Independent 10,586 by Eccles

Eccles is back in the midweek spot today.

As we have come to expect, this was a fun solve with lots of good surfaces and neat wordplay.
We had to check the Mexican in 28ac, but otherwise there were no unusual words.
We were initially totally stumped by 24d (our LOI, but the penny finally dropped as we were writing up the blog.
Unusually, there seem to be superfluous words in the clues for 4d and 17d, but the surfaces work well. However, we may be missing something.

image of grid

ACROSS
1. Youngster bored by liberal society (4)
CLUB

CUB (youngster) round or ‘bored by’ L (liberal)

4. Component of cell made of metal, mostly, with part hiding hole (10)
CHROMOSOME

CHROMe (metal) without the last letter or ‘mostly’ SOME (part) round or ‘hiding’ O (hole)

9. Whisky glass emptied over, say, picnic food (6,4)
SCOTCH EGGS

SCOTCH (whisky) GlasS (without the middle letters or ’emptied’) round or ‘over’ EG (say)

10. A path out of here? (4)
AWAY

A WAY (path)

11. Unusually, perhaps, notice bishop replacing centrepiece of altar (6)
ADVERB

ADVERt (notice) with B (bishop) replacing the ‘t’ (middle letter or ‘centrepiece’ of altar)

12. Decoration‘s gold handle not hollowed out (8)
ORNAMENT

OR (gold) NAME (handle) NoT without the middle letter or ‘hollowed out’

14. In addition, has time for school singer (4)
ALTO

ALsO (in addition) with T (time) replacing the ‘s’ (school)

16. Experienced nurses vote, with 50% absent, to be shown on TV (10)
TELECASTED

TASTED (experienced) round or ‘nursing’ ELECtion (vote) with the latter half missing

18. Gee, it’s obvious learner must be included in links? (4,6)
GOLF COURSE

G (gee) OF COURSE (it’s obvious) round or ‘including’ L (learner)

22. Body temperature taken roughly (2,2)
OR SO

tORSO (body) with the ‘t’ (temperature) omitted or ‘taken’

23. Shy character keen to be involved in disorder (8)
MEEKNESS

An anagram of KEEN (anagrind is ‘to be involved’) in MESS (disorder)

25. Bosom buddy heads out in large car (6)
ESTATE

bEST mATE (bosom buddy) with both first letters or ‘heads’ omitted or ‘out’

27. Black cat put in front grave (4)
TOMB

B (black) with TOM (cat) in front

28. Drive round front of ramshackle old Mexican Villa, and settle there (4,6)
DROP ANCHOR

DR (drive) round R (first letter or ramshackle) O (old) PANCHO (‘Mexican Villa’ – an electronic search reveals that Pancho Villa was a Mexican revolutionary general in the Mexican Revolution)

29. Detached wanderer‘s stomach produced wind before religious festival, reportedly (10)
TUMBLEWEED

TUM (stomach) BLEW (produced wind) + a homophone (‘reportedly’) of EID (religious festival)

30. Lean in a certain manner? Not us, unusually (4)
RELY

suRELY (in a certain manner) without ‘us’ reversed or ‘unusually’

DOWN
2. Put Penny off getting drugged (5)
LACED

pLACED (put) without the ‘p’ (penny)

3. Gambler going to be richer (6,3)
BETTER OFF

BETTER (gambler) OFF (going)

4. Slightly supportive of Charlie and other half initially going to live together (7)
COHABIT

A BIT (slightly) after or ‘supporting’ (in a down clue) C (Charlie in the phonetic alphabet) O H (first or ‘initial’ letters of other half) – ‘going’ seems to be superfluous here

5. African’s guide dog every so often left with large toy (3,4)
RAG DOLL

Every third letter (‘every so often’) of afRicAn’s GuiDe dOg + L (left) L (large)

6. A prickly character chases Mike regarding order (7)
MASONIC

A SONIC (‘prickly character’ – Sonic the Hedgehog) after or ‘chasing’ M (Mike in the phonetic alphabet)

7. Army claims war mends fences (5)
SWARM

Hidden in or ‘fenced by’ claimS WAR Mends

8. Country‘s trouble captured in film (5)
EGYPT

GYP (trouble) in or ‘captured by’ ET (film)

13. Wants to be observed taking daughter back (5)
NEEDS

SEEN (observed) round or ‘taking’ D (daughter) reversed or ‘back’

15. Wanton son visiting Cornish town (5)
LOOSE

S (son) in or ‘visiting’ LOOE (Cornish town)

17. Automobile association having tantrums looking over vehicle (6,3)
SPORTS CAR

RAC (Automobile association) STROPS (tantrums) reversed or ‘over’ – ‘looking’ seems superfluous

19. Late, drove crazily – extremely unsafe (7)
OVERDUE

An anagram of DROVE (anagrind is ‘crazily’) + UnsafE (first and last or ‘extreme’ letters only)

20. Patty is enthralled by rare fish (7)
RISSOLE

IS in or ‘enthralled by’ R (rare) SOLE (fish)

21. Gemstone dealer Mark Mills (7)
EMERALD

An anagram of DEALER M (mark) – anagrind is ‘mills’

23. Test, and test regularly, Catholic’s composition (5)
MOTET

MOT (test) + alternate or ‘regular’ letters of tEsT

24. Spaced out grandchild looking up to get food (5)
KEBAB

We were really baffled by this one until we tumbled to the instruction to ‘space out’ grandchild into K (1,000 – grand) + BABE (child) reversed or ‘looking up’ (in a down clue)

26. Republican blocked payment for inflammatory poster (5)
TROLL

R (Republican) in or ‘blocking’ TOLL (payment)

 

13 comments on “Independent 10,586 by Eccles”

  1. Rabbit Dave

    This was an absolutely top-notch puzzle and great fun as we unfailingly get from Eccles.  Many thanks to him and to B&J.

  2. copmus

    Great stuff.Thanks all.

  3. Hovis

    Excellent as always. Struggled to parse RELY but got there in the end. Thanks to Eccles and Bertandjoyce.

  4. Kathryn's Dad

    Yet another pleasing midweek puzzle from Eccles.  Sound clueing, good surface readings, all round good entertainment.  KEBAB was the only one I couldn’t parse (although only half parsed DROP ANCHOR, where I got as far as PANCHO and didn’t bother to look further to discover the ‘revolutionary’ bit).

    Thanks to S & Bs.

  5. crypticsue

    I like Eccles Wednesdays – this one was as enjoyable as ever.   I did know the ‘revolutionary’ too

    Thanks to Eccles and B&J

  6. jane

    Another very enjoyable offering from this setter although I wanted ‘on’ to be included in 30a and I did have to check on the religious festival.   I was another who found the parsing of 24d quite a challenge!

    Thanks to Eccles and to B&J for the review.

  7. Bill_Poster

    Thanks Eccles, and to B&J for the parsing of 24D, which I’m now suitably impressed by!


  8. 7 down is absolutely superb in an altogether brilliant puzzle.
    Thanks all

  9. baerchen

    always a treat. My favourite today was the Pancho Villa ref in DROP ANCHOR, but plenty of other goodies as per. Many thanks to Eccles, B & J

  10. allan_c

    We didn’t have too much trouble with this, although a few clues kept us guessing for a while.  In 4ac we were thinking of electrical cells at first, and with clues like 11ac we must remember that an adverb in the clue may sometimes (as here) be a definition by example.  And we liked DROP ANCHOR once we remembered about Pancho Villa – a very neat clue.

    Thanks, Eccles and B&J.

  11. Sil van den Hoek

    Yes, superb stuff.
    From a setter who has obviously taken over the place of the much-missed and appreciated Dac.
    And, in my opinion, his style is not unsimilar [yes, it’s in Collins] to Arachne’s (at another place, of course).

    All the more annoying that there was something not right in 4dn.
    But we’ll forgive him, don’t we?
    Like we’ll forgive Boris, or don’t we?

    Many thanks once more to our lucky blogging ‘team’ & to Eccles.

  12. Eccles

    Thanks to B&J for the blog, and to all who commented.

    4d, I just considered ‘going to’ as a link in the same way ‘leading to’ would be. In 17a, I was taking ‘looking over’ to be the reversal indicator as a whole, like in 24d with ‘looking up’ – although I see that neither is perfect. If I had noticed the repetition I would have tried to avoid it (just as I would have tried to use the present tense in in 26d if I had noticed that I hadn’t!).

  13. Sil van den Hoek

    Re 4dn: that’s ultimately fine then (even if it still feels a bit awkward to me – probably just a matter of taste).

Comments are closed.