
Henri (aka Rob T) has kindly provided a puzzle for the enjoyment of attendees at the 2025 Nottingham S&B, although unfortunately he couldn’t be there himself, to receive the bouquets (or brickbats?!) from said attendees. For those who weren’t at the event, there is a copy <here> for you to download and solve before reading the blog, if you so wish…
A brief preamble states that:
“Every grid entry is an ANAGRAM of its clue’s answer. Numbers in regular brackets refer to grid entries; if the original answer is a different number of words to the grid entry, this is {noted per clue like so}.”
Sounds simple enough! Although it does mean there will be a lot of cold-solving at first, until a few crossing words are found – either likely anagrams to give actual crossers, or where crossing words only share a couple of letters, reducing the permutations for the crossing cells.
(I’m sure I must have seen/solved similar ‘all-anagrammed’ puzzles before, but not too often, and not in recent memory. I’m sure there will be people with better/longer memories than me who might point out a few in the comments below… Also the bloggers were given advance sight of the S&B puzzles – I haven’t written all this up on the train back from Nottingham, apart from adding a few finishing touches!)
This turned out to be a puzzle of four quarters (with a few stragglers) for your correspondent. In the bottom-right corner PURIST changing to a (4,2) had to be STIR UP, and USED CAR as a (7) was most likely CRUSADE, meaning GRUNTS would probably be STRUNG…and so on, until I had most of that quadrant except 31A.
After a bit of a break, I came back to this and hit a vein of form in the top right, with TSARINAS -> ARTISANS as the way in, and ROBINIA -> NAIROBI raising an appreciative eyebrow. Again, this quadrant filled up mostly, apart from 12A.
Then the top left – CHIT -> ITCH led to PACIEST -> ASEPTIC, and the two nine-letters starting with E – EVALUATED and EGOMANIAC.
There followed another break, as the bottom left proved a bit chewier, and other blogging and prize puzzle submissions took priority.
I got hung up on ROMANCE -> CAMERON, which meant LADEN might be LANED, but those led to a few dead ends and it took ENCLAVE -> VALENCE and INFLATOR -> FLATIRON to put me straight with MENORCA and ELAND.
In amongst the corners, the 10s and 4s across the middle rows provided the glue to pull things together, and I eventually got the stragglers – DEPOSITOR -> DROOPIEST and COSINESS -> CESSIONS, with the latter needing a look-up to check it was a real word!
And there we have it – the original answers are ALL SHOOK UP to give the final grid:
A couple of nice touches, in that the E of CURÉ is also accented in ÉCRU, at least in the French version, and the palindromic TOOT anagrams to another palindrome in OTTO (although I did initially pencil in PEEP as a palindromic blast on a horn…).
It’s a bouquet from me – although it turned out to be harder than I initially expected – and my thanks to Henri for an interesting and enjoyable challenge.
(In my opinion this wouldn’t have been out of place as a Grauniad Genius, or could maybe have found a slot in one of the various crossword magazines, either of which outcome might have earned Henri a fee, so I think it is worth once again expressing gratitude to him for submitting it to the S&B, which only pays out in kudos – and maybe beers, for those setters who do attend!)
Across | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Clue No | Solution / Entry | Clue (definition underlined)
Logic/parsing |
||
1A | COME AGAIN / EGOMANIAC | What profit after business has money to repay regularly? {2 words} (9)
CO (company, business) + M (economics, money, as in M0, M1) + E A (regular letters from ‘rEpAy’) + GAIN (profit) |
||
6A | TUNAS / AUNTS | Sending back South America’s obsessive swimmers (5)
SA (South America) + NUT (obsessive), all sent back to give TUNAS [Chambers gives ‘tuna’ and ‘tunas’ as plurals of ‘tuna’] |
||
9A | PACIEST / ASEPTIC | Most rapid agreement about that is suspicious at first (7)
PAC_T (agreement) around IE (id est, that is) + S (first letter of Suspicious) |
||
10A | NITRATE / NATTIER | Gordon ultimately furious about introduction of table salt (7)
N (ultimate letter of gordoN) + I_RATE (furious) around T (first letter, or introduction, of Table) |
||
11A | HOUNDS / UNSHOD | Harasses more than one setter? (6)
double defn – to HOUND is to harrass; and a setter, or dog, is a HOUND |
||
12A | COSINESS / CESSIONS | Drop of sherry after functions providing comfort (8)
COSINES (mathematical trigonometric functions) + S (first letter of, or a drop of, Sherry) [loi] |
||
14A | STOW / TOWS | Place in sun to start to warm (4)
S (sun) + TO + W (start to Warm) |
||
15A | CONTINGENT / CONTENTING | Group of people in Africa, perhaps outside government (10)
CONTIN_ENT (Africa, for example) around (outside of) G (government) |
||
19A | REDEVELOPS / DEVELOPERS | Before cuts, socialist First Lady carries out urban regeneration (10)
RED (socialist, left-leaning) + EVE (biblical first lady) + LOPS (cuts) |
||
21A | CURÉ / ÉCRU | Parisian priest‘s dry food (4)
double defn. (ignoring accent) – a CURÉ is a French priest; and to CURE can be to dry food [both CURÉ and ÉCRU have an accented E!] |
||
24A | TOTALLED / ALLOTED | Kicked around thanks to Roller essentially being written off (8)
TO_ED (kicked) around TA (thanks to) + LL (essence, or middle, of roLLer) |
||
26A | GRUNTS / STRUNG | German manages to entertain first of the low-ranking soldiers (6)
G (German) + RUN_S (manages) around (entertaining) T (first of The) |
||
28A | ROMANCE / MENORCA | King’s church touring Arab nation is kind of novel (7)
R (rex, king) + CE (Church of England) around (touring) OMAN (Arab nation) |
||
29A | RETRACE / TERRACE | Go back over vintage style shortly before expert (7)
RETR( |
||
30A | RENTS / STERN | Lets rip at son (5)
RENT (tear, rip) + S (son) |
||
31A | DEPOSITOR / DROOPIEST | Bank customer’s departure, on vacation? Assume otherwise (9)
DE (D |
||
Down | ||||
Clue No | Solution / Entry | Clue (definition underlined)
Logic/parsing |
||
1D | VALUE DATE / EVALUATED | Victor, having beer around university, departs – worried when financial obligations are due {2 words} (9)
V (victor, phonetic alphabet) + AL_E (beer) around U (university), plus D (departs) + ATE (worried) |
||
2D | AVOWERS / OVERSAW | They declare that hurts in States (7)
AV_ERS (states, verbally) around OW (that hurt!) |
||
3D | ATONIC / ACTION | From Genoa to Nice with no accent (6)
hidden word in, i.e. from, ‘genoA TO NICe’ |
||
4D | CHIT / ITCH | Note from cleaners originally on strike (4)
C (initial letter of Cleaners) + HIT (strike) |
||
5D | OCEAN / CANOE | Main article supporting old church (5)
O (old) + CE (Church of England, again) + AN (indefinite article) |
||
6D | TSARINAS / ARTISANS | Tenor and soprano’s songs about northern empresses (8)
T (tenor) + S (soprano) + ARI_AS (songs) around N (northern) |
||
7D | ROBINIA / NAIROBI | Plant held back by chain I borrowed (7)
reversed hidden word in, i.e. held back by, ‘chAIN I BORrowed’ |
||
8D | RISES / SIRES | Comes up with rubbish at first, is extremely egregious (5)
R (Rubbish, at first) + IS + ES (extreme letters of EgregiouS) |
||
13D | PROM / ROMP | Dance for money (4)
PRO (for, in favour of) + M (money, economics, again) |
||
16D | ROTE / TORE | For the time being, exposed repetition (4)
( |
||
17D | GESTURING / GRUNGIEST | Acknowledges Turin grudgingly to some extent, waving? (9)
hidden word in, i.e. to some extent, ‘acknowledGES TURIN Grudgingly’ |
||
18D | INFLATOR / FLATIRON | Bike pump in apartment owner left empty (8)
IN + FLAT (apartment) + OR (O |
||
20D | ENCLAVE / VALENCE | In Spain once, wanting nothing, welcoming somewhere to go in protected zone (7)
E (Espana, Spain) + ( |
||
22D | USED CAR / CRUSADE | Employer taking daughter about in secondhand vehicle {2 words} (7)
USE_R (employer) around (taking) D (daughter) + CA (circa, about) |
||
23D | PURIST / STIR UP | Pedant quietly starts to understand, ‘right’ is sometimes tactless {1 word} (4,2)
P (piano, music, quietly) + URIST (first letters of, or starts to, ‘Understand Right Is Sometimes Tactless’ |
||
24D | MACES / ACMES | A second supporting member of clubs (5)
M (member of, as in MP, Member of Parliament) above, or supported by, in a Down clue, ACE (A, symbol in cards) + S (second) |
||
25D | LADEN / ELAND | Young man, nurse, is loaded (5)
LAD (young man) + EN (Enrolled Nurse) |
||
27D | TOOT / OTTO | Whichever way you look at it – it’s a blast! (4)
CD? TOOT (blast) is a palindrome, so is TOOT whichever way you look at it! [As is OTTO!] |
Very good fun, thanks to Henri and mc-rapper. Not sure I would have attempted it without electronic backup!
Many thanks mc_rapper67 for an excellent and comprehensive blog! As a Francophone I am particularly impressed that you noticed the É in CURÉ and ÉCRU 😁
It’s interesting that you made the comparison to a Guardian Genius puzzle as I must confess a debt of inspiration to Genius #255 by Soup, who used the same device. One of my cruciverbal ambitions is to get a puzzle in the Genius slot one day…
Still hoping to finish this one, enjoying it so far, so I have not yet read the blog.
An interesting challenge, which took me some time, and I failed to see ROTE/TORE at the end. I found the cold solving quite tough (I am not good at barred grid puzzles), and though I did find anagrams for most of the solutions on paper, I did use aids a little to check that there weren’t too many alternative anagrams. Also had the same journey with CAMERON and LANED as mc_rapper. A very clever construction which deserves a wider audience.
beery hiker @4 — thanks for your nice feedback, I may yet post this up on MyCrossword, although it would perhaps be towards the upper end of difficulty on there !
beery hiker @4 — thanks for your nice feedback, I may yet post this up on MyCrossword, although it would perhaps be towards the upper end of difficulty on there !
Edit: not sure why that appeared twice, maybe I confused it having two names saved on different devices ? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Footnote: there is a Mini Crossword (7×7) using the same device (but different words!) here.
I finally finished this. Quite an exercise. I was certain that I had solved a Genius puzzle using the same device, but I could not remember which one. This sort of ingenuity never gets old, as far as I am concerned. Well done.