Gozo is this morning's FT setter.
I have to admit I thought this was going to be a write-in. My first pass left me with only eight unsolved answers and all I had solved were easily parsed. But it took me a while to work out OSEA ISLAND and my LOI was SLATE. I took an inordinate amount of time trying to parse WENT before I saw how straightforward it was.
Most of the clues were fine, but I did have some minor quibbles. I can't make the grammar work for DIAPERS, and the definition for TREADLE seems a little weak. Also, the "his" in 6dn is superfluous.
EMENDATOR wasn't a word in the Chambers I referred to, but I found it in Collins.
There was a fair bit of general knowledge in the puzzle, ranging from easy stuff such as EAST OF EDEN, TREBLINKA and SCOTTIE, through things like having to know that Telford was a new town and that the Nigerian currency was the NAIRA, and eventually to the very niche OSEA ISLAND, which I have to admit I had never heard of.
I dfon't think there's a theme or a NINA, but I'm notoriously bad at spotting both, so am prepared to be corrected on that (and anything else I may have missed or misunderstood, of course).
Thanks Gozo.
ACROSS | ||
1 | NOTRE DAME |
Cathedral’s title includes radical books first (5,4)
|
NAME ("title") includes OT (Old Testament, so "books") + RED ("radical") |
||
6 | STEAL |
Go quietly at a pinch? (5)
|
Double definition |
||
9 | IDEAS |
Paragons left out for plans (5)
|
IDEA(l)S ("paragons") with L (left) out |
||
10 | RE-EDITING |
Get in dire trouble checking proofs anew (2-7)
|
*(get in dire) [anag:trouble] |
||
11 | SILHOUETTE |
Outline — sadly, the outline’s not new (10)
|
*(the outlies) [anag:sadly] where OUTLIES is OUTLI(n)ES [not N (new)] |
||
12 | NEWT |
Could be Telford with own amphibian (4)
|
With OWN, NEWT becomes NEW T-OWN ("could be Telford") |
||
14 | CANTERS |
Scrawny theorist regularly goes jogging (7)
|
(s)C(r)A(w)N(y) T(h)E(o)R(i)S(t) [regularly] |
||
15 | DESPAIR |
Result of having aspired unsuccessfully? (7)
|
*(aspired) [anag:unsuccessfully] and &lit. |
||
17 | DIAPERS |
Receive money back, returning small Pampers, say (7)
|
<=(REPAID) ("receive money back", returning) + S (small) Should be "gave" money back? |
||
19 | TRANCES |
Dreamlike states displaying vestiges of new intervention (7)
|
TRACES ("vestiges") with N (new) intervention |
||
20 | WENT |
Left, coming after Jack and Jill! (4)
|
In the nursery rhyme, Jack and Jill WENT up the hill, so WENT "comes after Jack and Jill" |
||
22 | HOTEL SUITE |
Luxurious rooms coming after golf and dessert, we’re told (5,5)
|
HOTEL ("coming after golf" in the NATO phonetic alphabet) + homophone [we're told] of SWEET ("dessert") |
||
25 | RE-IGNITED |
Flared up again at rule about diet (2-7)
|
REIGN ("rule") + *(diet) [anag:about] |
||
26 | ASIDE |
Comment on record’s principal song (5)
|
A-SIDE ("record's principal song") |
||
27 | SLATE |
Grey strip with blue edge (5)
|
SLAT ("strip") with (blu)E [edge] |
||
28 | EMENDATOR |
He makes corrections with energy to improve new rota (9)
|
E (energy) + MEND ("to improve") + *(rota) [anag;new] |
||
DOWN | ||
1 | NAILS |
Poles have trouble within — they get hammered (5)
|
N + S (North and South "Poles") have AIL ("trouble") within |
||
2 | TREBLINKA |
Writing material accepted by consort back at camp (9)
|
INK ("wwriting material") accepted by (Prince) <=ALBERT ("consort", back) Treblinka was a WWII Nazi death camp in occuped Poland. |
||
3 | EAST OF EDEN |
Donates fee reviewing novel (4,2,4)
|
*(donates fee) [anag:reviewing] |
||
4 | AIR BEDS |
Melody on small county inflatables (3,4)
|
AIR ("melody") on BEDS. (abbreviation for Bedfordshire, so "small county") |
||
5 | ERECTED |
Before court, English duke was upright (7)
|
ERE ("before") + Ct. (court) + E (English) + D (duke) |
||
6 | SLIP |
Fielder brings up his drink (4)
|
[brings up] <=PILS ("drink") |
||
7 | EXILE |
Half the team holding another for a period away from home (5)
|
[Half of] ELE(ven) ("team") holding XI ("another" eleven) |
||
8 | LIGATURES |
Gaultier’s tailored for conjoined characters (9)
|
*(gaultiers) [anag:tailored] |
||
13 | OSEA ISLAND |
Haven in the Blackwater Estuary having no water is terra firma (4,6)
|
O (zero, so "no") + SEA ("water") + IS + LAND ("terra firma") Osea Island is an inhabited island in the Blackwater Estuary in Essex. |
||
14 | CODE WORDS |
Could they be interpreted as Doc, Rod and Wes? (4,5)
|
*(doc ros wes) [anag: interpreted] and &lit. |
||
16 | ARCHIVIST |
Record keeper could be this vicar (9)
|
*(this vicar) [anag:could be] |
||
18 | SCOTTIE |
Little dog which Star Trek character suggests (7)
|
Double definition |
||
19 | TREADLE |
Related perhaps, but trodden underfoot (7)
|
*(related) [anag:perhaps] |
||
21 | NAIRA |
Rastafarians returning holding Nigerian currency (5)
|
Hidden backwards in [returning holding] "rastafARIANs" |
||
23 | EMEER |
Kuwaiti prince backing some agreement (5)
|
Hidden backwards in [backing some] "agREEMEnt") |
||
24 | KNEE |
King once called for a joint (4)
|
K (king) + NEE ("once called") |
The across solutions are in pairs (in each pair, one word is an anagram of the other).
Enjoyed this Gozo grid, as I always do, but felt my grin spreading even wider when I noticed (only towards the end!) what was happening with the across entries. Very nice indeed!
My favourite was SILHOUETTE but there were many I liked; SLATE and NAILS (surfaces), ARCHIVIST, LIGATURES (neat anagrams) and EXILE (wordplay).
22 needed 10 or a 28!
Thanks to Gozo for a well-crafted puzzle and Loonapick for fully parsing the two which made me suspect something was afoot.
Snap, KVa!
Me @3,
Or perhaps not since a suite contains rooms – my bad.
DIAPERS
Agree with loonapick’s comment in the intro para.
Diane@2
What is your comment on HOTEL SUITE?
Well spotted KVa. Quite an achievement by Gozo.
In 18d, I think the Star Trek character is ‘Scotty’, hence the ‘suggests’ in the clue.
In 6d, could ‘Fielder’ be the name of somebody (possibly a Czech, where Pils originates)?
CODE WORDS
Isn’t it more of a cryptic def than an &lit?
Telford/new town was a bit mean for us Antipodeans; no wonder I couldn’t parse NEWT. I did manage OSEA ISLAND, but only after a fair amount of googling. I’ve never seen EMEER spelt this way. I had DRAWERS for 17a and couldn’t understand it. I gather PAMPERS are a brand of diapers? You’ll have to forgive me; they’re not something we buy often, and anyway, we call them nappies. Never heard of EMENDATOR.
Thanks to FrankieG’s tutorial on county abbreviations just yesterday, I was able to parse AIR BEDS.
Surprised nobody has complained that 17a should have a US indication. Let me be the first. Mind you, I never complain when we get Australian or South African words, without indication, so I’m a bit of a hypocrite.
KVa, I initially thought the definition of 22A should be ‘hotel room’ singular but, as I say, I’ve since realised my error.
Well spotted, KVa @ 1. I wouldn’t have noticed.
Rats, I mean ‘luxurious room’ (don’t mind me!)
12A – Telford and 13D – Osea Island were a bit hard for we non-English dwellers but gettable after cross letters and an Internet search engine.
My total lack of knowledge of cricket led to 6D being my last one in.
Thanks loonapick.
Peter, you obviously aren’t aware of the old saying “A girl will slip out of her slip after a pils goes down”.
GDU @9 – I also had DRAWERS at 17ac, as it’s S for small + REWARD <- which is a receipt of money… But as an anagram of DESPAIR, we must concede that DIAPERS is a better fit for Pampers.
Thanks to all involved!
Spotted as KVa@1 and Diane@2 the symmetrically opposed anagrams – a clever construction.
Geoff Down Under@9 – looks like today we need a lesson on New Towns – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_towns_in_the_United_Kingdom#First_wave
‘Dawley New Town’ – nho – ‘Shropshire’ – aka Salop, from yesterday – celebrates its 60th birthday this year – making a nice change from… &c – (LIGATURE)
Some New Towns are even older. ‘Third wave’ Telford – Salop, also – is a mere stripling of 55.
loi & No Hope Of getting OSEA without Googling “Blackwater Estuary island”
Too much information, FrankieG. I only have an IQ of 82.
Thanks Gozo and loonapick
In another example of clues being recycled, EMEER was clued by Gozo in his Maskarade guise as “Eastern ruler backing some agreement” in his Guardian Bank Holiday puzzle this August.
Didn’t get Slate, Treblinka, or Osea Island (which is frankly bloody obscure). Otherwise this was a reasonable slog.
Thanks Gozo. I missed the very clever anagram construction and I ended up revealing HOTEL SUITE, OSEA ISLAND, and SLIP so this counts as a failure for me. I did enjoy many clues including DESPITE (nice surface), WENT, ASIDE, NAILS, and KNEE. Thanks loonapick for the blog.
The paired anagrams – very impressive; but we didn’t spot them so we weren’t too impressed. We thought 2dn in rather poor taste (though no doubt constrained by the across entries) and weren’t happy with the grammar of 17ac.
Thanks, though, to Gozo and loonapick.
Two short counties in a row (Hants and Beds) the former has always mystified me. Failed to get Treblinka – I wasn’t even looking for a camp but for writing!
TREBLINKA was one of my last in as I had to rethink writing materials as a definition, but when I had all the crossers I saw that ink could fit that gap, and camp came to mind with a clanging PDM (It helps having sat through Escape from Sobibor with the son of a survivor, those camps part of my mental mind mapping). I also took ages to work out OSEA ISLAND, and I used to work with someone who lives on Mersea, so was slightly more aware of those islands in the Blackwater Estuary.
Thank you to loonapick and Gozo.
I’d never heard of Osea Island, so that was my DNF for today. (Not exactly new knowledge that I am about to use anytime soon.) Otherwise, this was a fun solve, with an ingenious grid-fill, as noted by many others, that made me wonder if I had stumbled into a Brendan puzzle. (That is a compliment, by the way.)
Thanks Gozo for the fun, and loonapick for the clear and concise blog.
KVa @ 8 – you’re correct, CODE WORDS is certainly not an &lit since “could be” is not part of the word play; nearly though – a partial &lit
And what a delightful conceit – great puzzle
Many thanks