Inquisitor 1728: Face Trouble by Ifor

Ifor, and a rather asymmetrical grid.
 
Preamble: The clue to one entry in each row and each column contains an extra word. Each is primarily associated with a single letter from a complete set to be deduced; in row then column order (as clues are presented, for the convenience of solvers) these letters form a six-word sentence, to be written under the grid. Solvers must highlight 36 letters in six groups that spell out synonyms of each of its words. Constructions used in three clues may be verified online.

Each of the 13 rows & 13 columns lead to a single letter from a complete set; that’s 26 letters. Hmm, I wonder what set that could be.

I started this puzzle on Monday afternoon sitting in the local community hospital waiting for a wounded elbow to be cleaned up, X-rayed, and dressed. That took about 3½ hours during which time I’d looked through all the across clues and about half the downs – I felt I’d made reasonable progress, and thought that the clues were excellent & wonderfully crafted; every word pulling its weight.

After a couple more sessions over the next few days the grid was full and it was time to make a start on the “associated letters”. I didn’t do myself any favours with an initial scatter-gun approach but soon became more disciplined. Quite a few of the extra words led to a range of letters from which to choose: P– or QCeltic, S-, U-, or Zbend, I– or Jbeam, for example. But I was pretty confident that 36d led to Q sort and saw that 12d could give Z list, and I leapt onto QUIZ being the last word in the six-word sentence.

GLYPHS seemed to be emerging as the fourth word, followed by a hesitant VEXT – but that is indeed in Chambers as an obsolete version of “vexed”. Google duly resolved the remaining words, and I wrote CWM FJORD BANK GLYPHS VEXT QUIZ under the grid. But what about the six synonyms to be found in the grid?

I saw BANTER near the bottom, and above that was HARASS and then FLUTES; as I worked my way to the top all 6 appeared in the even rows and all 6 checked out in Chambers. I was delayed for some time with explaining the title – they’re invariably meaningful with Ifor. Musing in bed one morning I checked Chambers for PAN, and sure enough there is “face”; onto GRAM and under the third headword there’s “trouble”. Job done.

I don’t know – you wait for years for a pangram to arrive then two come along within the space of a fortnight. Thanks Ifor, a wonderful set of clues as I said earlier; so, a great journey, but somehow it felt a little flat towards the end – probably my fault.

Thanks also to fellow bloggers Kenmac and Duncan for helping with the parsing of 1a AVOGADRO & 40d LAR. And I think that the three constructions that may be verified online are F word, K ration, and R value.
Added later: not F word but S bend – see TonyG @6.
 

No. Clue [extra] α extra Answer Wordplay
Across
1 Scientist lived years ago, reflecting beginning that’s disappeared over [horizon] (8) C horizon AVOGADRO AV (lived years) AGO< ORD< (beginning, obs)
9 Previous guess at instrument (4)   HARP double definition
13 Craftily feign a left in swindle (7)   FINAGLE [FEIGN A L(eft)]*
14 [Particle] returned without limits, sadly neither one thing nor the other (6) W particle NEUTER [(r)ETURNE(d)]*
15 Live reforms on which one [theory] might be impoverished (8) M theory BEAM-ENDS BE (live) AMENDS (reforms)
16 Fish in Pacific, turning this over (4)   COHO HOC< (this) O(ver)
19 Café‚ delivered [word], keeping core of menu back (5) F word DINER RID (delivered) around (m)EN(u) all<
20 United [pen] supporter after result in due course (10) J pen EVENTUALLY U(nited) ALLY (supporter) after EVENT (result)
21 Broken alarm possessing quiet [ring] put in order (7) O ring MARSHAL [ALARM]* around SH (quiet)
24 Unusual vegetable, best without sun (4)   WORT WORST (best) ¬ S(un)
26 Adding shades of depression uncovered soul increasing [value] (11) R value COLOURISING COL (depression) (s)OU(l) RISING (increasing)
28 [Mark] two pages willingly, as reported (4) D mark LEAF homophone: LIEF (willingly)
29 Maybe lemon stops endless smell? (9)   LUTESCENT (f)LUTE(s) (stops) SCENT (smell)
33 Some discount offered until [movie] finished (4) B movie UNTO (disco)UNT O(ffered)
35 Growth of rust in US uranium immured, leaving one mark red (7)   UREDIUM [U(ranium) IMMURED ¬ M(ark)]*
{red=put in order}
37 Small coaches, cleaner than local [line] (6) A line CHARAS CHAR (cleaner) AS (than, dialect)
39 Comparison ignoring pressure devoted to crops (6)   ARABLE PARABLE (comparison) ¬ P(ressure)
41 Polishes of recognised [type] covering hot opening of stove (6) N type SHEENS SEEN (recognised) around H(ot) S(tove)
42 Headgear originally trendy in town (6)   TURBAN T(rendy) URBAN (in town)
43 Bank that’s raised [ration] shut up to cover mistake (7) K ration TERRACE TACE (shut up) around ERR (mistake)
44 Club supporters [spot] revolutionary ideas regularly (7) G spot BRASSIE BRAS (supporters) [I(d)E(a)S]*
Down
17 Half-moon-shaped bent metal [plate] in use (10) L plate SEMILUNATE [METAL IN USE]*
2 Lost challenge with opportunity of looking [level] (4) Y level VIEW VIE (challenge, obs) W(ith)
26 End of panic with hospital department on top of unusual bit of bone (7)   CENTRUM (pani)C ENT (hospital department) RUM (unusual)
3 Siege engine aiming without one minute taken by single uninterrupted operation (6)   ONAGER AIMING ¬ I+MIN (one minute) in ONER (single uninterrupted operation)
27 [Celtic] pipe that’s the right way up (3) P Celtic OAT TAO< (the right way)
37 Swimmers make trivial complaint (4)   CARP double definition
4 School [hour] happens around noon for street urchins (6) H hour GAMINS GAM (school) IS (happens) around N(oon)
5 Acting at hiding inside information (5)   AGENT AT around GEN (inside information)
22 Stop [bend] outside lines – pay attention! (5) S bend HOLLA HOA (stop) around LL (lines)
40 Household god left without place in lodgings (3)   LAR LARBOARD (left) ¬ BOARD (place in lodgings)
18 Party in Honolulu – could be usual shivering if sun goes in (4)   LUAU [USUAL ¬ S(un)]*
34 [Sign] near a ground (Wembley, say) (5) V sign ARENA [NEAR A]*
6 [Business] leader organised another set of hands (6) E business REDEAL [LEADER]*
30 Swagger around area, climbing trees (6)   TUARTS STRUT (swagger) around A all<
7 Former [generation] of locals housed in constituency (4) X generation ONST (c)ONST(ituency)
23 Remainers condemned leisure after leaving EU in stages (5)   LIERS [LEISURE ¬ EU]*
8 Add square, lose [square] – foolishly pointless endeavour (8, 2 words) T square DEAD LOSS [ADD S(quare) LOSE]*
38 Respectable male, bright pink after member’s cut off (4)   SHRI SHRIMP (bright pink) ¬ MP (member)
36 Idea revealed before very serious [sort] of poet (5) Q sort DEERE (i)DE(a) ERE (before)
10 Accepted generally high quality once together (5)   ATONE A(ccepted) TONE (generally high quality)
25 [Trap] individual twice, absolutely with a single thought (8) U trap ONE-IDEA’D ONE+I (individual twice) DEAD (absolutely)
11 Try again – I didn’t catch that, stuck in the back (6)   REHEAR EH (I didn’t catch that) in REAR (back)
31 Announce defective [beam], casting no shade (6) I beam NUANCE [ANNOUNCE]* ¬ NO
12 Without my separate [list], temporary changes make a fair allocation (7) Z list PRORATE [TEMPORARY ¬ MY]*
32 More than one construction like 5dn? Second letter in it seems unlikely (6)   TMESES [(i)T SEEMS]*
hit counter

 

17 comments on “Inquisitor 1728: Face Trouble by Ifor”

  1. This one was tough, with a whole bundle of obsolete words and meanings used in some beautiful clues. Both the sentence and highlighting stumped me, as I couldn’t make anything coherent from the list of extra words. No help was afforded me by the title either. Total logjam. I spotted the six words GLEN INLET SHALLOW FLUTES HARASSED & BANTER, as all were nicely spaced in the grid (and were of 36 letters as required), but I couldn’t reverse compile these to get six synonyms making a meaningful sentence, so it still meant nothing. The link from the 26 extra words to (yet another) pangram was just far too tenuous a connection for me I’m afraid. So sadly, a DNF recorded by me this week. So near, yet so very far.

    Thanks, as always, to both setter and blogger.

  2. A quick grid fill, and likely words to highlight spotted quickly too, but I wonder if I was alone in floundering on what we supposed to do with the extra words, “primarily associated”. It took several days to twig that we were looking for letters to add to the beginning of each, and even then I failed to get them all, resorting to Google to get the final “sentence”. Too tricky really then for me, but I enjoyed the bits I did manage to do properly.

  3. All thanks to Ifor and HG. Very slow progress here — I got distracted by real life and came back to this one after several days. A major obstacle was disbelief that we could be facing another pangram so soon after Ella Minnow Pea! None of the “perfect” 26-letter examples are even slightly memorable, but I eventually got there from CWM. After which, alas, the next IQ was waiting and I gave up after finding GLEN in the grid. Some idiot had carelessly pencilled in 6D as the nonsensical REDAAL, and the resulting INLAT rang no bells. Must try harder.

    Brilliant stuff though.

  4. Splendid puzzle with great clues, a real pleasure.
    I feel a bit sorry for Ifor, as the editor strangely decided to publish two pangrams in a row.

  5. The three constructions not in Chambers are S-bend, K-ration, and R-value. Chambers does have F-bomb. (All of these constructions are listed under the entry for their leading letter, except for O-ring, which you can find between Orimulsion and oriole.)

  6. Not sure if I’d have gone anywhere had it not followed so soon after last week’s…could hardly identify any of the correct letters even once I had most of the missing words, and couldn’t see anything else sensible emerging in the few I did have. Fortunately I remembered that there were some awkward 26 letter pangrams out there, so googled a list on the off-chance I could apply one of them here.

  7. A very satisfying crossword, and a most enjoyable endgame.

    When I completed the grid I had 24 of the 26 words from which I hoped to identify many of the corresponding letters. However, several of the words had alternative associated letters (like W or Z for particle and S or U for bend), and, not surprisingly, some letters could be associated with more than one word. At that point I had barely half of the letters that I needed.

    I suspected that the required pangrammatic sentence might be documented online somewhere, but I knew I would enjoy the endgame much more if I could work it out. Looking at what I had, and favouring W over Z for the particle, I visualised CWM at the start, followed by FJORD, with QUIZ possibly at the end, and I considered these to be confirmed when I found synonyms for them in the grid. That was as much as I could work out, though.

    I looked up ‘pangram’ in Wikipedia, and I was directed straight to the article where the required sentence was spelled out, and I could at last complete the puzzle. What a crazy ‘sentence’, but it just about makes sense.

    Thanks to Ifor and HolyGhost.

  8. I thought this was OK, but I was a bit underwhelmed by the pangram – which I had come across in my research for Ella Minnow Pea. I’m grateful to HG for explaining LAR – as a sailor I really should have known about larboard – and Avogadro – I had the answer for ages but ORD had escaped me. I thought the best bit was the explanation of the title! Thanks to Ifor – I presume CWM is in his native language – and HG.

  9. I’m also struggling to see a sentence, and to understand the instruction about ‘six groups’ in the grid – rather than six words. Not that I got close to that point: I’m one of those who, having listed all the words (or almost all; there were a couple I couldn’t parse), simply couldn’t see what their ‘primary association’ might be. Many of them are news to me.

    Thanks to Ifor and HG

  10. My thanks to those who commented, and of course to HG for his thorough exposition and kind remarks.

    As to the (non?)sentence, I took my cue from an elderly Guinness book (in the days when it had a words and language section) wherein this is given as a sentence and a “translation” provided. I can see some will take a different view; I think it comes down to whether the initial nouns can be seen as adjectival, as in (say) “river valley side”. I hope no-one in the other camp found that affected their arrival at a solution.

  11. I couldn’t finish this. There were alternates for at least two of the words you could have had col for cwm and terrace for bank.

  12. Thanks Ifor — very satisfying and clever! and thanks to HG for the helpful explanations — especially our friend LAR which I had parsed as L,AR but could crack AR. Out of curiosity, what’s the definition for 15a (BE,AMENDS) – I’m sure it’s staring at me… but… I’m blind. thanks!

Comments are closed.