Independent 11,336 / Phi

Phi has provided the last in this week’s string of mid-week puzzles.

I found this to be towards the harder end of the Indy spectrum, and although I think that I have successfully completed the grid, I am not sure of the parsing of some of the clues, e.g. at 17 (“spread”), 23 (“not at present” and 18 (“gifts of the Church”). I look forward to hearing what other solvers made of these clues.

I have spotted no particular theme today, other than a couple of ballet references.

My favourite clues today are 1, 9 and 24, all for smoothness of surface.

*(…) indicates an anagram; definitions are italicised; // separates definitions in multiple-definition clues

Across    
     
01 ICECAP Expert in copper and iodine backing polar region

[ACE (=expert) in PC (=copper, i.e. Police Constable)] + I (=iodine); “backing” indicates reversal

     
05 QUASARS Astronomical phenomena: question, when repeated, is about radius

R (=radius, in geometry) in [QU (=question) + AS (=when) + AS (=when)]; quasars are star-like point sources of radiation outside of our galaxy

     
09 VIOLENCE Crime involving random lone assault, say

*(LONE) in VICE (=crime, i.e. prostitution); “random” is anagram indicator

     
10 DOODLE Simple example of art degree a great many left incomplete

D (=degree) + OODLE<s> (=a great many; “left incomplete” means last letter is dropped)

     
11 LIBERATION Freedom in African country I discounted? Not I, after revolution

LIBER<i>A (=African country; “I discounted” means letter “i” is dropped) + *(NOT I); “after revolution” is anagram indicator

     
12 NOON Twelve notes about rings

O O (=rings, i.e. pictorially) in N N (=notes, i.e. 2 x N = note)

     
13 UNDERSTANDING Seeing lower reputation

UNDER (=lower) + STANDING (=reputation)

     
17 SCRAMBLED EGGS Something for breakfast? Clear off spread, say – good stuff initially following

SCRAM (=clear off, shoo) + BLED (=spread, ran, of liquid) + E.G. (=say, for example) + G<ood> S<tuff> (“initially” means first letters only)

     
19 ONUS British shirking extra responsibility

<b>ONUS (=extra); “British (=B) shirking” means letter “b” is dropped

     
21 REVELATION Stripping, perhaps, is outrageous in elevator

*(IN ELEVATOR); “is outrageous” is anagram indicator; “stripping” is the process of baring, revealing

     
23 AGE-OLD Are Spain occupying first place? Not at present

A (=are, i.e. 100 sq m) + [E (=Spain, in IVR) in GOLD (=first place, in competition)]

     
24 NIT-PICKS Is very critical of return of metal tools?

NIT (TIN=metal; “return of” indicates reversal) + PICKS (=tools)

     
25 VISIONS Food etc not supporting plans

<pro>VISIONS (=food etc; “not supporting (=pro)” means letters “pro” are dropped)

     
26 DOTARD Foolish lover to finish little inspired by Romeo? On the contrary

DO (=to finish, complete) + [R (=Romeo, in radio telecommunications) in TAD (=little, small amount)]

     
Down    
     
02 CRITIQUES Result of appraisals quite out of place in serious situation – is not to be repeated

*(QUIET) in CRIS<is> (=serious situation; “is not to be repeated” means second “is” is dropped); “out of place” is anagram indicator

     
03 CHLOÉ Ballet heroine children adore? Not very

CH (=children) + LO<v>E (=adore; “not very (=V)” means letter “v” is dropped); Daphis et Chloé is a 1912 ballet by Maurice Ravel

     
04 PENTAGRAM Marker to put symbol on sheep – part of occult ritual?

PEN (=marker, for writing with) + TAG (=to put symbol on) + RAM (=sheep)

     
05 QUERIST “Search interrupted by odd bits of rain?” one asks

R<a>I<n> (“odd bits of” means odd letters only) in QUEST (=search)

     
06 AIDAN Irish saint’s name attached to opera

AïDA (=opera, by Verdi) + N (=name); Aidan of Lindisfarne was an Irish monk and missionary credited with converting the Anglo-Saxons to Christianity in Northumberland

     
07 ABOUNDING A limitation in Government? Commonplace

A + BOUND (=limitation, border) + IN + G (=government)

     
08 SALVO Round of applause’s volume in social gathering reduced

V (=volume, in physics) in SALO<n> (=social gathering, of distinguished people; “reduced” means last letter is dropped)

     
14 DERISIONS Insiders upset about ordinary comments from mockers

O (=ordinary) in *(INSIDERS); “upset” is anagram indicator

     
15 NODULATED With swellings, no failure in accommodating most recent

NO + [LATE (=most recent) in DUD (=failure)]

     
16 GAS COOKER Kitchen appliance right to be included among diverse cargoes

OK (=right, alright) in *(CARGOES); “diverse” is anagram indicator

     
18 LIVINGS Mostly angry over Poles securing good gifts of the Church?

LIVI<d> (=angry; “mostly” means last letter is dropped) + {G (=good) in [N (=North) + S (=South) (=Poles)]}; the Church can offer a living or benefice to one providing spiritual care to the inhabitants of an area

     
20 NEGEV Area of Israel Genesis upheld (English version)

NEG (GEN.=Genesis, in the Bible; “upheld” means vertical reversal) + EV (=English Version); the Negev is a desert region in southern Israel

     
21 RODEO Travelled by horse to old American ballet

RODE (=travelled by horse) + O (=old, as in OT); Rodeo is a 1942 ballet, composed by Aaron Copland

     
22 TWIST Tense humour surrounding special plot point

T (=tense, in grammar) + [S (=special) in WIT (=humour)]; a twist is an unexpected development in e.g. the plot of a book

     

 

16 comments on “Independent 11,336 / Phi”

  1. Widdersbel
    Comment #1
    February 10, 2023 at 12:21 pm

    Thanks, Phi & RR. Interesting that you found it towards the harder end of the spectrum, RR – I often struggle to get on Phi’s wavelength but found this one more accessible than usual. Your parsings all look fine to me, though I also wasn’t initially sure about spread=BLED, until I thought of it in the sense of colours bleeding/spreading in the washing machine.

    DOODLE was the one that held me up longest, but one of my favourites once the penny eventually dropped.

    Phi did hint at the existence of a theme in this one in last Friday’s blog, but whatever it is, it eludes me.

  2. Widdersbel
    Comment #2
    February 10, 2023 at 12:24 pm

    Phi’s comment from last week was: “…the ones assigned to Feb 3 and Feb 10 have been swapped. The Feb 3 theme is not affected by appearing just one week later.”

  3. WordPlodder
    Comment #3
    February 10, 2023 at 12:40 pm

    I wasn’t sure of AGE-OLD either; probably my misUNDERSTANDING but I thought it meant very old without implying something only existing in the past, eg an age-old custom which may continue until the present day. I agree with your parsing of SCRAMBLED EGGS and LIVINGS.

    The rest went in OK, even if there were a few odd words such as QUERIST and DERISIONS (in the plural). Favourite was the surface for REVELATION.

    No idea about the theme I’m afraid.

    Thanks to Phi and RR

  4. KVa
    Comment #4
    February 10, 2023 at 1:26 pm

    SCRAMBLED EGGS and LIVINGS:
    I don’t see any issues.
    AGE-OLD:
    Not clear. Not at present!!! 🙂

  5. TFO
    Comment #5
    February 10, 2023 at 1:27 pm

    Thanks both. I had the same uncertainties as mentioned here, and the same habitual ignorance of any theme. I would add NIT-PICKS to the list, which I view as being mildly and perhaps inconsequentially rather than very critical, but I am probably just nit-picking

  6. redddevil
    Comment #6
    February 10, 2023 at 4:18 pm

    My only query was for late=most recent.
    Surely latest=most recent whilst late is just recent/recently?
    No idea on theme but that’s par for the course with Phi.
    Thanks to Phi and RR

  7. Simon S
    Comment #7
    February 10, 2023 at 4:42 pm

    rd @ 6 I think a phrase like “The late queen” refers to the most recent one.

  8. redddevil
    Comment #8
    February 10, 2023 at 5:13 pm

    Simon S @7 well it would have to refer to the most recent one in that case as there aren’t that many Queens to choose from.

    I’d have thought late in that sense just meant recently deceased..

  9. Stephen L.
    Comment #9
    February 10, 2023 at 5:42 pm

    I thought this not quite as challenging as this setter can be but as enjoyable as ever.
    I parsed AGE-OLD slightly differently in that I missed the Are=A abbreviation and just took it as a cryptic question of Spain (E) occupying A Gold (first place).
    My favourite today was DOODLE.
    Many thanks to Phi and RR

    On the “late/most recent debate” it can probably be justified in the sense of “late or breaking news”.

  10. allan_c
    Comment #10
    February 10, 2023 at 5:50 pm

    Enjoyable, with enough of a challenge to keep us on our toes. QUASARS, CRITIQUES and QUERIST were our favourites, with an honourable mention for SCRAMBLED EGGS. We couldn’t fully parse DOTARD, though. No idea as to the theme.
    Thanks, Phi and RR.

  11. redddevil
    Comment #11
    February 10, 2023 at 6:32 pm

    Stephen L @9 …though the phrase “some late news just in” still only suggests a meaning of recent rather than most recent…

    That said on checking Chambers it does list “most recent” albeit at meaning 11 but I’m still to hear a phrase where they FEEL interchangeable.

    TYAG

  12. Jimboeb
    Comment #12
    February 10, 2023 at 7:17 pm

    Nit-Picking took me the longest, as I agree with the comment that it doesn’t immediately suggest to me ‘very critical’, rather something less severe. The two slightly unusual plurals needed double checking before entering too. Surprised that some found it hard as it felt like the easiest of the week to me, but hey-ho.

  13. Phi
    Comment #13
    February 10, 2023 at 7:53 pm

    Don’t want you losing your Hair over this one. I’ve been putting zodiac-related puzzles up as first of the month for ten months now, and this is the first (but not the last…) switch to week two. The theme words are probably the longest set I’ve ever included, and AQUARIUS itself got rather jumbled up near the top. Sorry for taking an age to get round to it, but note the last words of these lines:

    Harmony and understanding
    Sympathy and trust abounding
    No more falsehoods or derisions
    Golden living dreams of visions
    Mystic crystal revalation
    And the mind’s true liberation

    I wanted to clue SCRAMBLED EGGS with a reference to ‘Yesterday’ as it was McCartney’s working title until he came up with a lyric. But I thought it not well enough known.

  14. FrankieG
    Comment #14
    February 10, 2023 at 8:28 pm

    Nice puzzle, the theme only Googlable by entering the two least common words from your list: ABOUNDING and DERISIONS.
    Most were words I’d discounted, sure it had to be about Chloe or Aidan Livings, or Trump the dotard, or the Mock Turtle’s Ambition, Distraction, Uglification, and Derision.
    Thanks Phi & RatkojaRiku

  15. Bertandjoyce
    Comment #15
    February 11, 2023 at 2:00 am

    Thanks for the explanation Phi. As soon as Bert saw the lyrics, he realised the significance. We were only talking about Hair recently and what a stir it caused when it was first staged. The conversation started when Aquarius came on the radio.

    Thanks RR for the blog.

  16. h.eckler
    Comment #16
    February 11, 2023 at 12:20 pm

    Terrific, Phi, your post: As much fun reading it as solving the puzzle itself. Thanks

Comments are closed.