Gozo takes a turn as the FT Thursday setter.
A puzzle for anagram fans, with seven full anagrams included (two more than what is usually the max in some style guides), but they were mostly very good anagrams (especially FLAMENCO DANCERS), so who cares?
I liked the simplicity of AHEAD and the fun ASSESS, but I also had a few quibbles, some of which may be trivial ("attacked" as a anagrind, for exampe). I wasn't keen on the clue for TRAWL, and also I'm convinced that ARC (a line) and SEGMENT (a shape) are not synonymous. In the clue for GALLEONS, the E is in, not out, so to indicate that GALLONS is outside of E, I'm not convinced "out" alone is enough. In the clue for Brussels, it may have been better to use RUSSIANS'. As I said, these may be trivial, and some may disagree with me, but a little editing may have helped.
Thanks, Gozo.
ACROSS | ||
1 | ASIANS |
A Welsh girl’s with Afghans, say (6)
|
A + SIAN'S ("Welsh girl's") |
||
4 | FORFEITS |
The penalties of strife, perhaps (8)
|
*(of strife) [anag:perhaps] |
||
10 | ANNOTATED |
Added a commentary at Eton and roundabout (9)
|
*(at eton and) [anag:roundabout] |
||
11 | AHEAD |
A top up (5)
|
A + HEAD ("top") |
||
12 | CHEMICAL ELEMENT |
He and Al appear in full as such (8,7)
|
On the periodic table of CHEMICAL ELEMENTs, "He in full" is helium and "Al" is aluminium |
||
13 | IMPUGNS |
Disputes the honesty of PM using spin (7)
|
*(pm using) [anag:spin] |
||
14 | NECTAR |
Sweet drink close by, keeping cold with time (6)
|
NEAR ("close by"), keeping C (cold) with T (time) |
||
17 | WREATH |
Tribute to the war fallen (6)
|
*(the war) [anag:fallen] |
||
19 | AUDITOR |
Accountant with car on hilltop (7)
|
AUDI ("car") on TOR ("hilltop") |
||
21 | TITUS ANDRONICUS |
Tudors in Tunics — a new play by the Bard (5,10)
|
*(tudors in tunics a) [anag:new] |
||
23 | IRAQI |
Irish oddly acquit Mosul resident (5)
|
Ir. (Irish) + A(c)Q(u)I(t) [oddly] |
||
24 | MOUSEHOLE |
Where Tom waits, maybe, in Cornish resort (9)
|
MOUSEHOLE is a town in Cornwall, but is also a place where a cat may lie in wait to capture his prey. |
||
25 | GALLEONS |
Old vessels having much capacity out east (8)
|
GALLONS ("much capacity") out(side of) E (east) |
||
26 | ASSESS |
Evaluate Jenny? (6)
|
A jenny is a female ass (an ASSESS, geddit?) |
||
DOWN | ||
1 | ANARCHIC |
Lawless segment in revolutionary China (8)
|
ARC ("segment") in *(china) [anag:revolutionary] As far as I am aware, an arc and a segment are not the same thing. |
||
2 | INNKEEPER |
Castle controlled by private landlord (9)
|
KEEP ("castle") controlled by INNER ("private") |
||
3 | NOTTINGHAMSHIRE |
Nightmare on this broadcast from county (15)
|
*(nightmare on this) [anag:broadcast] |
||
5 | OLD BEAN |
Friendly greeting unwanted amongst Heinz’s offering? (3,4)
|
OLD BEAN is a friendly term for an acquaintance, but also something you wouldn't want to find in a tin of Heinz beans |
||
6 | FLAMENCO DANCERS |
Carmen closed — fan attacked performers (8,7)
|
*(carmen closed fan) [anag:attacked] Attacked as an anagrind? Hmmm… |
||
7 | IRENE |
Peaceful girl, alluring one, topless, at end of promenade (5)
|
(s)IREN ("alluring one", topless) at [end of] (promenad)E In Greek mythology, Irene was one of the Horae and the personification of peace. |
||
8 | SEDATE |
Inwardly composed, at ease, calm (6)
|
HIdden in [inwardley] "compoSED AT Ease" |
||
9 | STOATS |
Extremely succulent food for small carnivores (6)
|
[extremely] S(ucculen)T + OATS ("food") |
||
15 | ARTICHOKE |
Take choir trip to Jerusalem, say (9)
|
*(take choir) [anag:trip] |
||
16 | BRUSSELS |
Sound measures to seize half Russian’s capital (8)
|
BELS ("sound measures") to secure [half of] RUSS(ian's) Russians' may have been better? |
||
18 | HANGMAN |
Pierrepoint’s game (7)
|
Double definition, the first referring to Albert Pierrepoint, Britain's last hangman who died in 1992. |
||
19 | ATRIUM |
A half-successful Roman courtyard (6)
|
A + [half-]TRIUM(phant) ("successful") |
||
20 | STRING |
Amateur left, gazing at train (6)
|
A (amateur) left ST(a)RING ("gazing") |
||
22 | TRAWL |
Cast from Dragnet? (5)
|
A TRAWL is a net that is dragged along the seabed. Not keen on this as a trawl may be cast from a boat, but the clue seems to indicate it's part of the defintion. |
I didn’t know decibels were tenths of a bel. Never heard of bels. But it makes sense. My knowledge of Greek mythology doesn’t encompass Irene, and the wordplay was a little too tricky, but it’s about all that fit. I wasn’t devious enough to parse ASSESS.
Plenty to enjoy, and, for the second day in a row, a welcome escape from an impossibly difficult Guardian puzzle. Thanks Gozo & Loonapick.
Full of Gozo’s customary wit. I liked MOUSEHOLE (Tom, as in Tom and Jerry, presumably), as well as CHEMICAL ELEMENT and WREATH.
As Loonapick says, there were anagrams aplenty and I had fun working them all out.
Thanks to Gozo and Loonapick.
With two examples, I felt 12a was defining the plural, CHEMICAL ELEMENTS, rather than the singular. I’d agree with loonapick about GALLEONS and cannot really make sense of TRAWL. The anagram were generally fun – nice to find Carmen in FLAMENCO DANCERS and WREATH is excellent – but I’m less keen on nounal anagrinds following the fodder like ‘spin’ in IMPUGN and ‘trip’ in ARTICHOKE. And, finally, I’d have preferred not to find wordplay from definition in NOTTINGHAMSHIRE. So, yes, some editing probably needed. ASSESS, TITUS ANDRONICUS and INNKEEPER my favourites.
Thanks Gozo and loonapick
Could an arc be a segment of a circle, maybe? I also think you might cast for an answer, as well as trawl for one.
I will remember Tudors in Tunics for a long time!
Thanks Gozo and loonapick!
AGN@4
ANARCHIC
arc may be =segment (loosely speaking).
TRAWL
The surface is nice. Cast for=Trawl for? TILT.
Diane@2
MOUSETRAP
Does Tom in the general sense of a male cat not work (without any reference to T & J)? Good clue. Agree.
CHEMICAL ELEMENT(s)
Agree with PM@3. HE and AL appear in CHEMICAL but that has no role in the WP, I think.
Thanks Gozo and loonapick!
KVa@5
Why yes, of course it does (but queens are just as likely to do this!)
Diane@6
LOL
MOUSEHOLE (keyed in MOUSETRAP @5)
You are right about queens. Today it was Tom’s turn.
Or a tom’s turn!
26a ASSESS is an old chestnut https://www.fifteensquared.net/2021/10/06/financial-times-16909-by-gozo/ – “26a Evaluate Jenny? (6)” – (same position, too)
As is 19a AUDI TOR
Liked the &littish 17a WREATH, 13a IMPUGNS – nice surface, and 7d IRENE – a “girl'”s name that means peace in Greek (Ancient or Modern).
[24a MOUSEHOLE – I’ve been there – “Tom Waits” – coincidentally getting mentioned in the G today]
Thanks G&L
An enjoyable solve with plenty of easy anagrams; our only complaint is that it was over too soon.
Thanks, Gozo and loonapick.
Thanks Gozo for a pleasant crossword. I liked the anagrams at 21a and 6d as well as MOUSEHOLE, IRENE, and STRING. OLD BEAN was new term for me. Thanks loonapick for the blog.
[Diane @6: In the wild it’s the female cat who does the lion’s share of the hunting while the male guards the territory. Domestically the roles are a bit more fluid.]
Thanks Gozo and loonapick
1dn: As a mathematician, I am fully aware that, in formal geometry, the words arc and segment are used with very precise and clearly distinct meanings. However, specialists in any field of knowledge have no right to restrict the use of words in general language to their formal meanings, so we should note the question posed by AGN@4 “Could an arc be a segment of a circle, maybe?” and see if we can find support for the reply by KVa@5 “arc may be =segment (loosely speaking).”
Collins 2023 gives us
“arc part of an unbroken curved line”; and
“segment a part of a line or curve between two points”.
On the principle that setters should not be expected to overrule dictionaries, I think we can and should accept “segment” in a clue as an indication for ARC in its solution.