Guardian 24077/Rover – whimsical

Solving time: 30’

Quite a few whimsical and cryptic allusions. I didn’t really enjoy this puzzle but probably because I’m a bit burnt out having just done The Times as well (“it’s not you, it’s me!”). I found myself being lazy on decoding all the wordplay – we’ll see if I manage while writing this up. Upon rereading, there are some good clues here – so it really is me after all.

Across

1 SADDLE,RY – I assume that a “groom’s gear” can be described as SADDLERY.
5 S(CR)EEN – CR must be an acceptable abbrev of “crown”.
9 UN,STEADY – Dicky isn’t a name (certainly not French!), just the definition: UN is “a [in] French”.
10 A,RREST=”rest” – a “spider” is a Brit for a snooker “rest” or bridge (wordplay decoded as we speak).
12 EARTHENWARE – (near the Wear)* — I wonder if this is an &lit: are “clay pots” produced in particular near the River Wear?
15 FLATS – two definitions: both of which seem cryptic. The second (“not natural”) must refer to stage scenery. No, Barbara notes below that it’s musical: ref. sharps and FLATS.
17 SPECTACLE[s] – double/cryptic def: spectacles come in pairs usually thus “Well, one of them!” to cryptically make singular – likewise, “A sight for sore eyes?” defines a singular SPECTACLE.
18 LIGHTSHIP – cryptic def of what is the marine equivalent of a lighthouse (thus “offshore” and “heavy weather”).
20 SHOPLIFTING – groan: cryptic def: “Is a crane needed for this theft?”
24 LARKIN[g] – Ref. Philip LARKIN the poet – almost invariably when a dropped “g” is encountered in a clue it indicates a dropped “g” in the wordplay (here, “foolin[g]” around and LARKIN[g] around).
25 BACTRIAN – not sure if this isn’t just a straight definition: because a BACTRIAN camel is in fact from Afghanistan and has (two) humps (yes, a BACTRIAN also describes part of Afghanistan). Anything else going on?
26 BOARDS – elegant double definition: “Stage directors”.

Down

1 SAUCERFULS – “Cats love these results of unexpectedly severe storms”. The definition is clear (what cats love) but what about the wordplay? Noted below that it’s ref. “a storm in a teacup” which must overflow and fill the saucer.
2 DIS(ARRAN)GE – ARRAN (our Scottish island) in (Gide’s)*. Nice clue since the definition “reorganise” is almost always an anagrind. Too bad Andre Gide didn’t write about Scotland…
3 LEE,CH – Ref. Laurie LEE the writer. I’m betting that once upon a time, when leeching was considered a good thing medically, doctors were referred to as leeches (?).
4 RIDING SCHOOL – nice clue: “get on up” refers to mounting a horse to go RIDING. And of course ref. West and East RIDING in Yorkshire.
6 CARPENTER – Ref. The (worst group ever in the history of pop music) CARPENTERs and what a CARPENTER does: namely, joining furniture.
11 CATERPILLARS – can be interpreted as a clever &lit: CATERPILLARS don’t do your vegetables (“greens”) much good nor do the Greens like them much (since they tear up the landscape).
14 NEWSAGENTS – cryptic def for which I would have expected some acknowledgement by the setter (e.g. a question-mark): the surface “rag trade” misleads towards the garment industry.
21 FAT,SO – “Podge: very good word for obese fellow”. Def is “obese fellow”. I think the wordplay is FAT for “podge” and SO for “very good word”, i.e. a word that is used to indicate superior quality (as in, “this clue is SO clever”).

6 comments on “Guardian 24077/Rover – whimsical”

  1. re: 1D Is the reference to ‘storm in a teacup’? ie. An unexpectedly severe storm would fill a saucer????

    Jon

  2. 15. Flats. This is a double def. The second one is flats as musical notes,as opposed to sharps or naturals.

  3. Thanks for the explanation of flats, Barbara. It was one of too many clues that I got, but couldn’t quite explain. Saucerfuls was another, and I hope there’s a better explanation than the ‘storm in a teacup’ one (no offence, Jon!)
    As for Bactrian, I agree that it seems to be a straight def.

  4. Actually I rather like the overflowing saucerful explanation… unless there are better offers I’m going to canonize it.

  5. I think for 21d, the definition is “good word for obese fellow” and SO is indicated simply by “very”.

    I could swear that ” raining saucerfuls” is a slang expression akin to “raining cats and dogs” but I can’t for the life of me find any verification of this online.

  6. Not very cryptic in terms of word split though. In Chambers PODGE has two meanings, one a name for a fat person (and therefore a synonym for FATSO) or thing, and the other a noun for excess body fat – i.e. what makes a fatso fat.

    Rover apears to be going with the former, and with SO defined (in one Chambers entry) as ‘very good’, the clue almost seems to say FATSO + SO = FATSO.

Comments are closed.