Independent 11,515 by Filbert

This felt like a ‘softer’ Filbert today without the various obscure synonyms which we normally expect from this setter. For that reason, we found this one more enjoyable.

It’s still Joyce blogging today but if there are any omissions or typos, I can blame Bert for not checking things through properly.

 picture of the completed grid

ACROSS
1. Sil’s come to resolve grammatical error (8)
SOLECISM

An anagram (‘to resolve’) of SIL’S COME

5. Tune only on jingle? (6)
ADJUST

JUST (only) on AD (jingle?)

10. Former agent brought back, I thought for testing (15)
EXPERIMENTATION

EX (former) +REP (agent) reversed or ‘brought back’ + I MENTATION (thought). Neither of us had come across ‘mentation’ before.

11. Minimal bow wave finally swelling (4)
NODE

NOD (minimal bow) E (final letter of wave)

12. Medicine that hurts patient in a bag on the bed (10)
PILLOWCASE

PILL (medicine) OW (that hurts) CASE (patient)

15. Tree surgeons on vacation without a plan (7)
MAPLESS

MAPLE (tree) SurgeonS (without the middle letters or ‘on vacation’). Another word we had to check although the meaning was obvious.

16. Devil in heaven unlikely to be warm enough? (6)
SKIMPY

IMP (devil) in SKY (heaven)

17. Big star back on stage (6)
LEGEND

END (back) on LEG (stage)

19. Pat‘s year in the bar wasted (2,5)
BY HEART

Y (year) in an anagram (‘wasted’) of THE BAR. We weren’t totally happy about BY HEART = PAT although you could justify it by saying ‘off pat’ or ‘off by heart’. However, ‘PAT’ is a synonym in Chambers for ‘BY HEART’.

21. Military camp declared strength, lengthening column (10)
STALAGMITE

STALAG (military camp) + a homophone (‘declared’) of MIGHT (strength)

22. A bit, or not a bit (4)
ZERO

Double definition

24. Turning to AI, teen derided physical work (4,4,7)
DEAD TREE EDITION

An anagram (‘turning’) of TO AI TEEN DERIDED

26. Aunt or niece lodges without any rent (6)
UNTORN

Hidden or ‘lodges’ in aUNT OR Niece

27. Highlander looks whiter with bare knees outside (8)
NEPALESE

PALES (looks whiter) with kNEEs (middle letters only or ‘bare’) outside

DOWN
1. Tough bit of breast from small bird that’s iffy (7)
STERNUM

S (small) TERN (bird) UM (that’s iffy)

2. Flying insects ruined Elsa’s first pedalo trip (11)
LEPIDOPTERA

An anagram (‘ruined’) of E (first letter of Elsa) PEDALO TRIP

3. Take heart from fellow engineers (4)
CORE

CO (fellow as in co-worker) RE (engineers)

4. Males apparently dressed smartly for important meetings (7)
SUMMITS

MM (males) in SUITS (apparently dressed smartly)

6. Spooner’s married the woman he sees as a burden (4-6)
DEAD-WEIGHT

A spoonerism of WED DATE (‘married the woman he sees’)

7. Wearing uniform upset fellow’s employer (3)
UNI

A reversal (‘upset’) of IN (wearing) U (uniform)

8. Subtle shade included by lighting engineer (5)
TINGE

Hidden or ‘included’ in lighTING Engineers

9. Old German‘s inclinations (6)
ANGLES

Double definition

13. Given a list of countries, perhaps sort by capitals? (11)
ALPHABETISE

A cryptic definition where ‘capitals’ could represent the capital city or the initial capital letter of the country

14. Patron of restaurant turned up between 4 (10)
BENEFACTOR

A reversal (‘turned up’) of CAFE (restaurant) between BEN and TOR (‘summits’ – 4d)

18. Girl stops running and starts to encourage laggers (6)
DAMSEL

DAMS (stops running) and initial letters or ‘starts’ to Encourage Laggers

19. Make oneself available one March, and before (2,5)
BE THERE

BETH (as in BETH March from Little Women) ERE (before)

20. Tar wanting a cat, to whip (7)
TROUNCE

TaR (missing or ‘wanting’ ‘a’) OUNCE (cat)

21. Ascetic‘s not happy with unfinished shack (5)
SADHU

SAD (not happy) HUt (shack) missing last letter or ‘unfinished’

23. Bird that could be a parrot mother keeps at home (4)
MINA

MA (mother) around or ‘keeping’ IN (at home)

25. Key ring lost by member of choir (3)
ALT

ALTo (member of choir) with ‘o’ (ring) missing or ‘lost’

 

17 comments on “Independent 11,515 by Filbert”

  1. Sofamore

    My toppies today are definitions – ‘without a plan,’ ‘unlikely to be warm enough’, ‘physical work’ and the very clever ‘bit but not a bit’. Failed to parse ALPHABETISE so thanks to B&J. Don’t like it much. Also failed 19d thinking 1 MTH (I’m there) for Beth March. Maybe the misdirection was intended. So, not so soft for me today but an excellent puzzle as always. Thanks.

  2. Tatrasman

    I agree this was comparatively easy for Filbert. I felt uneasy about UNI and ALPHABETISE, but always tell myself “if it works, it’s almost certainly right”, and have yet to come unstuck. Thanks Filbert and Joyce.

  3. FrankieG

    All these years thinking the “sole” in SOLECISM meant a one-off mistake – like a hapax legomenon – until looking up the etymology today.
    ‘…from Ancient Greek soloikismos from soloikos, “speaking incorrectly”, from Soloi, an ancient Athenian colony in Cilicia whose inhabitants spoke a dialect regarded by Athenians as a corrupted and barbarous form of Attic Greek.’ – tilt.
    Thanks F & B&J

  4. copmus

    Yes , not as tough as he can be but enjoyable all the same.I liked the Spooner.
    Thanks all

  5. KVa

    Thanks, Filbert and B&J!
    Liked STALAGMITE, CORE and SUMMITS.

  6. Bodger

    Thanks. I had ALPHABETISE in mind for ages, but couldn’t parse it as I couldn’t see it as a CD. Eventually bunged it in but it didn’t feel satisfying. On reflection, that might be a fault on my part. Like Sofamore @1 I had “I MTH ERE” until crossers ruled it out.

    I liked DEAD WEIGHT, STALAGMITE and the combination of SUMMITS and BENEFACTOR. ZERO stalled me for a good while (too many options) but was worth the wait when it finally dropped.

  7. TFO

    Thanks both. Agreed, this was easier for this setter, but I made it difficult by not correctly remembering the spelling for LEPIDOPTERA. Like others, ALPHABETISE hung around as I was looking for more substance in the clue, and I concur BENEFACTOR was a stand-out, and it took a while for me to get to grips with an apparently incomplete wordplay, which reminded me of a question my grandpa used to ask….”what is the difference between a duck?”

  8. Petert

    I really like the feeling when you arrive at the answer through the wordplay and then you see the definition, so NEPALESE and STALAGMITE were my favourites today.
    Thanks both or all three.

  9. Coot

    TFO @ 7 ….to which our answer always used to be “one of its legs is both the same”

    I very much enjoyed this puzzle and agree that BENEFACTOR was the stand-out clue. Thanks Filbert and B&J.

  10. TFO

    Coot@9 I suspected it was not an original!

  11. Pete HA3

    Typical Filbert for me. Half goes in, get stuck, come here and still scratching my head. DEAD TREE EDITION? Just three random words?

  12. flashling

    @11 Pete, no, not really. When the Indy used to have a physical edition there was often a crossword discrepancy between the paper and website, the actual paper was often referred to as the Dead Tree Edition

  13. Tony Santucci

    Thanks Filbert, I always enjoy your crosswords with TROUNCE, DEAD TREE EDITION, and BENEFACTOR being my favourites today. Thanks B&J for the blog.

  14. Pete HA3

    @12 flashling. Thank you. Now I see it. I wouldn’t have known the reference, but I was hung up on work=effort.

  15. Alliacol

    I thought the surfaces in some of these were inspired. 16A, 19A, 24A, 27A, 2D, 21D. I don’t think I’ve ever laughed so much while doing a crossword. Thanks to Filbert and Joyce!

  16. allan_c

    Great stuff and nothing too difficult. We liked TROUNCE (not seen many snow leopards in Crosswordland lately), PILLOWCASE and BENEFACTOR among others.
    FrankieG@3: SOLECISM is nevertheless often used to mean a mistake or faux pas of any sort – even respected authors such as Sir Walter Scott are guily of such (ahem!) solecisms.
    Thanks, Filbert and B&J.

  17. h.eckler

    Read up the unches in column 14 and you get SORRY SOS. Just a coincidence?

Comments are closed.