Bluebird sets the Independent challenge today.
This is a puzzle where the clues and the grid are awash with creatures.
In the grid I see RAT, BEAR, BAT, CAT, BAY, SPRINGBOK, FOX, ADDER, COW, FLY, LADYBIRD, HOG, OX and KITE.
In the clues, we have dogs (two), badger, steed, cattle, pussy, fish, whale, turtle, horse, ox, tiger and hen. The film KES referred to in the wordplay at 25 down is based around a kestrel
There may well be others that I have missed.
I liked the surface of the clue for STAMPEDES at 4 across. There seems to be quite a lot going on in the clue for CATHOLIC and I think there are three ways of solving the clue.
| No | Detail |
| Across | |
| 1 | Without hesitation, gun dogs can lead you to badger holes (5)
SETTS (badger burrows; badger holes) SETTerS (any of various breeds of large gun dogs) excluding (without) ER (expression of hesitation) SETTS |
| 4 | What may arise from steeds rushing across pampa unconfined? (9)
STAMPEDES (sudden mass rush of a panic-stricken herd; descriptive of steed rushing across the pampa[vast treeless plains] in an uncontrolled manner) Anagram of (rushing) STEEDS containing (across) AMP (letters remaining in pAMPa when the outer letters P and A are removed [unconfined]) ST (AMP) EDES* |
| 9 | Upset conductor by beginning to dance (7)
RATTLED (upset) RATTLE (reference Sir Simon RATTLE [born 1955], British conductor) + D (first letter of [beginning to] Dance RATTLE D |
| 10 | Black uniform seen on colonel in charge of tending cattle (7)
BUCOLIC (relating to the tending of cattle) B (black, on lead pencils) + U (uniform) + COL (colonel) + I/C (in charge) B U COL IC |
| 11 | British Rail have transport in Paddington, for one (5,4)
BROWN BEAR (The fictional bear, Paddington, from the stories by Michael Bond [1926 -2017], is a BROWN BEAR) BR (British Rail) + OWN (have) + BEAR (carry; transport) BR OWN BEAR |
| 12 | Remove the first piece of toilet paper – it’s coming out (5)
ISSUE (a physical publication of a newspaper, for example; something that comes out) tISSUE (toilet paper) excluding the first letter (remove the first piece) T ISSUE |
| 13 | Cook, say, flour, eggs and milk (6)
BATTER (both cook and BATTER can mean ‘to spoil or damage’ something) BATTER (in cookery, a BATTER is formed from a combination of flour, eggs and milk) double definition BATTER |
| 14 | Liberal chap obsessed with pussy? (8)
CATHOLIC (broad-minded; liberal) CAT (man or chap) + –HOLIC (suffix indicating a person having an abnormal desire or obsession for something; obsessed) A cryptic definition of CAT HOLIC could be ‘someone obsessed with a CAT [pussy]) CAT HOLIC |
| 17 | Tropical fish, whales and a turtle? (8)
TETRAPOD (any vertebrate that has four limbs; a turtle, for example) TETRA (any of various species of tropical freshwater fish of the family Characidae) + POD (a group of whales) TETRA POD |
| 19 | Dog’s beaten – how sad (6)
SHADOW (trail; dog) Anagram of (beaten) HOW SAD SHADOW* |
| 22 | Dash alongside horse to force into an inlet (5)
EMBAY (force into a BAY or inlet) EM (a printer’s term for a dash or space which is the width of a letter m) + BAY (a reddish-brown horse) EM BAY |
| 24 | Rugby player from Britain doing fine at the end of the season (9)
SPRINGBOK (South African rugby player) SPRING (season) + B (British) + OK (doing fine) SPRING B OK |
| 26 | Something dug by female ox left wearing digging tool (7)
FOXHOLE (small entrenchment; something dug) F (female) + OX + (L [left] contained in [wearing] HOE [a garden digging tool]) F OX HO (L) E |
| 27 | Parsnip in frying pan, both sides of which are modified (7)
SKIRRET (water parsnip) SKILLET (frying pan [especially in North America]) with both Ls (left hand side] replaced by [modified] R [right hand side]) to form SKIRRET SKIRRET |
| 28 | Song by prog rock band rated ‘weird’, but then, at last, ‘revolutionary’ (9)
YESTERDAY (song written by Paul McCartney [born 1942], but credited to Lennon-McCartney) YES (name of a prog rock band) + an anagram of (weird) RATED + Y (final letter of [at last] revolutionarY) YES TERDA* Y |
| 29 | Decontaminating a sesspool containing ammonia and methane? (5)
GASES (ammonia and methane are examples of GASES) GASES (hidden word in [containing] decontaminatinG A SESspool) GASES |
| Down | |
| 1 | Small baby tiger, say, runs inside bush (5)
SCRUB (bush) S (small) + (R [runs] contained in [inside] CUB [name for a baby tiger]) S C (R) UB |
| 2 | Charlie’s atop castle with traitor beheaded in retaliation (3,3,3)
TIT FOR TAT (retailiation in kind) TIT (idiot; charlie) + FORT (small fortress; castle) + rAT (traitor) excluding the first letter (beheaded) R TIT FOR T AT – as this is a down entry the letters TIT are atop the remaining letters |
| 3 | Stop speaking, because Roland Barthes’s article is boring (7)
SILENCE (command directing someone to stop speaking) LE (French [Roland Barthes] form of the indefinite article, the) contained in (is boring) SINCE (because) SI (LE) NCE |
| 4 | Head for Schwarzkopf counter further down (6)
SADDER (further down[cast]) S (first letter of [head for] Schwarzkopf) + ADDER (one who counts; counter) S ADDER |
| 5 | A right bad smell coming from the heart of trees (8)
ARBOREAL (of, or of the nature of, trees) A + R (right) + BO (body odour; bad smell) + REAL (sincere; coming from the heart) A R BO REAL |
| 6 | Gregory is hot and hungry (7)
PECKISH (somewhat hungry) PECK (reference the actor Gregory PECK [1916 – 2003], American actor) + IS + H (hot) PECK IS H |
| 7 | Northern valleys the source of slate and lead supply (5)
DALES (valleys through which rivers flow, a term commonly used in Northern England, e.g. the Yorkshire Dales) Anagram of (supply [derived from supple]) S [first letter of [source of] State and LEAD DALES* |
| 8 | Afraid, move around bully that’s beyond reproach (6,3)
SACRED COW (an institution, custom, etc, so venerated that it is above criticism; something beyond reproach) SCARED (afraid) with the letters rearranged [move around] to form SACRED + COW (to intimidate or bully) – may also be based on CA (circa; about; around) being reversed (moved) to AC SACRED COW |
| 13 | Frivolous person that’s fat carried by stagecoach (9)
BUTTERFLY (a frivolous, flighty person) BUTTER (a type of fat) + FLY (historical term for a fast stagecoach) BUTTER FLY – as this is a down entry BUTTER is above or carried by FLY |
| 15 | Red, winged creatures – hens? (9)
LADYBIRDS (winged creatures, mostly red in colour, but there are variants in other colours) LADY BIRDS (hens are female or LADY BIRDS) cryptic definition LADYBIRDS |
| 16 | Large cask holds all of beer’s froth (8)
HOGSHEAD ( Shakespearean term for large cask; a measure of capacity = 52.5 imperial gallons, or 63 old wine gallons) HOGS (selfishly holds all of) + HEAD (froth on beer) HOGS HEAD |
| 18 | From now on, the heart of Queen Mary is broken (3,4)
ANY MORE (from now, definition in Collins) Anagram of (is broken) ON and E (middle letter of [heart of] quEen and MARY ANY MORE* |
| 20 | Looking for money dropped outside (7)
HUNTING (looking for) HUNG (dropped) containing (outside) (TIN (money) HUN (TIN) G |
| 21 | Macabre girls mutilated the backside of teddy (6)
GRISLY (macabre) Anagram of (mutilated) GIRLS + Y (last letter of [backside of] teddY) GRISL* Y |
| 23 | Socks and pants abandoned by the side of river (5)
BOXES (hits; socks) BOXErS (BOXER shorts; loose fitting underpants for men) excluding (abandoned) R (letter on either side of the word RiveR) BOXES |
| 25 | High-flown things I start to think during film (5)
KITES (items that fly high in the sky) (I + T [first letter of {start to} Think]) contained in (during) KES (1969 British coming-of-age drama film) K (I T) ES |

I was sailing through this lovely, smooth and witty puzzle until I came to a bit of a halt in the SW. I daresay I have encountered EMBAYS in another crossword but never in real life and that would not come to mind -even with the likely EM at the beginning. It intersected with ANY MORE which also beat me – I suspected an anagram but never spotted that ON was part of it and did not recognise the def. Faves inc SHADOW, SPRINGBOK, SADDER, ARBOREAL, LADYBIRDS, HOGSHEAD and BOXES. Paddington, of course, was a BROWN BEAR in more ways than one.
Thanks Bluebird and duncan
SACRED COW
I think
around=C and C is moved.
Liked STAMPEDES, CATHOLIC, HOGSHEAD, TIT FOT TAT, SHADOW, SILENCE and BOXES.
Thanks Bluebird and duncan
An extraordinary puzzle which took no time at all to solve three quarters and then an eon of staring at the southwest quarter and revealing three clues in frustration.
Perhaps Bluebird set the SW corner on a different day from the rest!
Thanks all
I was too preoccupied making a pig’s ear of the SW to take much notice of the rest of the menagerie. I thought inlet might be bay, but failed to remember the totally standard bit of crosswordese, dash = em, grrr! So I cheated by guess-check for a couple of letters to finish. ‘Any more’ for ‘from now’ is slyly oblique. Skirret the parsnip waa a newie, nice word, and the pussyholic raised a grin. Enjoyed it despite a bit of pain, ta Bluebird and Duncan.
ANY MORE
I assumed ‘From now on’ was the def. Also assumed a double duty for ‘on’.
Duncan says ‘from now’ for ANY MORE is in Collins. So, no issues except
that I would be happy to see an example sentence in which the interchangeability
of these two phrases is established.
I think “I won’t do it any more/ from now” works although “from now on” would probably work better. Maybe somebody can come up with a better case for substitution
I’ve a feeling that BATTER might have been overthought. I took it as referring to Sir Alastair Cook, one of Englands greatest ever batsmen – or ‘batter’ in todays gender neutral newspeak.
Certainly a slightly different challenge with a setter on a slightly different wavelength.
Thanks to Bluebird and duncan
You might well be right, Doofs @7, never occurred to me though I’m a cricket lover.
That’s how I read it Doofs@7.
Beaten by ANY MORE and oblivious to the arkful of animals, but that’s quite normal for me.
Thanks both.
I’m another who thought of Alistair Cook for the BATTER; I don’t really follow cricket much, but I have heard of him. I was, however, unfamiliar with the conductor, so RATTLED was a bit mysterious until I came here. Also unparsed was BOXES; I’d forgotten that in Britain “pants” are underwear, not trousers. Thanks to duncanshiell for explaining both.
I agree that the right half went along like a well-oiled machine, while the bottom left quadrant sputtered to a halt like a worn-out jalopy. But I did get there in the end!
I really don’t understand how Charlie gets you to tit, I can’t see the link to idiot…
MN @ 11
Chambers gives one definition of Charlie as “a credulous person; an inefficient, ineffectual person, a fool, often in the phrase a proper Charlie”
Collins has a similar definition
For tit, Collins uses the definition: “A foolish person: often used as a term of address”.
Often used in the phrase “that person is a right tit”
I think therefore that ‘fool’ links Charlie and tit
I’m another who ground to a halt in the SW corner, after relatively good progress to that point. Several clues that I thought I understood, but which never quite worked as expected. I’m happy with “from now” as a def, I just always seemed to read it as “from now on” and consequently had fodder of E+MARY+IS, which unsurprisingly came to nothing.
Thanks Bluebird and Duncan.
Thanks both. I liked SACRED COW. Those two simple words ANY MORE have certainly occupied many, myself included. Personally, I see it as an oddity (noting any dictionary support makes it fair game) as it’s not a standalone expression, and needs specific context, as if I were telling someone “I don’t sleep in a cot any more”, I would not mean I had done it up until that moment.
I had the same experience as everyone else, with the SW seeming like it was a different puzzle! I started revealing there, but wished I’d persevered with FOXHOLE instead but F-OX seemed soo obvious that I dismissed it out of hand! With the X I think I would have made a path through the rest. As it was, I revealed ANY MORE and BOXES.
I interpreted ANY MORE as per Hovis@6 though it’s pretty sly since “from now on” it clearly the more common variant and so, like others, I wasn’t aware that I had the ON to play with.
As a side note, I was tickled by TIT FOR TAT and reckon it’s ripe for picking in a clue related to some sort of dodgy product exchange on eBay…
Overall I enjoyed spotting the many animals on this pleasant safari. Thanks both!