Independent 11,528 / Coot

[New comment layout] - details here

This appears to have been the first crossword by Coot in the Indy that has been blogged on 15, although I see that one was published in the IoS and blogged earlier this year. It is certainly my first outing with this setter, either as solver or as blogger.

I found this to be towards the more challenging end of the Indy spectrum in terms of difficulty, with wordplay that was quite difficult to tease out, even when the solution was clear from the definition, e.g. at 19. Coot has had the last laugh on me today, since I cannot parse 6D – I look forward to being enlightened by other solvers – thanks for explaining the parsing and for the other corrections/tweaks; blog now updated.

My favourite clues today were 1, for originality; 2/8, for its saucy surface; 10 and 24, both for smoothness of surface; 21, for the misleading reference to Clio; and 28/20, for its clever inclusion of the Dales and the compiler’s name.

Incidentally, I was wondering what might have ousted Phi from his usual Friday spot. I had noticed that there were numerous golfing references in the clues – at 11, 12, 19, 26, 27 … – and then I spotted that the names CHARLEY HULL and GEORGIA HALL are to be found around the perimeter of the completed grid. A quick Google search revealed that these two ladies are British professional golfers, and that today sees the start of the Solheim Cup between Europe and the USA, being held near Estepona (see 19!) in Spain. Now we know!

*(…) indicates an anagram; definitions are italicised; // separates definitions in multiple-definition clues

Across  
   
06 CHINO Branch in Oregon stocks fabric

Hidden (“stocks”) in “branCH IN Oregon”

   
07 ULTRA-HIGH Fanatic uttered greeting imitating Sopranos?

ULTRA (=fanatic, extremist) + homophone (“uttered”) of “hi”

   
10 ART DECO Extravagant red coat in 20s style

*(RED COAT); “extravagant” is anagram indicator

   
11 PIVOTAL Partner takes divot striking 3-wood at last – that’s decisive

<d>IVOT (“striking 3-wood at last” means last letter is dropped) in PAL (=partner)

   
12 LURCH Beginners in lush uncut rough can’t handle pitch

L<ush> U<ncut> R<ough> C<an’t> H<andle>; “beginners in” means first letters only; to pitch is to roll from side to side, to lurch

   
14 EXTENSOR Old men, clothing XS, showing muscle

[TEN (=X, in Roman numerals) + S] in [EX- (=old, former) + OR (=men, i.e. other ranks)]

   
15 YARDMAN Yeovil’s original tough guy denied opening as farm worker

Y<eovil> (“original” means first letter only) + <h>ARD MAN (=tough guy; “denied opening” means first letter is dropped); a yardman is a person in charge of a farmyard

   
17 WEARING Exhibiting is// arduous

Double definition: “wearing” is exhibiting, sporting AND arduous, taxing

   
19 TURNED ON Excited to find new course west of Estepona: cue round!

TURN (=to find new course) + E<stepona> (“west of” means first letter only) + DON (NOD=cue; “round” indicates reversal)

   
21 ERATO Partially reupholster a Torino, an old relative of Clio

Hidden (“partially”) in “reupholstER A TOrino”; Clio and Erato were sisters, two of the nine Muses in Greek mythology!

   
24 UTENSIL Implement bizarre resolution to liberate Roo

*(<r>ES<o>LUTI<o>N); “to liberate Roo” means that letters “roo” are dropped from anagram, indicated by “bizarre”

   
25 BACKLOG Champion’s loss initially placed on “self-inflicted wound” pile

BACK (=champion, support) + L<oss> (“initially” means first letter only) + OG (= “self-inflicted wound”, i.e. own goal)

   
27 LONG SHOTS Driving can produce these unexpected outcomes

In golf, driving can produce long shots, i.e. balls that go a long distance

   
28/20 COSTA DEL SOL A popular destination, Southern Dales left Coot refreshed

*(S (=Southern) + DALES + L (=left) + COOT); “refreshed” is anagram indicator

   
Down  
   
01 SISTER One with habit assuming this makes bets better?

“bets” becomes “better” when “s is (=becomes) ter”; a sister is a nun, hence “one with habit”

   
02/08 HOME ADVANTAGE You can’t have it away in vehicle” – Tesla’s boring motto

HOME (=in) + {[VAN (=vehicle) + T (=Tesla)] in ADAGE (=motto)}; if you play an away game, you cannot have a home advantage!

   
03 EUROPEAN Drunk on a purée from Provence?

*(ON A PUREE); “drunk” is anagram indicator

   
04 STOP IT Behave best housed in squat

TOP (=best) in SIT (=squat, crouch); Behave! as an exclamation means Stop it!

   
05 VIRTUOSI Struggling tour is after six elite players

VI (=six, in Roman numerals) + *(TOUR IS); “struggling” is anagram indicator

06 CHARLEY Silly cleaner’s last in line for promotion

CHARLADY (=cleaner); “last (=last letter) in line for promotion (=ad(vert))” means letter “ad” is replaced by “e”; a charley is a fool, a silly (person)

   
09 HALL Snatch pig from shallow passageway

<s>HALL<ow>; “snatch pig (=sow) from” means letters “sow” are dropped

   
13 HUMANISTS Terrible tsunami disheartened Haitians – they can’t imagine life after this

*(TSUNAMI + H<aitian>S); “disheartened” means middle letters are dropped from anagram, indicated by “terrible”; humanists do not believe in the afterlife

   
16 ROUTE ONE Defeat 3-1 results in long-ball strategy

ROUT (=defeat) + E (=European, i.e. entry at 3) + ONE (=1); route one is a strategy in football whereby the ball is kicked a long distance to a target strike, as opposed to a short pass

   
17 WENT BUST Lost fortune and, given time, travelled by public transport

WENT (=travelled) + BUS (=public transport) + T (=time)

   
18 GEORGIA In a state, blokes scratching backsides

GEORG<e> + IA<n> (=blokes, i.e. male forenames; “scratching backsides” means last letters are dropped

   
22 ABLEST Cycling fast, more accomplished than the rest

STABLE (=fast, fixed); “cycling” here means that the first and second letters have moved to the end of the word

   
23 HULL Tip for horseradish: removing skin fully, peel

H<orseradish>H (=tip, i.e. either first or last letter) + <f>ULL<y> (“removing skin” means first and last letters are dropped); to hull is to husk or remove outer covering, hence “peel”

   
26 COCO Mizuno’s latest clubs held in firm palm

[<mizun>O (“latest” means last letter only) + C (=clubs, in cards)] in CO (=firm, i.e. company)

   
   

17 comments on “Independent 11,528 / Coot”

  1. KVa
    @1 - September 22, 2023 at 1:08 pm

    6D CHARLEY
    Cleaner=CHARLADY, last in line=E, promotion=AD, E for AD in CHARLADY.

  2. KVa
    @2 - September 22, 2023 at 1:19 pm

    My top fave:
    SISTER
    ‘assuming S IS TER(this) makes bets better’ —reads nice.
    The def is cute too.

  3. FrankieG
    @3 - September 22, 2023 at 1:28 pm

    typo 07a ULTRA-HIGH

  4. FrankieG
    @4 - September 22, 2023 at 1:44 pm

    Not a fan of golf but Estepona is in the COSTA DEL SOL

  5. Flea
    @5 - September 22, 2023 at 1:47 pm

    Good puzzle. As I type this. we Europeans are currently 4-0 down in the Solheim Cup !

    I believe there are smatterings of other S C tournament references in there. I counted COSTA DEL SOL, EUROPEAN, HOME, LONG SHOTS, ROUTE ONE, WEARING CHINO, ULTRA-HIGH ( loft wedges) [ there’s an error in 6a in the blog ] ….

    Thank you Coot and RR.

  6. TFO
    @6 - September 22, 2023 at 1:56 pm

    Thanks both. Liked HOME ADVANTAGE. Had the same issues with parsing, notably CHARLEY, where more importantly I did not know it means silly )in that spelling), and without trying too hard can’t find anything to confirm it does

  7. allan_c
    @7 - September 22, 2023 at 2:08 pm

    We share the opinion of golf attributed to Mark Twain, so the theme was lost on us. A satisfying solve nevertheless, although we couldn’t parse 14ac, 1dn or 6dn. Favourites were ERATO and HOME ADVANTAGE.
    Thanks, Coot and RR

  8. ilippu
    @8 - September 22, 2023 at 3:09 pm

    Thanks Coot and RatkojaRiku.

    Tough one.

    Parsed CHARLEY but not SISTER, thanks.

    BACKLOG, got BACK and L, was messing with EGO for self, couldn’t get rid of E 🙁
    Of course, Own Goal it is.

    HOME ADVANTAGE
    TURNED ON
    STOP IT
    HULL
    CHARLEY are favs.

  9. Simon S
    @9 - September 22, 2023 at 3:29 pm

    Thanks Coot and RR

    The game does nothing for me, but there do seem to be quite a lot of golf references in the clues too.

  10. Simon S
    @10 - September 22, 2023 at 3:31 pm

    Oh, and I think that in 23D ‘peel’ & ‘hull’ are being used in the verbal sense.

  11. jane
    @11 - September 22, 2023 at 3:40 pm

    Filling the grid was one thing, sorting out some of the parsing a different matter altogether! Failed on 1&16d – simply didn’t know the football term in the latter and remain somewhat unconvinced about the former.
    Always good to see a new face getting a puzzle published so congrats to Coot and many thanks to RR for help with the parsing.

  12. nicbach
    @12 - September 22, 2023 at 4:07 pm

    I parsed 6d as CHAR+cleaner , afterwards (last) LEY line. Considering the number I didn’t parse, it seemed good to me. Just checked , four unparsed. It felt like more!

  13. PostMark
    @13 - September 22, 2023 at 5:25 pm

    A nicely worked theme acknowledging an event about which I may know nothing but I appreciated the surface references and admire the range of references in the clues too. Some nice constructions with EXTENSOR, BACKLOG, LONG SHOTS, HULL, HUMANISTS and EUROPEAN amongst my favourites. Podium is the lovely combo of surface and construction in HOME ADVANTAGE, the cunning parse for SISTER and the neat surface for PIVOTAL.

    Thanks Coot and RR

  14. Coot
    @14 - September 22, 2023 at 6:22 pm

    Many thanks RR for the blog and to everyone who has commented. Well done on working out the theme RR! I flew out to Estepona today and will be watching the event over the weekend. After a bad start today, I’m hoping that the EUROPEANs can make their HOME ADVANTAGE pay! My intended parse for CHARLEY was as noted by KVa @ 1. And Flea @ 5 I’m delighted that you managed to stretch the theme even further than I intended, although I might add that I’m sure the teammates see each other as SISTERs and that they are the ABLEST ‘elite players’ that we have.

  15. Tim C
    @15 - September 23, 2023 at 12:39 am

    I didn’t do this (sorry Coot, but there’s only so many hours in a day) but I know Coot from MyCrossword so if you enjoyed this one you can get more there. He’s also supplied one of the comp. puzzles for the Crossword Centre this year.

  16. DiBosco
    @16 - September 23, 2023 at 11:00 am

    This was tough. Finished this morning after starting in the pub last night, having a third left. Fell in to place this morning even if we couldn’t parse two or three and were doubtful about others.

    Thanks RR and Coot 🙂

    Still don’t understand sister!

  17. paul b
    @17 - September 23, 2023 at 1:44 pm

    Coot means ‘when S IS TER, e.g. betS becomes betTER’. I liked that idea, which seems to present with an implied warning against gambling.

Comments are closed.