An educational (for me) solve from the Ace of Hearts this week…will OLIVER leave us asking for more?!…
The preamble states that:
“In OLIVER, four clues are normal and their answers are associated with a keyword which must be highlighted in the completed grid. From the answer to every other clue, a letter must be deleted wherever it appears before entry; definitions refer to the full unmutilated answer, wordplay and numbers in brackets to the grid entry. The omitted letters in clue order give the etymology of the keyword.”
My approach to this kind of ‘removed letter’ device is usually to try a bit of cold solving and either pencil-work or mental/alphabetical arithmetic to get to a point where coinciding letters in crossing solutions have to be a particular letter, usually meaning that I can make an educated guess as to where the beginning or remainder of those words fit…and so on, until a bit of traction is gained…(if that makes sense?! A bit like a game of Connect 4 with letters, dropping them down from the top, to see where they match the acrosses … no, that makes even less sense!…never mind…)
The fact that there are four normal clues complicates things a bit, but after a couple of runs through I had a few that were obviously too long for their slots, and would need a letter or letters removing, and hence some of the aforementioned juggling.
Slow but steady progress was made, until I eventually hit on a couple that just fitted – 23D HOT DOG, and 36A ALLEYOOP. I resisted the urge to just Go-ogle these terms, as they weren’t completely familiar to me, but my solving notes have a questioning ‘surfing/skateboarding?‘ at this point. So after an hour or so, helped by these and the long anagram at 28A (F)OR ALL THE WORLD, I had the bottom half pretty much complete, but only 2D (F)EINT in the top half.
A few more sessions later, probably totalling another hour, and I had most of the top half done, including 10A WIPEOUT and 6A FAKIE – so again looks like we are in the realms of my earlier guess. I also remembered to check out the ‘omitted letters in clue order’, and started to piece together something like ‘NICKNAME OF ALAN G?LF??DUS SKATEBOARDER.
At this point I did succumb to a bit of r-e-search, to discover there is a US SKATEBOARDER called ALAN GELFAND who, around 1978, invented the (now ubiquitous) ‘flip/jump’ move which was eponymously named the ‘OLLIE‘ from his nickname (also explaining the title).
FAKIE, WIPEOUT, HOTDOG and ALLEYOOP are all skateboarding terms, and the OLLIE can be found in the top left quadrant – tipped up/backwards in the style of a board being flipped up in said move!
As I said, all educational to me, as I missed out on the skateboarding thing in my youth – I’m only 4 years younger than Alan G, but I obviously had my nose in too many books at the time, and I have probably travelled a total of about 200 shaky metres on skateboards in my entire life! My teenage son and his mates are more into scootering and bunny-hops than skateboards and ollies.
I can’t see any particular significance of the date of publication – i.e. there doesn’t seem to have been a ‘Eureka’ moment from young OLLIE when he did his first move exactly forty years ago in Oct/Nov 1979, as it seems to have been more of an evolutionary thing – so maybe this is just a homage from the Ace of Hearts to a previous (and/or current?) passion?
I didn’t find the clueing too difficult – certainly not at the harder end of the EV spectrum, but things were definitely complicated by the constant mental adjustment for word lengths and the uncertainly of how many times an omitted letter might occur. Looking back, the clues for the boarding terms do have some helpful pointers – ALLEYOOP mentions a ‘sporting move’, FAKIE even mentions a ‘movement on deck’, and to HOTDOG is probably a reasonably well-known surfing/skateboarding term to most people(?), although I am more recently familiar with it as an FI winner’s celebratory spins in front of the grandstands…or am I confusing HOTDOGs with DONUTS in this case?!
Some relatively obscure words – KENSPECK, ROKELAY, WENTLETRAP, PALUDAL, DETORTION, INCULT and LARNAKES all needed looking up for confirmation – but there was enough in the wordplay and crossers to help get to them, and it also helped when I eventually got the other long anagram at 16A.
Thanks to the Ace of Hearts for an interesting challenge, and hopefully I have it all covered off below.
Across | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Clue No | Deleted letter – Original Solution | Entry | Clue (definition underlined) / Logic/Parsing (wordplay leads to adjusted entry, not original solution) |
|
1 | N – SEEDPLANT | SEEDPLAT | Flowering shrub noticed by old plot of ground! (8) / SEE + D (notice + d ?!) + PLAT (archaic for plot of ground) |
|
6 | (Thematic/normal clue) | FAKIE | One stopping cook’s movement on deck (5) / FAK_E (cook, as in cook the books) around (stopped by) I (one) |
|
10 | (Thematic/normal clue) | WIPEOUT | South African man on record backtracking in intelligence disaster (7) / WI_T (intelligence) around PE (EP, extended play record, backtracking) + OU (a man, Afrikaans) |
|
12 | I – ELDIN | ELDN | Departs for Australia in style to get fuel in Perth (4) / EL( |
|
13 | C – INCULT | INULT | Rarely coarse, son shuns offensive action (5) / IN( |
|
14 | K – LARNAKES | LARNAES | An earl’s assorted ornamental chests (7) / anag, i.e. assorted, of AN EARLS |
|
15 | N – WENTLETRAP | WETLETRAP | The French on water net shellfish (9) / WET (water) + LE (the, in French) + TRAP (net) |
|
16 | A – DISSERVICEABLE | DISSERVICEBLE | Injurious putting Catholic among radical disbelievers (13) / C (Catholic) inserted into DISSERVI_EBLE (anag, i.e. radical, of DISBELIEVERS) |
|
17 | M – ESTEEMED | ESTEEED | Respected horse injected with ecstasy after end of race (7) / E (end letter of racE) + STEE_D (horse) around (injected with) E (ecstasy) |
|
20 | E – CORNEAL GRAFT | CORNAL GRAFT | Order Lorcan to work hard after eye operation (11, two words) / CORNAL (anag, i.e. order, of LORCAN) + GRAFT (work hard) |
|
25 | O – DETORTION | DETRTIN | Journalist returns with translator initially to investigate network unravelling, once (7) / DE (Ed, editor or journalist, returns) + TR (translator) + TIN (initial letters of ‘To Investigate Network’) |
|
28 | F – FOR ALL THE WORLD | OR ALL THE WORLD | Precisely tell old Harrow frolics (13, four words) / anag, i.e. frolics, of TELL OLD HARROW |
|
29 | A – TANGLEMENT | TNGLEMENT | Explosive catching leg badly, people in perplexed state (9) / TN_T (explosive) around (catching) (GLE (anag, i.e. badly, of LEG) + MEN (people) |
|
31 | L – DALESMAN | DAESMAN | District Attorney names criminal northerner (7) / DA (District Attorney) + ESMAN (anag, i.e. criminal, of NAMES) |
|
32 | A – PALUDAL | PLUDL | Place Deputy Lieutenant around university concerned with boggy ground (5) / PL (place) + DL (Deputy Lieutenant), around U (university) |
|
33 | N – OLENT | OLET | Aromatic odour primarily to hire (4) / O (primary letter of Odour) + LET (to hire) |
|
34 | G – GUARANIS | UARANIS | Indian princesses east of Ukraine for foreign bread (7) / UA (International Vehicle Reg. code for Ukraine) + RANIS (indian princesses) |
|
35 | E – GLEEMAN | GLMAN | Old musician once set off about lecturer getting married (5) / G_AN (archaic for gone, or set off) around L (lecturer) + M (married) |
|
36 | (Thematic/normal clue) | ALLEYOOP | Sporting move to roar back into a headless loop (8) / A + LLEY (yell, or roar, back) + ( |
|
Down | ||||
Clue No | Deleted letter – Original Solution | Entry | Clue (definition underlined) / Logic/Parsing (wordplay leads to adjusted entry, not original solution) |
|
1 | L – SWINDLER | SWINDER | Conman to persuade socialists to go back round (7) / S_DER (reds, or Socialists, back) aound WIN (persuade) |
|
2 | F – FEINT | EINT | Pretend a German is on time (4) / EIN (a, in German) + T (time) |
|
3 | A – DELAPSE | DELPSE | Sink down, not currently dead, sleep uneasily (6) / D (dead) + ELPSE (anag, i.e. uneasily, of SLEEP) |
|
4 | N – LUCERNE | LUCERE | Solved clue about cattle food (6) / LUCE (anag, i.e. solved, of CLUE) + RE (about) |
|
5 | D – TWADDLING | TWALING | Chattering in some places expressing surprise return into ring (7) / T_ING (ring) around WAL (law, interjection, as in lord! – expressing surprise – returning) |
|
6 | U – FORECOURT | FORECORT | Ancient vestibule beneficial to gigolo, say, taking out soprano (8) / FOR (beneficial to) E( |
|
7 | S – ASSENTER | AENTER | One who acquiesces about to join in (6) / A (about) + ENTER (to join in) |
|
8 | S – IDEALIST | IDEALIT | Dreamer dismounted beneath view (7) / IDEA (view, opinion) + LIT (dismounted) |
|
9 | K – KENSPECK | ENSPEC | Recognisable Scottish entity heads to party’s European congress (6) / ENS (entity, being) + PEC (first letters, or heads, of ‘Party’s European Congress’) |
|
11 | A – PULSATOR | PULSTOR | Machine turned up to deposit nearly fifty inside (7) / PU (turned ‘up’) + L (fifty) + STOR( |
|
18 | T – ENTITLEMENT | ENILEMEN | Something which one can claim, topless Eileen excited males (8) / ENILE (anag, i.e. excited, of ( |
|
19 | E – AFTERSUN | AFTRSUN | Skin ointment a female turns out (7) / A + F (female) + TRSUN (anag, i.e. out, of TURNS) |
|
20 | B – CORNBALL | CORNALL | American boor losing weight in English county (7) / CORN( |
|
21 | O – AUTOMATA | AUTMATA | Robots say, allegedly tested at malls throughout Utah, are originally rejected (7) / reversed (rejected) initial (original letters of ‘Allegedly Tested At Malls Throughout Utah, Are’ |
|
22 | A – HANDCLASP | HNDCLSP | American welcome in hotel, North Dakota, calls up regularly (7) / H (hotel) + ND (North Dakota) + CLSP (regular letters from ‘CaLlS uP’) |
|
23 | (Thematic/normal clue) | HOTDOG | Show off sausage roll (6) / double defn. – to HOTDOG can be to show off; and a HOTDOG can be a bread roll with a sausage in it |
|
24 | R – ALLSTAR | ALLSTA | Having notable players in football stadium (6) / hidden ‘word’ in ‘footbALL STAdium’ |
|
26 | D – EDENTAL | EENTAL | Like sloths perhaps climbing behind small space inside (6) / E_TAL (late, or behind time, climbing) around EN (small space) |
|
27 | E – ROKELAY | ROKLAY | Scottish woman’s outer garment is fine in right situation (6) / R (right) + LAY (situation), around OK (fine) |
|
30 | R – RADIO | ADIO | Transmit recorded sound waves not socially acceptable (4) / A( |
Sad to see yet another excellent EV blog attract no comments. It’s always a good sign for a puzzle when one enjoys it despite having no interest in the theme, as was the case here. I was delighted to discover the wonderful word WENTLETRAP and am determined to create as many opportunities as possible to use it!
Thanks, cruciverbophile…the lack of comments is not a huge issue…we know the lurkers are out there as any mistakes are usually picked up on fairly pronto!
I agree – WENTLETRAP sounds like a wonderful word. I’m sure you could work it into a bit of Viz-style Roger Mellie innuendo…
If anyone is interested in locking horns again with the
AoSAoH, head over to today’s Inquisitor 1621 ‘Stone the Crows’ in the ‘i weekend’ paper – should still be in the shops tomorrow – with a similar removed-letters device and five ‘normal/thematic’ answers this time!You mean AoH Mc_rapper67!!
A lurker
QED…(;+>)
I don’t do the EV very often but I did do this one.
I wonder if anyone else did the same as me. I entered FAGIN at 6a and then wasted ages looking for other OLIVER (OLLIE) references.
Thanks to mc_rapper67 and The Ace of Hearts.