Inquisitor 1414: Breakthrough by Schadenfreude

Another Schadenfreude offering this week. Usually quite difficult and this was no exception, not helped by slightly misleading (to me, Hi, anyway) rubric, which read:

After filling the grid, solvers must obey the following instruction, completed by single missing letters from the wordplay yielded by 13 clues (read in the grid left to right, top to bottom): “ALTER NINE CELLS TO….”. Numbers in brackets give the lengths of final grid entries, all words or proper names, including one film title.

It was implied, by the fact that “lengths of final grid entries” were given, that there would be changes to the lengths of certain answers. There actually were gaps in the grid after all the clues were solved, so the phrase “After filling the grid” was the one which misled me. I spent time desperately searching for definitions that simply weren’t there. (e.g. I searched for a definition of ADIEU in 12A before realising that it clued ADIE, and as for 6D, only two of 10 letters clued!)

Anyway, all seemed to be going well when I solved 1A on a first reading, and I solved most of the LH half of the grid quite quickly. After an overnight break I eventually got a start on the right hand side with ALICE and LAMA and after much gnashing of teeth realised that almost all of 6D was to be left empty, and the clue simply referred to the first and last letters.

By this point I had found 13 extra letters and in grid order they read REVEALTERSINA, which didn’t help a lot, though the word “reveal” was clear enough. Finding words to fit into the answers with blanks (all had to be proper words) led me (via ADIEU, OCREATE and NON-COME – the only possible words to fill those slots) to 6D being EU?O???N?L , hence EUROTUNNEL. Now in the past Eurotunnel puzzles, of which there have been quite a few in various magazines and papers, have always involved the termini, often CHERITON or FOLKESTONE and CALAIS. I therefore tried to find my mistakes in the extra letters, as TERSINA could read TERMINI if I corrected two wrong answers or interpretations. First 34A was not SANS (for Sanscrit – foreign characters) but SINS – I’m not up on my Hebrew characters, and this was listed under SIN(4) = SHIN in Chambers. Second the extra S I had in 21D CISCOS was explainable with the full wordplay and the only M was in 29A where I had a question mark as I hadn’t understood the wordplay anyway – knowing there was an extra M helped a lot. The instruction was therefore ALTER NINE CELLS TO REVEAL TERMINI. I have indicated the letters without wordplay in yellow in the grid below.

Once these were sorted out, I looked for places (obviously overlapping the first and last letters of EUROTUNNEL) to alter. CALAIS could appear with three alterations at the bottom and FOLKESTONE with six alterations at the top – a total of nine cells as required. I’ve shown these in turquoise the diagram below. The new words formed are INFO, KES (the film title) and TONES across the top, LIPA, KEEN, SLICE and TABRET down from the top. Then ALA across the bottom, ARETA (proper name) TOSA and ANTI down to the bottom.

Finally I thought I should check on the title and sure enough the tunnel Breakthrough took place on the 1st of December 1990 – 25 years ago on the Tuesday after publication.

Nice puzzle but not one of Schadenfreude’s best. Some indication in the rubric of the need to leave blanks in the grid would have helped – e.g. “after completing the grid, blank cells should be filled appropriately”.

Ho enjoyed it more and had a higher opinion of it than Hi. It will be interesting to read your views in the comments.

Inq1414 anim

 

Across

 No.  Clue (definition)  Answer  Wordplay  
 1  Small container popular with retired men (4)  INRO  IN (popular) + O(ther) R(anks) (men) reversed
 5  Terrorist militia’s – penetrated by English marine (3)  SEA  SA (Nazi militia) round E(nglish)
 8  Prescribed routes left by retreating Indian army (5)  LANES  L(eft) + SENA (Indian army) reversed
 12  TV reporter about to stop working (5)  ADIE  Kate Adie: A(bout) + DIE (stop working)
 13  Attack by anonymous monk (4)  LAMA  LAM (attack) + A(nonymous)
 14  Kind American priest entering forgotten path (7)  STRIPE  P(riest) in STIE (obsolete form of sty – a path or ladder). The R is unclued  R
 15  Farewell Elizabeth – no longer a time for drinking (5)  BEVER  BV (Bene vale – farewell) + ER (Elizabeth). The first E is unclued  E
 16  Regularly Noah disowns one from Columbus (6)  OHIOAN  Columbus Ohio: Alternate letters in NOaH dIsOwNs. The A is unclued  A
 17  Institute worried by gang short of whiskey (7)  CREATE  CRE(W) (gang minus W(hiskey)) + ATE (worried)
 18  Australian uncle suffering with afternoon  depressions (8)  LACUNAE  [A(ustralian) UNCLE A(fternoon)]*
 23  Virginia’s descendants pursuing active battles (8)  ACTIONS  A(ctive) + CIONS (US spelling of scions – descendants). The T is unclued  T
 24  Time to bury a colourist (7)  TINTER  T(ime) + INTER (bury)
 26  Piece of armour with large silver plate (6)  TASSEL  TASSE (piece of armour) + L(arge)
 28  Inclusive note inserted in spaces (5)  INCUT  INC(lusive) + UT (note)
 29  Sudden attack at Perth formerly stopped by head of ordnance (7)  ONCOME  ONCE (formerly) with O(rdinance) inserted. The M is unclued  M
 30  Acting junior army officer got off his horse (4)  ALIT  A(cting) + LT (junior officer). The I is unclued  I
 31  Poet has time for catholic mute (5)  STOP  SCOP (poet) with T(ime) replacing C(atholic)
 32  Some wordage I challenged relating to DNA sequences (5)  GENIC  Hidden in wordaGE I Challenged. The N is unclued  N
 33  Baron leaves district for some doll? (3)  ELT  The definition refers to a young sow (elt) which might also be the doll (smallest or pet pig): BELT (district) minus B(aron)
 34  Foreign characters new on board (4)  SINS  Sins = shins, Hebrew characters: N(ew) in SS (on board). The I is unclued  I

Down

 No.  Clue (definition)  Answer  Wordplay  
 1  Exposing to the sun is not good in athletic ground (10)  INSOLATING  [IS NOT G(ood) IN A(thletic)]*. The L is unclued  L
 2  Prophet born in this year before November (6)  NATHAN  NAT (born) + H(oc) A(nno) (in this year) + N(ovember)
 3  Offensive party raised promissory notes (6)  ODIOUS  DO (party) reversed + IOUS (promissory notes)
 4  Norse beer drink (4)  NIPA  N(orse) + IPA (India Pale Ale)
 5  Considered situation for the auditor (4)  SEEN  Sounds like SCENE (situation)
 6  The Spanish part of a building in Los Angeles (10)  EL  Double definition, the Spanish and a wing of an L-shaped building in the US
 7  Eponymous heroine caught in a story (5)  ALICE  C(aught) in A LIE (story)
 8  Rector invested in embroidered table ornament (6)  LABRET  [R(ector) + TABLE]*
9 Academician probing assurgent old Chinese language (6)  NAVAHO  A(cademician) in O(ld) HAN (Chinese) reversed (assurgent = rising). The V is unclued  V
10  Aged reptile close to snake on overturned box (4)  EVET  (snak)E + TV (box) reversed. The second E is unclued  E
 11  Switch by Liberal during session lacking emphasis (10)  STRESSLESS  TRESS (switch) + L(iberal) in SESS(ion)
 12  John is able to dance (6)  CANCAN  CAN (John = loo in US) + CAN (is able)
 20  Intellectual I see supporting rampant people of fashion (6)  NOETIC  I + C (see) under TON (people of fashion) reversed. The E is unclued  E
 21  Fish caught by seaman going round island cape (6)  CISCOS  C(aught) + OS (Ordinary Seaman) round IS(land) C(ape)
 22  Forward raised handle for a single person (6)  ONE-MAN  ON (forward) + NAME (handle) reversed
 23  European leaves climbing rocky edge (5)  ARETE  E(uropean) + TEA (leaves) reversed. The R is unclued  R
 25  Pessimistic theologian that’s no good at heart (4)  INGE  Dean Inge: IE (that’s) round NG (no good)
 26  Rarely agitated child, about seven (4)  TOST  Rare form of tossed: TOT (child) round S (seven – medieval Roman numeral)
 27  Soldier joining advanced column (4)  ANTA  ANT (soldier) + A(dvanced)

 

 

 

14 comments on “Inquisitor 1414: Breakthrough by Schadenfreude”

  1. I found this, in terms of clues at least, to be at the easier end of the Schadenfreude spectrum, but no less enjoyable for that. I also thought that leaving most of a column blank without mentioning it was a lovely touch that added to the enjoyment of puzzling out the end game (although realising that 6D was just EL took me a lot longer than it should have). Finally, keeping a submerged tunnel in the grid and revealing the termini was the final PDM in a puzzle that entertained me from start to finish.

    Lovely stuff.

    Thanks to setter and blogger.

  2. I’m with Hi. I completed most of the first 4 columns relatively quickly but then ground to a halt attempting to fit answers across the middle. I’m not advanced enough a solver to realise that there might be gaps involved and need more precise instructions! I battled with 24a for ages having TINTE?? and guessed that ADIE might be the TV reporter. On the right hand side I incorrectly entered DOAN at 13a and then got no further.

    Thanks to blogger and setter.

  3. Fine puzzle, but I was also in two minds about whether or not to fill in the cells between the E and the L … after all, no definitions or wordplay had been mentioned, and that part of the tunnel is indeed invisible under both SEA and sea bed. What prompted me to send entry in with FILLED cells, was indeed the preamble starting “AFTER FILLING THE GRID”. Otherwise it would only have been partly filled.

    I remember being foxed by a previous Schadenfreude IQ preamble, and wrongly highlighting SUB instead of a diagonal TORPEDO !

  4. I must say that I had no real difficulty with this puzzle, and found it remarkably easy for a Schadenfreude. I got 24a TINTER straight away & thought TINTERN, then 10a LACUNA & thought LACUNATE. Having solved EL at 6d, entering 12a ADIEE quickly led me to EUROTUNNEL, with a fair amount of the right-hand side still to go.

    Reading the missing letters in clue order made no sense (obviously, and rather stupid), but finding the instruction in the grid helped with the last couple of clues (34a SINS was the final one I think).

    Thanks for the blog – and for alerting us to the anniversary (which is something I often fail to notice of late: it seems we all overlooked the anniversary of Mae West’s death in the previous puzzle). Good fun though – was the appearance of SEA LANES in the top row coincidental?

  5. That should of course have read “12a ADIEU“. (My excuse is that ‘Preview comment’ no longer works on my desktop PC, and so little errors can – & do – creep in.)

  6. I enjoyed this and liked the tunnel down the middle. No need to spell it out in the instructions, one could spell it out for oneself in the grid.

    The instructions say the grid must be filled, it does not tell you how you have to do it. You have to figure that out for yourself.

    I thought the clues were bloody hard. I would not have finished the SE corner at all without the extra help from predicting CALAIS and EUROTUNNEL.

    Thanks Schadenfrude, super puzzle.

  7. Well I suppose that simply failing to properly interpret the now quite clear instruction about how to read the missing letters from the wordplay has to go down as a particularly stupid error. If I had identified all 13 of the missing letters correctly (Liker Hi I had two wrong, the A in SANS was one of them) I could have got it from the anagram of the thirteen letters. As it was I never did get the final instruction about which 9 cells to alter which made for a particularly frustrating end to my efforts. The shorter solutions in the across clues to provide the space for EUROTUNNEL however came relatively easily.

  8. This was my first attempt at an Inquisitor (for which I have to thank Gaufrid). I confess to failing to understand the instructions and was left with many more than 13 missing letters after inserting Eurotunnel (nothing else would fit). I worked out what then needed to be done without ever completing the instructions, but I got 34 wrong, so just as well that I didn’t submit my entry. It’s all good learning for me and I found the blog, particularly the animated grid, really helpful.

  9. We enjoyed the puzzle. For some reason or other which neither of us can remember, we had REVEAL EROINA at some point and were looking at it being EURO something or other – using a U perhaps in 23ac. Once we had parsed some of the answers more clearly we realised our early mistake but this may have helped us in identifying EUROTUNNEL more quickly.

    Thanks Hihoba – excellent blog as always and Schadenfreude for a great puzzle.

  10. I enjoyed this without being enthralled by it. For a while I was looking for something like a rat in a drainpipe, having guessed at ‘reveal vermin’ (and seemingly having lost my ability to count), but got to the final answer eventually, albeit slowly.

    I’ve been scratching my head over the film title, but have just noticed KES in the grid above (and have also now noticed that Hi has already hilighted this) – the writing on my own grid is none too clear. And thanks to Murray Glover @3 for pointing out that the Eurotunnel goes under the SEA – surely not coincidental.

  11. Like HG@4 I got off to a flyer- I guessed TINTER(N), (O)CREATE and LACUNA(T)E so EUROTUNNEL followed quickly. However, like PeeDee@6 I struggled with the SE corner for a while before getting ONCOME. And I had to talk myself through the instruction to read the missing letters top to bottom left to right !

    And ah….KES, brought back memories, esp. of Colin Welland who sadly passed away recently.

    I thought this was a nice ‘construction’ so many thanks to Schadenfreude and Hihoba.

  12. No complaints here — I always enjoy the warm glow of smugness at finishing a Schadenfreude puzzle (albeit not one of this setter’s toughest). It seemed clear from early on that there would be blank spaces, and the tempting symmetry of having them all in the same column happily turned out to be the right guess.

    My personal red herring was the suspicion that we were being asked to REVEAL HEROINE. A wide wide field of fruitless speculation …

  13. I thought this was pretty straightforward, especially for Schadenfreude. I found many of the clues quite easy, so my grid filled quickly, though identifying the unclued letter in some of the more tricky wordplay slowed me down. I couldn’t see anything wrong with the preamble. It was pretty obvious from the last sentence that some answers were not the same length as entries, and a couple of examples soon suggested where an addition might be made to form a new word. I appreciate that this might not be so obvious to someone only just starting to tackle IQ.

    Since the preamble said that numbers in brackets give lengths of final grid entries it’s pretty clear that UROTUNNE should not be submerged.

    All in all, I’d say it’s a very well-balanced puzzle, and certainly very enjoyable.

Comments are closed.