This week’s 11 x 11 crossword from the Guardian, intended to teach cryptic crosswords, found here
This week we have the 17th Quick Cryptic by Carpathian, who was setting these puzzles on alternate weeks at the start, but hasn’t set a puzzle since puzzle 49. She is a regular setter at the Guardian and elsewhere. Today we only have anagrams and hidden clues with all the letters given, plus reversals and charades, all of which have met before. Still in the app and I suspect in the published paper, but now corrected on the website, there are a couple of mistakes, noted below.
The whole point of these crosswords is support and encouragement of new solvers, so special rules for these crosswords apply – see here – those rules include not posting solving times.
This blog continues to develop in response to suggestions. We hide the answers and the wordplay descriptions (parsing) too. To find the solution click on “Answer” and to find how the word play works, click on “Parsing” which will reveal the hidden information. You can choose to reveal everything using the “Expand All” button. If you have partially revealed the page, refreshing it will clear that, and allow you to expand all. The definition is in bold and underlined, the indicator is in red.
For additional help click here
There is a summary of the tricks used in the first six months here and a Guardian Crossword blog called the ultimate beginner’s guide has tips which may be useful for some solvers
For abbreviations and clue tips click here
Fifteen Squared uses several abbreviations and jargon tricks, there’s a full list here, of which I’ve used the following in this blog:
- underlining the definition in the clue – this is either at the beginning or end of the clue
- indicators are in red.
- CAPITALS to indicate which bits are part of the answer, e.g. RApID for the lose the middle example, Give A Good joke for the acrostic example.
- anagram – letters being used shown in brackets (SENATOR)* for the clue below to give TREASON.
- anagrind – anagram indicator – in the case below it is “arranged”
- reversals – shown by the symbol < so from the example, the pet is a DOG <.
- charades – the description below only gives the example of words being added together, but charades can be more complicated, adding abbreviations or single letters to another word. Examples previously used in this series are: Son ridicules loose overgarments (6) S (son) + MOCKS (ridicules), Get rid of dead pine (5) D(dead) + ITCH (pine) – D ITCH, and early on DR (doctor) + IVE (I have) to give DRIVE.
- CAD or clue as definition– where the whole clue gives the definition, sometimes called an &lit. These are rare.
- DBE or defintion by example – e.g. where a dog might be clued as a setter – often using a question mark, maybe, possibly or e.g. to show that this is an example rather than a definition.
- surface – the meaning from reading the clue – so often cryptic clues use an English that could only be found in a cryptic crossword, but a smooth surface is a clue that has a meaning in English, which can be pointed or misleading.
TODAY’S TRICKS – from the crossword site – because the clues have moved on from the clue descriptions below, I am now adding more to the descriptions hidden above. Clues begin or end with a definition of the answer. The rest is one of these:
- Anagram An anagram of the answer and a hint that there’s an anagram
‘Senator arranged crime (7)’ gives TREASON - Hidden word Answer is hidden in the clue’s words
‘Some haVE ALtered meat (4)’ gives VEAL - Charade Combination of synonyms/abbrevs
‘Qualify to get drink for ID (8)’ gives PASSPORT (pass + port) - Reversal The answer backwards, and a hint that we’re reversing
‘Deity’s pet coming back (3)’ gives GOD from DOG (pet) <
| ACROSS | Click on “Answer” to see the solutions | |
| 1 |
Paddy harbours boomerangs (5)
|
AnswerSTROP |
Parsingreversal (boomerangs) of PORTS (harbours) < where paddy is being used as a synonym of a rage or pet. |
||
| 4 |
Neat electric vehicles reversing (5)
|
AnswerSMART |
Parsingreversal (reversing) of TRAMS (electric vehicles) < |
||
| 7 |
Person eagerly holding individual (3)
|
AnswerONE |
Parsinghidden (holding) in persON Eagerly |
||
| 8 |
At not time name first lady Queen (5)
|
AnswerNEVER |
Parsingcharade of N (name) + EVE (first lady) + R (queen) and I think there’s a typo in the definition and it should read “At no time” as it does now on the website. N for name we haven’t met in this series before, nor Eve as the first lady (as in the Bible), but R (regina) has been used in this series. |
||
| 9 |
Outcast people person embraces (5)
|
AnswerLEPER |
Parsinghidden (embraces) in peopLE PERson |
||
| 10 |
Aggressive dog: small number wanting restriction on time outside (6)
|
AnswerCURFEW |
Parsingcharade of CUR (aggressive dog) and FEW (small number) |
||
| 12 |
Prohibit bold, spiteful remark (4)
|
AnswerBARB |
Parsingcharade of BAR (prohibit) + B (bold – from wordprocessing software) – another new abbreviation in B for bold. The answer when revealing on the app and originally on the website was GARB, which makes no sense. It’s been corrected on the website, but these errors aren’t then corrected on the app or printed paper. |
||
| 14 |
Hit part of car apparently (3)
|
AnswerRAP |
Parsinghidden (part of) in caR APparently |
||
| 16 |
God going back to city in Egypt (4)
|
AnswerSUEZ |
Parsingreversal (going back) of ZEUS (god) <. The grammar of the clue is: parsing ZEUS (god) + action (going back) gives answer (SUEZ) to tell which way around this should be (not that it mattered to me as it was my last one in, I’d forgotten this reversal). |
||
| 17 |
Flipping student’s error (4-2)
|
AnswerSLIP-UP |
Parsingreversal (flipping) of PUPILS < (students) – and I think there’s another typo here – for this to work it should be plural for students to match pupils, so the apostrophe should indicate that – so students’ – and in this case it is not the possessive, but an apostrophe of omission, saying “flipping students is error” |
||
| 20 |
Art Al reconstructed somewhere in church (5)
|
AnswerALTAR |
Parsinganagram of (ART AL)* with anagrind of “reconstructed”. |
||
| 22 |
Plant in sea waving (5)
|
AnswerANISE |
Parsinganagram of (IN SEA)* with anagrind of “waving” to give this plant. |
||
| 23 |
Article by new woman (3)
|
AnswerANN |
Parsingcharade of AN (article – indefinite article) + N (new – abbreviation – as in New York/NY) – woman cluing a woman’s name is a regular in British crosswords – I know that this is not allowed in American crosswords, but it is standard in the UK. |
||
| 24 |
Dug revolting material (5)
|
AnswerDENIM |
Parsingreversal (revolting) of MINED < (dug) – this is another clue we’ve seen before – and when I was doing the puzzle, I only entered the middle N as I wasn’t sure of which was the answer MINED or DENIM until I had more crossers to confirm. |
||
| 25 |
At that point ether exploded (5)
|
AnswerTHERE |
Parsinganagram of (ETHER)* with anagrind of “exploded” |
||
|
DOWN
|
||
| 1 | Travelling around the speed of sound, coins melted (5) |
AnswerSONIC |
Parsinganagram of (COINS)* with anagrind of “melted” |
||
| 2 |
Setback concerning poetry (7)
|
AnswerREVERSE |
Parsingcharade of RE (concerning) + VERSE (poetry) – RE gets used a lot in cryptic puzzles, as concerning / on / about / referring to – and it comes from business jargon. |
||
| 3 |
Hotel employee in stop or terminus (6)
|
AnswerPORTER |
Parsinghidden (in) stoP OR TERminus |
||
| 4 |
Ego of small magical being (4)
|
AnswerSELF |
Parsingcharade of S (small – from clothing sizes) + ELF (magical being). |
||
| 5 |
Victoria’s python consumed another snake (3)
|
AnswerASP |
Parsinghidden (consumed) in victoriA’S Python. |
||
| 6 |
Beat broth wildly (5)
|
AnswerTHROB |
Parsinganagram of (BROTH)* with anagrind of “wildly” |
||
| 11 |
Lived with a son (3)
|
AnswerWAS |
Parsingcharade of W (with) + A (from the clue) + S (son – from genealogy) and we’ve had this use of the verb to be before – used to mean lived / existed. |
||
| 13 |
Brief application increase (7)
|
AnswerAPPRISE |
Parsingcharade of APP (application – as in phones or computers) + RISE (increase) |
||
| 15 |
Flexible plan – it changed (6)
|
AnswerPLIANT |
Parsinganagram of (PLAN IT)* with anagrind of “changed” – and this clue has two options that could both be anagrinds: flexible and changed. |
||
| 16 |
Saint with bear (5)
|
AnswerSTAND |
Parsingcharade of ST (saint) + AND (with) – St for saint is often seen, but we also see S for Saint, and SS for the plural. |
||
| 18 |
Groupie celebrated hiding titbit (5)
|
AnswerPIECE |
Parsinghidden (hiding) in grouPIE CElebrated. |
||
| 19 |
Caught sheep pack (4)
|
AnswerCRAM |
Parsingcharade of C (caught – cricketing terminology) + RAM (sheep – specifically a male sheep) |
||
| 21 |
Section of vibrant, entertaining number (3)
|
AnswerTEN |
Parsinghidden (section of) in vibranT ENtertaining. |

Is “revolting” for reversal common? I suppose you could argue that someone living in revolting conditions is living in “backward” conditions.
Thanks Shanne. Shame about the typo in the clue for NEVER, and the error in the revealed answer for BARB. I thought the clue for SLIP-UP was okay, ignoring all punctuation.
APPRISE was my LOI. Credit to Carpathian for the misdirection with brief (adjective) application. Instead the def was brief, verb.
STROP and PADDY from the clue, and PET from Shanne’s blog, are 3 words/synonyms not very well known in my dialect and which I had to learn early on in my cryptic journey. (Nothing to do with my moniker though.) We tend to use words like ”tantrum” or ”hissy-fit”.
I enjoyed Carpathian’s concise cluing, entertaining surfaces, misdirections, eg brief as mentioned, bear noun and verb, the tenses in hit and rap.
Dug revolting material, and the Groupie clue were amusing.
DylanN@1. I’ve seen revolting as a reversal indicator before, but I can’t find a source or a dictionary entry to support that. I wouldn’t mind it so much in a down clue, because to me it has the connotation of ”rising up”.
Just to add, I did find the surface for STROP a bit hard to visualise. A paddy (field) of boomerangs? Or someone called Paddy with a collection of them?
Thought there were some tougher def/answers like “setback=reverse”, “brief=apprise” and needed an alphatrawl to get to Suez – had never realised it’s a city as well as a canal! Thanks to Shanne for the blog and to Carpathian.
My talkthrough solve is available at .. https://youtu.be/x0_qp5ktWNA .. for anyone looking for tips and tactics on how to approach solving. Today I demonstrate how, even when you’ve been doing these for a few years, they aren’t always a write-in!
There were some nice clues – and I particularly liked 4a where electric was misleading & clever, ONE, SELF, and THERE.
But there was also a lot of loose cluing or editing or both – many mentioned already plus a couple of other clues that bugged me.
Thanks Carpathian and Shanne
So annoying about the typos.
Like HG@5, I also hadn’t realised suez was a city! My geography is rubbish!
Can someone explain the rules of allowing a single letter (eg w from with in 11d)? )
I thought it had to be a used abbreviation (eg s for south) – or indicate in the clue that it was the first letter of a word ?
Enjoyable crossword though – thanks Carpathian and Shanne for your ( as always ) very helpful blog
Hi Holly @8 – w as an abbreviation for with is in Chambers – in the last of the four lists (week, wife, with). As we’ve seen it before I didn’t do a lot of detail on it. I suspect it comes from prescription abbreviations – R(x) q.o.d w aq sorry, it’s a pdf – which translates as take four times a day with water. R and w turn up in puzzles regularly. But you also see e.g w/bath as an abbreviation in say estate agent listings to say the bathroom has a bath.
Basically the rule is that a single word abbreviation has to be recognised, so in dictionaries.
Holly@8, according to Google’s AI, the use of “w/” as an abbreviation for “with” is believed to have originated in the fast-food industry in the 1950s as a way for waitresses to quickly write down orders. Similarly w/o is without. No doubt it’s in Chambers or Collins, which is the usual requirement for use of such abbreviations.
[Cross-post with Shanne]
I felt there were too many single letter abbreviations at play in this with WAS being the most egregious using W from ‘with’. But all in all it was mostly Carpathian’s fair clueing. I must have been a bit late for the typo and starting letter issues. Thanks Carpathian for the puzzle and Shanne for the blog.
thecronester @11 – if the Quick Cryptics don’t use the regular abbreviations, how are learners supposed to learn them. W for with is everywhere in cryptic crosswords – I read clues which include with and start building words using w. And it has long usage – prescription language often turns up in crosswords.
Thanks for the excellent blog Shanne. FYI the error in 12a has been corrected on the iPhone App, but the other mistakes are still there.
Shanne @ 12. Yes I understand the principle and I’m fine with stuff like C for ‘caught’ and S from ‘short’ and B from ‘bold’ as these seem genuine abbreviations and I know the context they come from. With the W from ‘with’ it just seemed arbitrary and I’m not sure I know what context it comes from, but that’s probably just a lack of knowledge on my part.
For 8a I had ER for first lady queen leaving Nev for name! While that was possible it didn’t impress me much. The correct parsing is much better and I should have realised that “lady queen” was unnecessary and that ER wasn’t the first queen. Hey ho, we live and learn .
Shanne@9 and AP@10. Thank you – so I was correct that it has to be a recognised abbreviation , I just didn’t understand how w was one. But now I do. Onwards and upwards !
Holly Anderson @16 and thecronester @14 – as further justification of the use of w for with, I was reminded I have a book on reading English Handwriting from 1150-1750 from when I was researching a local site. In an inventory from 1638, with is being abbreviated to w and a superscript. (I had a feeling I’d seen it in early documents, scribes use a lot of shorthand, it’s where ye for the comes from – the thorn being shorter to write than th.)
thecronester @14 – if you read the comments @ 9 and 10, you’ll see several explanations of the use of w for with.
Shanne @ 17. Thanks, I’ve read through the comments now and see how it’s justified. New knowledge for me, and also the wider idea w.r.t. prescription language usage.
Loads of misdirections here!! I had lots of ( wrong) alternatives. I read 20A as “ART AI” but the crossing words made me get it finally. Still struggling with charades and there were lots here. But 2D and 4D made me laugh. Also noticed that 25A is both anagram and hidden word. That was helpful!! So Shanne is once again totally essential for me but thanks Carpathian for the BIG challenge
Hello Shanne, since we all come here for explanations I don’t see the point in hiding them until clicked. I find it a bit of an irritation.
But thank you so much – you’re an essential part of the game!
Florrie Boleyn @20 – we were asked to put this blog together with hidden solutions and explanations to give different levels of support. The idea is that if you’re really stuck you can come to the blog and see what the definition is and maybe some idea of the clue type from the indicators, or you can check a few solutions without having to see everything. There have been a number of requests that we extend this style to the Quiptic, but it’s a fair bit of extra work, so we’re not extending it.
The other option as someone coming to read the blog is to click the “expand all” and see everything as if it’s a standard blog, which isn’t a lot more effort.
I thought 17a was okay, on the basis that STUDENT’S is PUPIL’S, which reverses to SLIP-UP.
If there’s an issue with the apostrophe (i.e. that it would be S’LIPUP) then wouldn’t the same apply to the hyphen, wherever you put the apostrophe? I’m always unsure over the rules for punctuation in cryptic clues, so a long time ago I decided it was simpler to assume there (generally) aren’t any. Perhaps that’s wrong?
GillGamesh @22 the usual rule for getting from the question to the answer is to ignore punctuation, except sometimes the definition is the punctuation. However, the clue should be grammatical within itself, so I was complaining in this clue that the apostrophe was of omission not possession (as it was pretending to mislead),
Flipping student’s error (4-2) reads as the turning of the error of one student or turning a student is an error, but to get SLIP UP you need to turn several students/pupils.
so make the clue work it needed to be students’
Thanks Shanne @23. I’m still not sure why it can’t be turning “student’s” or “pupil’s”. It’s the letters that are flipped, and they’re all there, regardless of where you put the apostrophe. You need to turn several students, or one student plus possessive s.
The surface meaning is separate, and involves flipping as an adjectival euphemistic curse word. ‘The error of one fli**ing student’. That works, and inverting the letters works for the parsing.
Bit like I said above, I’m never sure how much I can ignore punctuation in parsing.
LOI 16A, and my first attempt was Deus. Shamefully. Otherwise I found it nicely straightforward.