Enigmatic Variations No. 1169: Sentiment by Stick Insect

There have been some fun puzzles from Stick Insect over the last few years, including his recent Listener puzzle, Reductio Ad Absurdum.

I was surprised that this solve started off quickly and continued apace with little time for tea or alcohol. Less than an hour after starting, I was faced with a completed grid, save the two unclued entries in the top and bottom rows. As it turned out, we were pretty much spoon-fed what we had to do. Firstly, the two entries were the same. Secondly, they created new words for the crossing down entries, new first letters being required in the northeast corner and new last letters in the southwest.

EV 1169What we weren’t told was that we needed more than one word for the entry. After toying with …WOLD for some time, I GROW OLD finally made itself known after only a few minutes. Unfortunately, this meant nothing to me, and I needed Google to find that it was a line from a TS Eliot poem, The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock:

I grow old … I grow old …
I shall wear the bottoms of my trousers rolled.

Finally, we were required to draw a line through the title character in a symmetrical and relevant shape, and J ALFRED PRUFROCK was there for the asking, starting in the main NW–SE diagonal and finishing in a circular group of cells towards the southeast. (Unfortunately, the preamble states that the line goes through fourteen cells, but it is, in fact, fifteen. A rare mistake these days.)

So that was that. Except that I couldn’t really see in what way the shape was relevant. It certainly didn’t look like one leg of a pair of trousers rolled up! I read the poem all the way through, hoping for a revelation, but nothing seemed obvious. Part of me thought that it looked a bit like a balloon drooping downwards after losing a lot of air.

I put the puzzle down for a day or so and when I returned, I read the poem again. This time, not quite half way through, I read “I have measured out my life with coffee spoons;” and that seemed to be the answer. However, I wasn’t 100% convinced, and read the poem through to the end again. When creating the diagram for this blog, the shape is, indeed, like a coffee spoon, but I feel the link is somewhat tenuous.

I have some unfinished business for the first time in many, many months, and that is in the clue to MAOISM at 45ac: An ideology in Iceland embraced by middle America and old money (6). Iceland is IS, old money is O and M, but I don’t think that MA is an abbreviation for Middle America. Of course, the answer could be TAOISM, but then I’d be really stumped!

Anyway, thanks to Stick Insect for a neat, straightforward puzzle. Even just dipping my toes into the literary notes for the poem made me realise what a complex piece of work it is. Mind you, I can totally relate to the thoughts behind the two lines quoted above!

Legend:
Definition in clue
ANSWER becomes ENTRY with unclued
ABC* = anagram
ABC< = reversal
abCDef = hidden

ACROSS
No Entry Clue and Explanation
1 ARRAS Tapestry at heart undergoes R&B rearrangement for Asian track producers? (5)
ARBAS (tapestry) has central B replaced by R
5 I GROW OLD Unclued
11 UNCLAD Uncovered pawnbroker’s unending promotion (6)
UNCL[E] (pawnbroker, without end) + AD (promotion)
12 ARD-RI Head king, Queen and Empress on a road (5)
RI (Queen and Empress, abbreviation) on (just after) A RD (road)
13 MOJO Jack’s captured by low charm of New Orleans (4)
J (Jack) in MOO (low)
14 ELISION Eastern hero seizes internal security in suppression (7)
E (eastern) LION (hero) containing IS (internal security)
15 OTTAWA Unfinished row about power unit reversed new name for Bytown (6)
OA[R] (row, unfinished) about WATT< (power unit); little wonder they changed the name!
17 PITURI I trip badly over university shrub (6)
(I TRIP)* over (across) U (university)
18 PLAYA Trifle with a hollow that’s sometimes a lake (5)
PLAY (trifle) + A
23 ROOT Grub’s basis for Jonathan’s support (4)
3 meanings; Jonathan is a word for Americans
25 FERRETER Judge overturned network rule for tireless searcher (8)
REF< (judge, overturned) + RETE (network) + R (rule)
27 DUMOSE Oddly, dour moors get bushy sometimes (6)
odd letters of DoUr MoOrS gEt
28 CURTSY Short Sally’s lacking every indication of respect (6)
CURT (short) + SALLY – ALL (every)
30 ANAPHASE A downy surface is characterized by base stage in cell division (8)
A NAP (downy surface) + HAS (is characterized by) E (base)
32 CHAD Some French adored African language (4)
in frenCH ADored
36 RIDER A mini imposter with this proposition could produce a priori determinism (5)
compound anagram: (A MINI IMPOSTER + RIDER)* = (A PRIORI DETERMINISM)*; the longest compound anagram I’ve come across… but not for long!
38 NORMAL Ordinary and not married, lecturer’s after adult (6)
NOR (and not) M (married) + L (lecturer) after A (adult)
40 PRORES Ships in odes for resolution (6)
PRO (for) RES (resolution)
42 WEEPIER More tearful, we’re upset about confusion (7)
WE’RE* about PIE (confusion)
43 UFOS Saucers, maybe, in overturned sets of utensils (4)
reversed in setS OF Utensils
44 LLAMA Cloth obtained from a shopping area to the west (5)
(A MALL (shopping area))<
45 MAOISM An ideology in Iceland embraced by middle America and old money (6)
IS (Iceland) in MA (middle America??) O (old) M (money)
46 I GROW OLD Unclued
47 ATOLL Island of coral and aluminium embraces reversal of fortune (5)
AL (Aluminium) about LOT< (fortune, reversed)
DOWN
No Entry Clue and Explanation
1 ARMOUR Royal Marines in active period of service having no time for heraldic insignia (6)
RM (Royal Marines) in A (active) TOUR (service period) – T (time)
2 ROOTBOUND Spooner’s kick about is lacking room for growth (9)
as Spooner might say BOOT ROUND (kick about)
3 AMOA Animal certainly not found in Australian acreage (4)
NO (certainly not) in A (Australian) A (acreage)
4 SCOWLS Initially, Simon Cowell’s lost most of a high note and looks threatening (6)
S (Simon, initially) + COWELL’S – E-L[A] (high note, mostly)
5 LEA
becomes
ILEA
Periodically, Polynesia is fallow (3)
periodically in poLynEsiA
6 ALLY
becomes
GALLY
Radical deserted by left supporter (4)
ALLYL (radical) – L (left)
7 AS IS
becomes
OASIS
Athletic little sibling is unaltered (4, two words)
A (Athletic) + SIS (little sibling, sister)
8 RIT
becomes
WRIT
Scots score liturgy with no end of trouble (3)
RITE (liturgy) – E (end of troublE)
9 DOUR
becomes
ODOUR
Dog fur missing in the middle is grim (4)
DO[G F]UR
10 ICIER
becomes
DICIER
Colder and cloudy – that is right on island (5)
C (cloudy) IE (that is) R (right) on I island)
16 TOOM To a greater extent than desirable, money is Scotsman’s tip (4)
TOO (too a greater extent than desirable) + M (money)
19 AFEAR One iron army regulation is scare for Edmund (5)
A (one) FE (iron) AR (army regulation)
20 ARCED Formed a curve and drove radius from first to second place (5)
RACED (drove) with R moved to second place
21 MERC Hired soldier briefly held by Khmer company (4)
in khMER Company
22 SESAME OIL Country containing hint of eucalyptus and identical Asian plant product (9, two words)
SOIL (country) containing E (hint of Eucalyptus) SAME (identical)
24 TOPI Island supporting the very best thing for antelope (4)
I (island) supporting, ie under) TOP (very best thing)
26 ERS Second note about special plant (3)
RE (second note)< + S (special)
29 THOR God with organ abandoned by divided northern town (4)
WITH ORGAN – WIGAN (northern town divided in two, ie WI and GAN)
30 ANNUL
becomes
ANNULI
Abolish California poppy say that’s lost second American (5)
ANNUAL (eg Californian poppy) – second A (American)
31 KERRIA King and queen with affectation of superiority over yellow shrub (6)
K (king) ER (Queen) + AIR< (affectation of superiority)
33 DOSSAL Feasts with Salvation Army lead to laundering altar cloth (6)
DOS (feasts, plural of DO) + SA (Salvation Army) + L (first letter of Laundering)
34 AREA
becomes
AREAR
Region within Near East (4)
in neAR EAst
35 PAPA
becomes
PAPAW
Pascal’s personal assistant was pope (4)
PA (pascal) PA (personal assistant)
37 IDEA
becomes
IDEAL
Archetype of manifold varieties can make a form every chief Platonist expressed with this (4)
compound anagram (A FORM EVERY CHIEF PLATONIST + IDEA)* = (ARCHETYPE OF MANIFOLD VARIETIES)* &lit.; a new record for the longest compound anagram I’ve come across
39 MEM
becomes
MEMO
Letter thirteen? Twice! (3)
M + EM (ie 13th letter twice)
40 PRO
becomes
PROD
For parking, take centre of A-road (3)
P (parking) + R (take) O (centre of a-rOad)
41 OUST Expel Judge from contest (4)
JOUST (contest) – J (judge)

 

1 comment on “Enigmatic Variations No. 1169: <em>Sentiment</em> by Stick Insect”

  1. Thanks to Dave for the review. Apologies to all solvers for the two blunders – it should indeed have been 15 cells not 14 and I also seem to have imagined M as an abbreviation for middle in 45 across. No excuse – I know how irritating it is as a solver to know the answer but not be able to see how it works so I’m very sorry for any time wasted trying to puzzle out something that’s just plain wrong.

Comments are closed.