Independent 11,414 by Phi

Well this was a tricky Phi-day challenge.

We had to check a number of definitions along the way. Luckily there was the odd ‘easy’ solve such as 22d and 13ac but others such as 19ac and 27ac took much longer. The grid didn’t help with the NE and SW corners only linking to the rest of the puzzle with 1 clue apiece.

However, the clues were smooth as we have come to expect with Phi so we have no other complaints! Regulars will know that Phi often includes a theme. Sometimes they are so obscure that only Phi is party to the fun as he uses them to give some structure to the puzzle at the start. With some odd entries 28ac and 19ac for example, we are pretty sure that something is going on but we cannot find anything.

Having said that, we solved the puzzle so knowledge of any possible theme is not necessary – which is how we like it.

 picture of the completed grid

ACROSS
1. Servant cleans round rear of room, taking less than instant (8)
DOMESTIC

DOES (cleans) around M (last letter or ‘rear’ of room) + TICk (instant) missing the last letter or ‘less than’

5. One leading chess player passing through station in disgrace (6)
STIGMA

I (one) GM (Grand Master – ‘leading chess player’) inside or ‘passing through’ STA (station)

9. I’ll be enthralled by curve on vessel at sea or vessel aloft (8)
AIRCRAFT

I inside or ‘being enthralled by’ ARC (curve) on RAFT (vessel at sea)

10. Stubborn character brought about a couple of days’ confusion (6)
MUDDLE

MULE (stubborn character) outside or ‘brought about’ DD (couple of days)

12. Deterioration of thatching with observation of late? (5-5)
NIGHT-WATCH

An anagram ‘deterioration’ of THATCHING and W (with)

13. Director getting behind sickly staff (4)
WAND

D (director) behind WAN (sickly)

15. Mother and leader married – one year later, coining it (6,5)
MAKING MONEY

MA (mother) KING (leader) M (married) ONE Y (year)

17. Popular comedy item, though half-hearted (3)
HOT

HOoT (comedy item) missing one of the ‘O’s or ‘half hearted’

18. Currently excluding Welsh? (3)
NOW

NO (excluding) W (Welsh)

19. Airmen – crikey! – in stretchy latex? That’s close to a bloomer (11)
EXTRAFLORAL

RAF (airmen) LOR’ (crikey) in an anagram (‘stretchy’) of LATEX. We had to check the definition here – extrafloral means situated outside a flower or not in a flower

20. Only some part of useful vegetarian food (4)
TOFU

Hidden (‘only some’) in parT OF Useful

21. Show dedication to working a short time to fill box (10)
CONSECRATE

ON (working) SEC (short time) inside or ‘filling’ CRATE (box)

25. Work old revue, giving it a new look (6)
OEUVRE

O (old) + an anagram (‘giving it a new look’) of REVUE

26. Part of army, say, one with soldiers? Right about that (8)
REGIMENT

EG (say) I (one) MEN (soldiers) with RT (right) outside

27. Criticism with heroin being included in comedian’s material (6)
SHTICK

H (heroin) inside STICK (criticism)

28. Knight hurried west, interrupting holiday somewhere in Cornwall? (8)
STANNARY

N (knight) + RAN (hurried) reversed or going ‘west’ inside STAY (holiday). Another one that needed checking – The Stannaries is a tin-mining district in Cornwall. ‘Stann-‘ signifies tin apparently according to Chambers.

DOWN
1. Racket encompassing car reversing – not front, exhaust (5)
DRAIN

DIN (racket) around or ‘encompassing’ a reversal of  cAR without the first letter or ‘not front’

2. University event supporting second girl at St Andrews? (5)
MORAG

RAG (University event) after or ‘supporting’ (in a down clue) MO (second). Do they still have Rag weeks at universities anymore?

3. One investigating observer snatching vintage container (10)
SCRUTINEER

SEER (observer) round or ‘snatching’ CRU (vintage) TIN (container)

4. A doubling of money in price increases? It arouses passion (12)
INFLAMMATION

A + MM (money twice or ‘doubled’) in INFLATION (price increases) Thanks stevo

6. Dull sound that has undertones, dwindling at the outset (4)
THUD

First letters (‘at the outset’) of That Has Undertones Dwindling

7. Farm worker mostly is concealing sources of dairy feed, boss (9)
GODFATHER

GOATHERd (farm worker) missing the last letter or ‘mostly’ around or ‘concealing’ D F (first letters or ‘sources’ of Dairy Feed)

8. Obsessive about City spot, according to reports (9)
ANECDOTAL

ANAL (obsessive) about EC (city) DOT (spot)

11. Look over the deals misrepresented in newspaper (7,5)
SCANDAL SHEET

SCAN (look over) and an anagram (‘misrepresented’) of THE DEALS. Another one that needed checking!

14. Item of parliamentary news – extra reading (2-8)
BY-ELECTION

BYE (extra as in cricket) LECTION (reading)

15. Doctor, on Truss needing treatment: ‘Dreadful’ (9)
MONSTROUS

MO (doctor) and an anagram (‘needing treatment’) of ON TRUSS

16. Network set-up about rugby included in equipment? It’s a New Zealand thing (4,5)
KIWI FRUIT

WI-FI (network set-up) round RU (Rugby Union) inside or ‘included in’ KIT (equipment)

22. Motorists’ group securing reduced payment for show venue (5)
ARENA

AA (motorists’ group) around or ‘securing’ RENt (payment) missing last letter or ‘reduced’

23. Opening element of 12, perhaps not opening? (5)
ENTRY

sENTRY (perhaps an ‘element’ of night-watch – 12ac) missing first letter or ‘not opening’

24. Cold fury rising in Morecambe? (4)
ERIC

A reversal (‘rising’) of C (cold) IRE (fury). Eric obviously refers to Eric Morecambe.

22 comments on “Independent 11,414 by Phi”

  1. Very good. Very Phi. Happy to see it was tricky for the bloggers. I thought so too. Could not parse BY-ELECTION. Thought it was cryptic def. Doing some extra reading by choice. The joys of being a greenhorn. Thanks for that. Found STANNARY in a word search and then what it meant online. My toppie is ANECDOTAL, initially thinking homonym, ‘according to reports’. 4d was easy enough to solve but passion being synonymous with inflammation put me off breakfast. Heat of a different kind. C’est la vie. Thanks for the blog and the workout.

  2. Our Economic History course at school included the stannary towns, which were also in Devon, so I had no difficuty with that. Like Sofamore I couldn’t parse BY-ELECTION. Otherwise all slipped in very smoothly, so thanks Phi and B&J.

  3. The first Discworld novel came out in 1983, so a 40th anniversary.
    Makes a change from 50-year-old LPs. 🙂

  4. Thanks both. Made uninhibited progress whilst needing to check a few answers e.g. STANNARY and SHTICK, and confidently entered DOMESTIC whilst being uncertain how ‘cleans’ and ‘does’ are synonyms

  5. A perfect Phi workout on Phiday, and all is right in the world. As with my fellow solvers, couldn’t parse BY-ELECTION. Hat tip to STANNARY, which as an American I had never heard of but had sufficiently clear wordplay that I could get it – makes the puzzle more inclusive. Thanks to Phi and B&J!

  6. TFO@11. British middle-class expression referring to someone who works as a cleaner “she does for mrs brown”.

    All enjoyable and informative today. Never heard of stannary but tin being Sn I suppose that makes sense. Tough going too.

    Thanks both

  7. We didn’t find this particularly tricky; in fact we breezed through it in a couple of passes, only needing to check in Chambers that EXTRAFLORAL was a word. Lots to like, too, such as SCRUTINEER, BY-ELECTION and STANNARY. Didn’t spot the theme but that’s not surprising as we’re not into Discworld.
    Thanks, Phi and B&J.

  8. Spotted the theme fairly early but still got stuck towards the end. I was a big fan of Discworld, bought the first one back in 1987 after all my friends telling me all about it.

  9. For once I spotted the theme, but that meant 7d had to be Hogfather, which didn’t quite work. Truly, a little knowledge is a dangerous thing.
    Thanks to setter and blogger.

  10. TFO@11: The expression “A lady who does” describes a cleaner.

    Pedantic point: The explanation for 4D should be A MM in INFLATION, giving INFLAMMATION

  11. Thanks to everyone including Phi for the hints and comments. We have been walking the Norfolk Coastal Path so have been a bit out of touch after the initial posting.
    Thanks stevo – we will amend the blog accordingly.

  12. Petert@19 – have you spotted an inadvertent mini-theme? The reference to Liz in 15d might round it off!

Comments are closed.