sick for the most part) in (masks) TWIT (clown) | ||
| 20 | CLOVEN | Nothing in common, stuffing knocked out – split! (6) |
| LOVE (nothing, as in tennis) in C[ommo]N | ||
| 23 | BURR | Rough edge to p-polish up (4) |
| R-RUB (p-polish) backwards (up) | ||
27ac:
Dictionaries tell me that GIRO can mean ‘giro cheque’.
If that’s all right, then this clue is fine.
One should read it as that IN is written on [after, in an Across clue] a reversal of GIRO.
Not unimportantly, in these kind of constructions Mudd – unlike many other setters – always uses a comma, as he did here.
8d:
TE is an alternative spelling of ‘ti’, the seventh tone.
17d:
I think ‘not left out’ should be seen as the opposite of ‘left out’.
The RIGHT bit is clear and – although cricket is many bridges too far for me – it might well be that
ON is the opposite of OUT (= not batting). I have seen ON clued as ‘batting’ on several occasions.
But as I said, I can easily be wrong but then others will surely correct me.
Thanks Pete (& Mudd)
thanks Mudd & Pete.
To expand on Sil’s comment on 17 down, the expression “right-on”, meaning trendy, is the opposite of “left out”.
Nice puzzle, thanks both, and thanks Sil for explaining 17d. As for 17d, right-on in my era vernacular is an approval expression, so it doesn’t quite work, but a mere quibblet. Thought axle for 12 straight away, but took a bit to wake up to axe = pull, as in eg pull someone from a team. No op stressed was fun.
.. meant thanks Sil for 27ac
27a. To flesh out what Sil has written, in the 1960s very few people had bank accounts but many more had accounts with the Post Office. The governmment decided to introduce the continental Giro system into the UK and the Post Office was given the remit. One of their initiatives was the introduction of the girocheque which was a cheque in every respect except not drawn on a bank but on the PO. With later computerisation the name was shortened to giro.
I thoroughly enjoyed the puzzle and thanks to you both.
Sil, Thank you for helping me out regarding Giros. I never used a giro and was not living in Europe in the days when they were widely used so I know little about them. Wikipedia mentions girocheques, I see (written as one word).
psmith, Thanks for your comment. I was not familiar with “right on” meaning trendy.
trenodia, Thank you for filling in that history.
Thanks Mudd and Pete
Entertaining puzzle as always from Mudd and one that I found a little harder than normal for some reason. Not helped by making the same mistake with HILT / AXLE. Was familiar (from a distance and only through crosswords) with GIRO = cheque.
Didn’t ever work out the word play to OAST – had gone down a homophone for HOST path, so thanks for setting me straight there. Not sure whether I fully worked through the RIGHT ON logic, so good to see that here too.
Finished in the top left hand corner by finally correcting CLUELESS (from HOPELESS) at 2d and AXLE at 12a.
Thanks to all for comment and explanation – I couldn’t get ‘Oast’ either. I suspect a lack of familiarity with unemployment in the ’80s for everyone not fully conversant with a giro. It’s how the dole was paid.
I think I’m persuaded by the batting explanation to explain ‘On’ being the opposite of ‘Out’ in 17d.
I really liked 1a: it was succinct and playful.