Methuselah is the setter on this week’s Tuesday puzzle
Tuesday is usually theme day in the Independent and there was a clear theme today which Methuselah has developed very well with further use of both parts of the gateway entry at 14/1
It took me a while to identify all the component parts of the anagram of POST-IMPRESSIONIST as I wasn’t sure immediately whether the entry at 1 was going to be IMPRESSIONIST or IMPRESSIONISM
I liked the way Methuselah cross referenced POST-IMPRESSIONIST, IMPRESSIONIST and POST elsewhere in the clues.
I thought the wordplay in many cases was outstanding. Intricate wordplay with many component parts is the type of wordplay that I most enjoy.
There is one clue however that has defeated me and that is the one at 23 down. I think the answer is SEXTET but there are at least four possible words that each satisfy both possible definitions of group and number (piece of music). See detailed blog below.
However, I don’t see how the wordplay works for any of them, beyond thinking that SET is a container meaning group. It is the ‘a precise [number]’ that defeats me. I can see that EXACT can mean precise which makes SEXTET a distinct possibility for the entry but I can’t see how to exclude the AC in the centre of EXACT. I also wondered whether ‘precise number’ was another term for the mathematical concept of a perfect number. 6 is a perfect number as it is equal to the sum of its factors, 1 2 and 3, so SEXTET and SESTET would both work for that idea. I expect that I am missing something blindingly obvious and look forward to being a bit embarrassed when I am told how the clue works.
I also liked the clues for ROB BRYDON and [Steve] COOGAN but I can understand that these clues may be a bit impenetrable to solvers who are not up to speed on British television .personalities.
Georges SEURAT was a new artist for me. I was OK with MONET and CEZANNE.
At 11 across I was thinking of EARTH for a while before I realised it had to be TERRA given the crossing letters.
SURINAME was a solution to Worldle recently so it wasn’t too far from the forefront of my mind when I came to parse 20 across.
I could wax lyrical about other clues, e.g. the one for EMULATES where Methuselah no longer has the hots and TIGHT KNIT where it was we had to form an anagram of HIKING without an anagram indicator being present, but suffice to say I really enjoyed this puzzle even if I can’t crack 23 down.
Thanks to Methuselah for a challenging crossword.
No | Detail |
Across | |
1 |
See 14 [POST-] IMPRESSIONIST |
10 |
1 mafioso pursues crime after kicking drug (3,6) ROB BRYDON (reference ROB BRYDON [born 1965], Welsh actor, comedian, IMPRESSIONIST [entry at 1 across] , television presenter, singer and writer) ROBBERY (crime) excluding (kicking) E (ecstasy; drug) + DON ([American] slang for a Mafia boss) ROB BRY DON |
11 |
14-1’s sphere about to absorb, er, everyone’s sphere (5) TERRA (Latin and Italian word for planet earth, the sphere on which we all live) ART (the field or sphere in which the POST-IMPRESSIONISTs [14 / 1 entry] worked) reversed (about) containing (to absorb) ER T (ER) RA< |
12 |
Item worn by woman asleep next to Bond (7) NIGHTIE (clothing often worn by women when asleep although I reckon men can also wear NIGHTIEs. Perhaps the technical term in that case is nightshirt) NIGH (near to; next to) + TIE (bond) NIGH TIE |
13 |
See 24 Down [PAUL] CEZANNE |
14 / 1 |
Description of movement‘s frequently a mess if Spooner spits it out (4-13) POST-IMPRESSIONIST (descriptive of an art movement that followed [POST] he period dominated by the IMPRESSIONISTS) Anagram of (out) MSI (letters 2, 4 and 6 [frequently] of A MESS IF) and SPOONER SPITS IT POST–IMPRESSIONIST* |
16 |
A couple of cricket sides seen at intervals (2-3-3) ON AND OFF (reference the ON side AND the OFF side on a cricket pitch) ON-AND-OFF (intermittent, occasional. at intervals) double definition ON-AND-OFF |
20 |
13 or 22 possibly taking over independent nation (8) SURINAME (a nation in South America) SURNAME (the entries at 13 across and 22 down are CEZANNE and COOGAN, both of which are SURNAMEs) containing (taking) I (Independent) SUR (I) NAME |
21 |
Jelly available in tea garden (4) AGAR (jelly prepared from seaweeds of various kinds used in bacteria-culture, medicine, glue-making, silk-dressing, and cooking) AGAR (hidden word in [available in] TEA GARDEN) AGAR |
24 |
Bit of fruit leading to sinful occasion’s a banana skin (7) PITFALL (hidden danger or unsuspected difficulty; banana skin can be defined similarly) PIT (fruit stone; piece of fruit) + FALL (lapse into sin) PIT FALL |
25 |
Old 1 and silent 1 each losing a million (3-4) ONE-TIME (past; old) MONET (reference Claude MONET [1840-1926], French painter and founder of IMPRESSIONIST [1 across] painting) excluding (losing) M [million] ) + MIME (descriptive of the performance a silent IMPRESSIONIST [1 across] on stage or in film) also excluding […each losing …] M ONE T IME |
27 |
Did egg on uniform ultimately trigger meeting with my boss? (5) URGED (egged on; did egg on) U (Uniform is the International Radio Communication codeword for the letter U) + RG (final letters [ultimately] of each of TRIGGER and MEETING) + ED (editor; a crossword editor is usually the ‘boss’ of a crossword setter) U RG ED |
28 |
Close temperatures keeping characters from hiking round Thailand (5-4) TIGHT-KNIT (closely integrated) (T [temperature] + T [temperature] giving temperatures) containing (keeping) ([a jumble of] the characters of HIKING containing [round] T [International Vehicle Registration for Thailand]) T (IGH (T) KNI*) T |
29 |
See 9 Down [MALE] IMPERSONATOR |
Down | |
2 |
Important chap reportedly avoided a disputed territory when travelling north (2,3) MR BIG (head of an organisation, especially of a criminal organisation; important chap) MR (MISTER [sounds like {reportedly} MISSED A {avoided}]) + GIB (Gibraltar [territory disputed by United Kingdom and Spain]) reversed (when travelling north) MR BIG< |
3 |
Collector’s item‘s a bloody state, I suppose! (6) RARITY (something valued for its scarcity, hence a collectible item) RARITY (reference a steak cooked RARE which means it remains fairly bloody) double definition RARITY |
4 |
Wet earth covering animal’s lair (6) SODDEN (soaked thoroughly; very wet) SOD (piece of turf; earth) + DEN (animal’s lair) SOD DEN |
5 |
Avoiding both fringes, old Labour leader starts to eat next to Green (8) INNOCENT (naive; green) KINNOCK (reference Neil KINNOCK [born 1942], former leader of the Labour Party) excluding the outer letters (avoiding both fringes) K and K + ENT (first letters of [starts to] each of EAT, NEXT and TO) INNOC ENT |
6 |
Perhaps Facebook users have seen zit burst by noon (8) NETIZENS (person who regularly uses the Internet, such as a user of Facebook) N (noon) + an anagram of (burst) SEEN ZIT N ETIZENS* |
7 |
Dangerous strain sees father and son kept apart by national government (5,4) SIREN SONG (something alluring but also potentially dangerous; dangerous strain [SONG]) ([SIRE {to father} + SON] containing [kept apart by] N [national]) + G (government) SIRE (N) SON G |
8 |
Old men with power like propping up old royal (8) GRANDPAS (old men) GRAND (this looks like the ‘old royal’ part of the wordplay, but I can’t find a dictionary or thesaurus that directly relates grand and royal. The best I can find is a link through regal) + P (power) + AS (like) GRAND P AS |
9 / 29 |
Certain artists could be 14-1s by the sound of it (4,13) MALE IMPERSONATORS (type of performing artistes) MALE (sounds like [by the sound of it] MAIL [POST [entry at 14 across]) + IMPERSONATORS (IMPRESSIONISTS [1 across]) MALE IMPERSONATORS |
15 |
14-1 has time for Brussels to mature with a bit of manure in plot (9) STRATAGEM (plan for deceiving an enemy or gaining an advantage) SEURAT (reference Georges SEURAT [1859-1901], French artist considered to be one of the most important painters in the POST-IMPRESSIONIST [entry at 14-1] movement with T (time) replacing (for) EU (European Union, colloquially referred to as Brussels where the headquarters are located) + AGE + M (first letter of [bit of] MANURE) STRAT AGE M |
17 |
What rice does for sushi eaters’ sake? (8) FERMENTS (SAKE is Japanese [sushi eaters] alcoholic drink made from FERMENTed rice) FERMENTS (the whole clue is a definition of the entry FERMENTS) FERMENTS |
18 |
Cycling star to turn and get off seat (8) UNSADDLE (remove from a seat) SUN (star) with the letters cycled left one position to form UNS + ADDLE (go rotten; turn) UNS ADDLE |
19 |
Fickle Methuselah no longer has the hots for mimics (8) EMULATES (imitates; mimics) Anagram of (fickle) METHUSELAH excluding (no longer has) (H [hot] and H [hot] giving hots) EMULATES* |
22 |
Cheat hanging around own goal area – 1 often seen with 10 (6) COOGAN (reference Steve COOGAN [born 1965], actor, comedian and screenwriter who has appeared in a series of semi-fictionalised travelogue television programmes films with ROB BRYDON [entry at 10 across]) CON (swindle; cheat) containing (hanging around) (OG [own goal] + A [area]) CO (OG A) N |
23 |
Group including a precise number (6) This clue has defeated me. There are at least four possible words that each satisfy both possible definitions of group and number (piece of music) The four possibilities I can see are DECTET, SEPTET, SESTET or SEXTET each of which can be defined as a piece of music (number) for 10, 7, 6 or 6 players I don’t see how the wordplay works, beyond thinking that SET is a container meaning group. It is the ‘a precise [number]’ that defeats me. I can see that EXACT can mean precise which makes SEXTET a distinct possibility but I can’t see how to exclude the AC in the centre of EXACT. SET (group) containing EPT? EST? EXT? Using SET as a definition for group rules out DECTET as an option. ? |
24 / 13 |
14-1‘s spanner regularly fixing disruption to Suez Canal when one end’s blocked (4,7) PAUL CEZANNE (reference PAUL CEZANNE [1839-1906], French POST-IMPRESSIONIST [14 /1 entry] artist) PNE (letters 2, 4 and 6 [regularly] of SPANNER) containing (fixing) an anagram of (disruption to) SUEZ CANAL excluding the first letter (when one end’s blocked) S P (AUL CEZAN*) NE |
26 |
Tattooist has a change of heart relating to private area? (5) INNER (private area) INKER (tattooist [someone who works with inks or indelible dyes[) with the central letter K changed to N (change of heart) INNER |
Spiffing puzzle in spite of Halpernesque grid-hopping
Entry into the maze came with COOGAN (i’m a huge fan)-from there ROB BRYDON
I liked NETIZENS (not being one really)
I struggled finally on MALE (my(weak excuse is that Coogan did a very funny Pauline Calf
_”ooh I’ve ad im”)
Big thanks Duncan for parsing ONE TIME
Btw Steve Coogan has done so many great things, this put a spring in my step this morning.
Shame about my knees
I’ll get me coat
Thanks duncanshiell!
Solving online means that we know that SEXTET is the intended solution for 23d, but we can’t give any explanation I’m afraid.
In 8d, we had GR (King George) as the old royal, with the AND coming from the word “with” in the clue.
Thank you for the explanations, as we’d bunged in a couple of answers without parsing, including the ones using Seurat and Monet.
Thanks to Methuselah too
PS – minor point on the blog. In 20a, the solution is SURINAME ….
I found this very tough. I stared blankly at an empty grid for about 10 minutes before a few of the less difficult ones went in and it was PAUL CEZANNE that gave me the way in to 14-1 and its misleading ‘Spooner spits’. I can’t help with 23d for which SEXTET is the correct answer, but after going through the same thought processes as Duncan, I’ve no idea why. I agree with DavidO @2 re the parsing of 8d.
Too many top rank clues to mention them all but I thought ONE TIME and FERMENTS were particularly clever.
Thanks to Methuselah for a real tour de force and to Duncan for having done such a great job in working things out. I look forward to seeing what the (probably simple as Duncan says) explanation of 23d is.
DavidO @ 4
Thanks – I could see what was going on, but I clearly got the entry and the parsing the wrong way round.
The blog is corrected now
DavidO @ 2
Your suggestion of GR (old royal) + AND makes a lot of sense, particularly as I was struggling to relate grand and royal.
Using GR with AND gives me another clue I would add to my list of excellent clues in thsi puzzle.
Re SEXTET: Is the (6) in brackets the definition, so it is a CD?
I parsed GRANDPAS like DavidO and WP above. And like everyone above, including duncan, I cannot parse 23d. EXT is, of course, the abbreviation for ‘extension number’ which is a precise number within a business telephony system but that still leaves elements of the clue doing double duty.
Otherwise, all very enjoyable with nice plays on the two interlocked themes. Like copmus, I struggled with MALE and a pdm when it eventually fell.
Thanks both
I think 23dn is an & lit. whose wordplay is EXT(ension) in SET, a telephone extension being the precise number of the person you want to speak to.
I’ll get in early and clarify that 23d is meant as SET (group) containing EXT (extension, a precise phone number). The whole clue is the def, a musucal group with a precise/non-negotiable number of members.
Thanks duncanshiell for the blog.
Richard Heald @9: I think that’s you with the gold medal but I think I squeeze in as runner up???
Muffyword @7: that is a lovely suggestion. Not sure whether it breaks any rules but I’d very happily give it a pass if it was a one-off bit of cheek.
Nice mixed theme which we don’t get that many of.
I managed to figure out SEXTET after guessing it; it made me wonder what sort of telephone numbers are approximate?
James @12: nice question! I rationalise it on the basis of the automated message on a general corporate number inviting you to enter the extension number if you know it. So that’s the specific or precise number and switchboard is the general number. Worked for me.
Top fun, despite not parsing CEZANNE properly. URGED, SIREN SONG and the non-Spoonerism just some of many favourites. Cheers Duncan & Methuselah for a lovely puzzle.
Thanks both. So very clever but way beyond my ability to solve unaided, noting contrived anagrams for key and linked clues being respectively of 17 and 11 letters! My GK covered who I know as comedians i.e. BRYDON, COOGAN, but not that the former is an impressionist. Had I fully parsed STRATAGEM I would have invited myself to get out more often
Really tough – took me the best part of an hour, against my usual 9-12 minutes. Can’t really say why – even after I’d spotted the theme (and variations) some of the clues seemed really impenetrable. I’m grateful for the explanation of SEXTET above, although in this digital age the idea of an extension is a bit passe.
Thanks to Methuselah for dropping in to confirm the parsing of SEXTET. The POST IMPRESSIONIST/MALE IMPERSONATOR combination was brilliant!
One of those days. Spent about an hour and got all of four clues, none of them theme related. Put the puzzle aside to do other things and when I finally had the enthusiasm to get back to it, couldn’t get any more