Here is Henri’s puzzle for the York S&B
The preamble:
‘Eight clues contain an extra word; select the letter in the word that corresponds to the word’s position in its clue. In order, selected letters indicate what must be highlighted (12 cells), which in turn will assist in entering six undefined thematic answers.’
As usual with puzzles involving extra words etc, we set out to solve as many ‘normal’ clues as possible in order to tease out the hidden instruction and thematic entries. We expect barred puzzles to contain some unusual words – and this one had more than its fair share, plus several clues requiring fairly specialist general knowledge – we had to check words in the clue or the definition for 1, 6, 10, 13, 15, 17, 19, 23, 27, 32 & 33 across and 5, 9, 16, 18, 21, 24, 25, 26 & 28 down – half the clues! Perhaps this shows a lack of knowledge on our part, but it did make the puzzle a serious challenge.
However, as all but four of the across clues turned out to be ‘normal’, we managed to fill much of the grid with a lot of help from Chambers and search engines. With the crossers in place, we tried to figure out 22d and decided that it had to be one of the six clues without definitions. We realised that a reversal of CHINOOK would fit, and the penny dropped when we noticed ‘PUT THE WIND UP’ in the diagonal FROM the P in the bottom left cell TO the P in the top right – the letters in the extra words, as highlighted in green below. This also explained the puzzle title. We looked for the names of other winds that we knew, and realised that MISTRAL fitted into 1d, and FOEHN at 3d, but we had to search for the other three, which were new to us.
ACROSS | |||
No. | Entry | Letter | |
1 | LAING | F |
Eminent psychiatrist was still (briefly) good (5)
|
LAIN (was still) G (good) | |||
6 | AFFRAP |
Ed’s to strike when new paraffin less hot (6)
|
|
An anagram (‘new’) of PARAFF |
|||
10 | CHOANA |
Opening chapter of unfinished Anglo-Norman saga dismissing depression (6)
|
|
CH (chapter) O (of ‘unfinished’) AN (Anglo-Norman) |
|||
12 | REDEEM |
‘Get Back‘ – revolutionary tune, ultimately, by revolutionary writer (6)
|
|
RED (revolutionary) E (last or ‘ultimate’ letter of tune) + a reversal (‘revolutionary’) of ME (writer) | |||
13 | DOODLE |
Party organiser initially led astray in Scottish play (6)
|
|
DO (party) O (‘initial’ letter of organiser) + an anagram (‘astray’) of LED | |||
14 | TRIOS |
Musical compositions from fun people with tenor coming to the fore (5)
|
|
RIOTS (‘fun people’) with the ‘t’ (tenor) moving to the front | |||
15 | UNHAT |
One local cardinal’s office to make respectful gesture (5)
|
|
UN (a dialect or ‘local’ form of ‘one’) HAT (cardinal’s office) – who’d have guessed?! It’s in Chambers! | |||
17 | HOIDENS |
Old romps stop, papers expose drunken shenanigans at last (7)
|
|
HO (stop) ID (papers) + E N S (last letters of exposE drunkeN shenaniganS) | |||
19 | ISATIS |
Plant lives by briefly doing a particular thing with sun (6)
|
|
IS (lives) AT I |
|||
20 | SACK | R |
Get rid of (horribly) outdated dress (4)
|
Double definition | |||
23 | MESE |
Note uncles previously cycling (4)
|
|
EMES (obsolete or ‘previous’ word for uncles) with the ‘s’ moved to the front or ‘cycling’ | |||
26 | NANDOO | O |
Relative’s (youngest) daughter loves Big Bird (6)
|
NAN (relative) D (daughter) O O (loves) | |||
27 | SAMSHOO |
Drink in abandoned mansion house, ignoring strange ennui (7)
|
|
An anagram (‘abandoned’) of MA |
|||
29 | EMOTE |
Core ingredient of casserole: speck or ham (5)
|
|
E (middle letter or ‘core ingredient’ of casserole) MOTE (speck) | |||
31 | FUTON |
Periodically faulty, then working? Maybe sleep on it (5)
|
|
Alternate or ‘periodic’ letters of F |
|||
32 | ROTOLO |
Returning soldiers welcoming somewhere to go, carrying ton weight (6)
|
|
A reversal (‘returning’) of OR (other ranks – ‘soldiers’) round or ‘welcoming’ LOO (‘somewhere to go’) round or ‘carrying’ T (ton) – apparently an Italian form of ‘rotl’ – an E Mediterranean variable weight | |||
33 | MIRITI |
Motorway slowing down beside one tree (6)
|
|
MI (motorway) RIT (slowing down – in music) I (one) | |||
34 | COITUS |
Business’s appeal before US Congress (6)
|
|
CO (company – ‘business’) IT (appeal) US | |||
35 | PERSON | M |
Being a (timely) issue (6)
|
PER (a) SON (issue) | |||
36 | REBEC |
Isaac’s wife forgetting about former music producer (5)
|
|
REBEC |
|||
DOWN | |||
No. | Entry | Letter | |
1 | MISTRAL -reversed |
Humble, shy of outsiders, protecting first and second of grandchildren (7)
|
|
2 | ACEROSE | P |
A (spiky) flower, needle-pointed (7)
|
ACE (a) ROSE (flower) | |||
3 | FOEHN -reversed |
Environmentalists finally banish nuclear (5)
|
|
FOE (Friends of the Earth – ‘environmentalists’) H (last or ‘final’ letter of banish) N (nuclear) | |||
4 | GOES WITH |
Courts get who is criminal (8, 2 words)
|
|
An anagram (‘criminal’) of GET WHO IS | |||
5 | SHAMAL – reversed |
Indian singer, 50 (6)
|
|
SHAMA (Indian songbird or ‘singer’) L (50) | |||
6 | AND HOW |
A new boat? Yes indeed! (6, 2 words)
|
|
A N (new) DHOW (boat) | |||
7 | FRONDS |
Leaves priest getting drunk with police officer (6)
|
|
FR (father – ‘priest’) ON (drunk) DS (Detective Sergeant – ‘police officer’) | |||
8 | REDHEADS |
Studies covering Dutch ambassador’s birds (8)
|
|
READS (studies) round or ‘covering’ D (Dutch) HE (His Excellency – ‘ambassador’) | |||
9 | AULA |
Support group securing United League’s hall (4)
|
|
AA (Alcoholics Anonymous – ‘support group’) round or ‘securing’ U (United) L (League) | |||
11 | BETS |
Opinions of British and French society (4)
|
|
B (British) ET (French for ‘and’) S (society) | |||
16 | GAS-MOTOR |
Engine chat with Mauretanian touring Thailand (8)
|
|
GAS (chat) MOOR (Mauretanian) round or ‘touring’ T (Thailand) | |||
18 | ID AL-FITR |
Airlift last of food cooked for festival (8, 2 words)
|
|
An anagram (‘cooked’) of AIRLIFT and D (last letter of food) – we’d never heard of this festival, celebrated on the first day after Ramadan | |||
21 | COCOTTE | T |
(Tasty) dish made with edible tuber and dry slice of eggplant (7)
|
COCO (edible tuber) TT (teetotal – ‘dry’) E (first letter or ‘slice’ of eggplant) | |||
22 | CHINOOK – reversed |
Greek character with sexual partner that is to be ignored (7)
|
|
CHI (Greek character) NOOK |
|||
24 | ESTOCS | O |
Swords shown by English (platoon) upset Caledonians (6)
|
E (English) + a reversal (‘upset’) of SCOTS (Caledonians) | |||
25 | EOZOON |
Mixed ozone and oxygen to create fossil possibly (6)
|
|
An anagram (‘mixed’) of OZONE and O (oxygen) | |||
26 | SIMOON – reversed |
Selling ecclesiastical benefice on taking over city (6)
|
|
SIMO |
|||
27 | SERB | P |
European cured beef chopped up, 50% off (4)
|
A reversal (‘up’) of BRES |
|||
28 | EURUS – reversed |
Capital essentially popular for nothing (5)
|
|
EUR |
|||
30 | MOUE |
Pout from timid type, casting off shyness in the end (4)
|
|
MOU |
Ah, so that’s where it ended up Henri. 🙂
A big thanks to Bertandjoyce for the blog! And thank you to anyone that solved this at or after York. I wasn’t expecting any comments on here [given it was (a) an S&B puzzle, (b) I wasn’t there and (c) it’s a barred thematic!] but pleased to see one from an early test solver 🙂
I had a little trouble deciding which words were the “extra” words. Spiky? Tasty? Strange, maybe? Not always obvious. Nonetheless, I completed the grid and figured out what was going on with the six inverted winds, but still could not see what FROMPTOP was “assisting” me with. Oh, well. There are only two Ps in the grid, so maybe I should have stared at it a bit longer. Well constructed and really quite challenging.